Best Bed-in-a-Box Mattresses

Updated on August 8, 2020 While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about our affiliate program here.
 

Nearly everything can be bought online these days. A mattress is no different, over the last decade bed-in-a-box mattresses have exploded in the mattress industry. Whatever your preference, you will likely be able to find a mattress of your liking in a bed-in-a-box model. There’s no question that the convenience of a bed-in-a-box mattress can’t be beat, but you may be wondering if the quality is up to par. Through extensive testing, our team has found that bed-in-a-box mattresses are just as if not more comfortable and durable than traditional mattresses. Choosing a bed-in-a-box mattress is a convenient way to get a quality mattress that fits your needs.

With so many bed-in-a-box mattresses to choose from it can be difficult to decide on the mattress that is best for you. To help, our expert team has put together a list of our top picks and created a buying guide explaining the ins and outs of a bed-in-a-box mattress.

ManufacturerModelMattress TypeFirmnessPrice (Queen)
Signature
Hybrid
3 choices:
Soft (4), Medium (6), Firm (7-8)
$949
Puffy MattressMemory FoamMedium (5)$1,150
Nectar MattressMemory FoamMedium Firm (6.5)$799
MintMemory FoamMedium Firm (6)$995
Casper MattressMemory FoamMedium (5)$1,095
Leesa HybridHybridMedium (6)$1,699
The WinkBedHybrid4 choices:
Soft (4), Medium (6), Firm (7-8), Plus (8)
$1,599
 

Brooklyn Bedding Signature

Why We Like it

  • A gel-infused foam helps regulate temperature and resist heat buildup
  • TitanFlex foam cushions pressure points
  • Coils and Energex foam provide bound and prevent excess sinking feeling
  • 120-night trial with no fees for returns, shipping or restocking

Brooklyn Bedding Logo

Brooklyn Bedding Signature

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress was reengineered from its original model in 2018 and is constructed of three layers. Titanflex foam works to cushion pressure points and reduce joint and muscle pain while advanced cooling technologies resist heat buildup and regulate body temperature.

This hybrid features a two-inch layer of TitanFlex foam designed to have the contouring features of memory foam with the responsiveness of latex. The Brooklyn Signature can be purchased in a soft, medium, or firm style.

The Brooklyn Signature comes with a 120-night risk-free trial, during which you can return your mattress at no cost. The company does require that you keep the mattress for at least 30 nights before initiating a return. If at any time after the 30 nights you would like to return the mattress for any reason, you can do so for a full refund of the purchase price. This model is also covered under a 10-year warranty that accounts for defects in materials and manufacturing. Brooklyn Bedding will repair or replace a mattress confirmed to be defective.

 

Puffy Mattress

Why We Like it

  • Deep contouring from 2” gel-infused memory foam
  • Significant motion isolation
  • Lifetime full replacement warranty, 101-night sleep trial, free returns and shipping

The Puffy mattress is a simply designed supportive all-foam mattress. It maximizes comfort with a thick layer of gel-infused memory foam. Great for temperature regulation, the Puffy mattress also includes a layer of ClimateComfort foam designed to keep the mattress at a consistent temperature regardless of outside factors.

The Puffy mattress is constructed with two inches of gel-infused memory foam, a middle layer of two inches of ClimateComfort polyfoam for temperature consistency, and a third layer of six inches of support polyfoam for maximum comfort. The Puffy is a medium firmness falling at a 5-5.5 on the firmness scale.

The Puffy mattress is only available on the Puffy website and offers free shipping within the contiguous United States.

Puffy offers a 101-night sleep trial and does not have a required break-in period. Lastly, Puffy offers a lifetime warranty replacing your mattress if your mattress is defective in its construction or craftsmanship.

 

Nectar Mattress

Why We Like it

  • Excellent price point for gel-infused memory foam mattress
  • Sleeps cooler than many memory foam options
  • 365-night sleep trial

Nectar logo

Nectar Mattress

Created in 2017, the Nectar mattress quickly became one of the most popular bed-in-a-box mattresses on the market. Known for its quality and affordability, Nectar has made quality sleep products more accessible than other brands on the market.

The Nectar mattress is composed of four foam layers. The cover of the mattress is composed of Tencel, an eco-friendly fabric made from the wood pulp of trees grown on tree farms. The Nectar mattress is available in one firmness option, measuring in at a medium firm 6.5 on the firmness scale.

Nectar offers a lifetime warranty and a lengthy 365-night sleep trial with a required 30-night break-in period. If you choose not to keep the mattress after 30 nights but before 365 nights, you will be eligible for a full refund of the price of the mattress. Nectar will also help arrange for the disposal or donation of the mattress you are returning.

 

Tuft & Needle Mint

Why We Like it

  • Graphite and ceramic gel in the foam fight heat retention
  • 5 total inches of pressure-relieving adaptive foam
  • Reinforced perimeter for edge support
  • 10-year warranty covering defects in materials or manufacturing

Tuft & Needle

Tuft and Needle is one of the most recognized mattress brands on the market. As part of a quest to improve their already successful original mattress, Tuft & Needle launched the Mint Mattress. For customers interested in an all-foam mattress that blends bounce and contouring and that provides excellent comfort from its medium-firm feel, the Tuft & Needle Mint is a great option to consider.

The Mint is similar to the original Tuft & Needle mattress but adds an additional transition foam layer and boasts features meant to boost the responsiveness, edge support, and cooling properties of the mattress. The Mint is made with a combination of micro polyamide and polyester. It has a medium firmness level and lands at a 6 on the firmness scale.

Tuft and Needle offers a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year limited warranty for the Mint mattress. If you decide to return your mattress within the 100-night sleep trial Tuft and Needle will coordinate pick-up or find a location for the mattress to be donated.

 

Casper Mattress

Why We Like it

  • Excellent pressure relief
  • Bolstered support from zoned transition layer
  • Blend of contour and bounce
  • 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year limited warranty covering defects in materials and workmanship

Casper

The Casper Mattress

Established in 2014, Casper was one of the first mattress companies to offer a bed-in-a-box model. Casper’s savvy marketing and top of the line customer service helped the brand quickly rise as an industry leader. Casper has also opened brick-and-mortar stores in major cities around the US and can be found in most Target stores.

The Casper mattress is constructed of four layers of high density, premium foam. With a new foam framework that provides zoned support, the Casper mattress contours around pressure points to provide full-body support and spinal alignment. The Casper mattress is available in one firmness level, which is medium measuring in at a 5 on the firmness scale.

Casper offers a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year limited warranty. The warranty covers defects in construction or materials. If you decide that the mattress isn’t right for you within the 100-night sleep trial, Casper will coordinate pick-up and return details for your mattress. Shipping is free within the contiguous US. If you are interested in additional services, Casper offers in-home delivery and set up for $149.

 

Leesa Hybrid

Why We Like it

  • Specialty polyfoam and memory foam for notable contouring
  • Pocketed coils permit airflow and add bounce
  • Certified B-corp that makes donations of mattresses as part of social mission
  • 100-night sleep trial and 10-year limited warranty during which Leesa will repair or replace a mattress with qualified defects

Leesa Hybrid mattress

The Leesa Hybrid is a great option for consumers who want the comfort of a foam mattress along with the resilient support of innersprings. Leesa is committed to delivering high-quality materials, social and environmental responsibility, customer service, and convenience to their customers.

The Leesa Hybrid mattress is made up of five layers. The top three layers are foam, beginning with ventilated foam for airflow and temperature regulation. Next is a memory foam layer for pressure relief on muscles and joints, then an unperforated foam transitions into the innerspring layer. Lastly, an additional layer of foam serves as a base for the coils and helps diminish sound and motion transfer. The Leesa Hybrid is available in one firmness level, which measures 6 on the firmness scale.

Leesa ships for free and can be found online on the Leesa website, Amazon, West Elm, or Pottery Barn. For an additional charge, in-home delivery is available for $150. Leesa offers a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year limited warranty. If you decide to return your mattress within the 100-night trial, you will be charged a $49 fee and refunded the remaining price of the mattress.

 

The WinkBed

Why We Like it

  • Coil-on-coil design for bounce and contouring
  • Gel-infused foam in euro-top adds pressure relief
  • 120-night sleep trial and a lifetime that covers defects in materials and manufacturing

Winkbed

The WinkBed is a hybrid mattress featuring a coil-on-coil design for bounce and contouring with a gel-infused foam that provides comfort and pressure relief. The WinkBed is designed to accommodate various types of sleepers offering multiple levels of firmness, including one specifically designed for heavier sleepers.

Winkbed comes is offered in all traditional sizes and is constructed of six layers for maximum comfort. The mattress includes two inches of support foam, a layer of pocket innerspring coils, a layer of cotton padding, 2.4 inches of additional innerspring coils, one inch of gel-infused foam, and one inch of softer foam. The Winkbed can be purchased in three different firmness levels. Each size can be ordered in a soft 4, a medium 6, or a firm 7-8 level.

The Winkbed can only be purchased online on WinkBed’s website or Amazon. Shipping is free and orders typically arrive in 7-14 business days. If you are compelled, Winkbed offers a white glove delivery for a $99 fee and a removal service for your old mattress for a total of $159. Winkbed offers a 101-night sleep trial and a 10-year limited warranty.

 

Best Bed in a Box Mattresses: Buyer’s Guide 

To help you decide which bed-in-a-box mattress is best for you, we’ve created the buying guide below. We go in-depth on types of bed-in-a-box mattresses, features to consider, construction ins and outs, purchasing tips, and unboxing directions. Shopping can seem daunting with so many bed-in-a-box mattresses on the market, but these tips will help you find the perfect fit.

Types of Bed in a Box Mattresses 

Bed-in-a-box mattresses come in three different mattress styles. Use the table below to differentiate the mattress types and find the best mattress for your needs.

Foam
Latex
Hybrid
Foam

Memory foam, also known as Viscoelastic foam, is a highly responsive foam that compresses where weight is applied and becomes softer as it heats up. As the body warms up memory foam mattresses conform offering a deep hugging sensation.

Average Price:

$800 – $1,200

Pros:
  • Excellent motion isolation
  • Excellent contouring
  • Durable (6-8 years)
  • Comfortable and supportive
Cons:
  • Poor temperature regulation
  • Can provide too much “hug”
  • Limited edge support
Latex

Latex mattresses may contain natural latex, synthetic latex, or blended latex. Latex beds are naturally elastic, accommodating pressure points while keeping a bouncy feel.

Average Price:

$1,000-$2,000

Pros:
  • Above average durability (8-10 years)
  • Good temperature regulation
  • Quiet
  • Above average contouring to support side sleepers
Cons:
  • High price point
  • Could be a concern for people with latex allergies
  • More motion transfer than foam
Hybrid

Hybrid mattresses combine an innerspring coil support core with a robust comfort system typically composed of latex, memory foam, and/or specialty polyfoam.

Average Price:

$1,000-$1,500

Pros:
  • Both responsive and conforming
  • Good motion isolation
  • Quiet
  • Good airflow and temperature regulation
Cons:
  • Higher price point
  • Because they are relatively new to the market, durability is not known
 

What Features Should You Look For in a Bed-in-a-Box?

The bed-in-a-box industry has grown rapidly over the last decade. There are hundreds of reviews and mattresses to sift through. In order to ensure you find the best bed-in-a-box mattress for your needs, it’s important to know what features to look for.

  • Size: Typically brands offer a variety of mattress sizes. Queen is the most popular size, but may not be the best choice for you. Decide what size mattress you are interested in based on personal preference and allotted space in your bedroom. Mattress prices vary based on size.
  • Contouring: Mattress contouring refers to the way a mattress conforms to the body. Innerspring mattresses tend to conform to the body quickly and maintain shape after a person gets up from bed compared, while memory foam mattresses that are slower to conform and revert back to their original shape.  
  • Firmness: Firmness is one of the most important features for buyers to look at when deciding on a mattress. Firmness refers to how soft or firm a mattress feels. The firmness scale ranges from extra soft to extra firm on a scale of 1 through 10. Certain levels of firmness are ideal for different types of sleepers, but it ultimately comes down to personal preference. 
  • Motion Isolation: Motion isolation is the effectiveness a mattress has to limit motion transfer. This is especially important for couples and light sleepers. Light sleepers can experience major sleep disturbances if their partner moves throughout the night on a mattress with poor motion isolation. 
  • Temperature Regulation: Different mattress models are tailored to regulate temperature. Some mattresses are best for keeping you cool, while others retain heat.
  • Edge Support: Edge support measures the amount of resistance a mattress provides around its edges. Edge support prevents the edges of your mattress from sagging so that your body doesn’t fall towards the outside of the mattress. Edge support also provides a strong surface to allow you to sit comfortably on the side of the bed. 
  • Sleep Trial Offering: Purchasing a mattress is a big decision. Because most bed-in-a-box mattresses are ordered online, many consumers rely on online reviews and word of mouth to make their decision. Most companies offer sleep trials to ensure you are happy with your purchase. 
  • Warranties: For reasons similar to wanting a sleep trial, warranties are an important feature offered by mattress companies. Warranties protect you financially from potential issues and vary from brand to brand. 
  • Delivery Options: Most bed-in-a-box brands offer at home or in-store pick-up for your mattress. Delivery fees vary. 

Key Considerations When Choosing a New Bed in a Box Mattress 

Personal preference plays a large role in choosing the best bed-in-a-box mattress for you. Below are various factors that you should consider when narrowing down your mattress choices. 

  • Price: Setting a budget is a great place to start your mattress search. Bed-in-a-box models can range from under $500 to over $2,000. Setting price range filters on your search is a good way to initially narrow down your options. Check out our best mattresses for the money guide for insight on the best-valued mattresses.  
  • Sleep Needs: Before beginning your mattress search, take the time to identify your sleep needs and preferences. Different types of mattresses are better for temperature regulation, couples, and other sleep preferences. Identifying these needs and prioritizing your must-have features will save you time from searching through mattresses that don’t align with your needs. 
  • Sleeping Style: Depending on your sleeping style, certain mattresses may be best for you. Common sleep positions include: back, side, stomach, and combination. Refer to our best mattresses for side, back, and stomach sleepers pages to see what types of mattresses are best for you. 
  • Style Preference: One way to differentiate mattresses is through firmness. Firmness is a way of describing the feel of a mattress specifically in terms of comfort. Firmness is measured on scaled from 1 to 10 and ranges from “extra soft” to “extra firm.” Many brands offer different models with different firmness levels.
  • Customer Reviews: Online customer reviews and forums are a great way to get unbiased information from fellow consumers. Although mattress brands typically offer sleep trials and returns, returning bulky items can be a hassle. Reading reviews is a good way to get a mattress that suits you on the first try. 

How is a Bed-in-a-Box Made? 

When bed-in-a-box mattresses first entered the mattress industry many consumers thought the concept was too good to be true. For decades, maneuvering a large awkward mattress into your bedroom was just a part of life. So how do they fit high-quality mattresses into a box that will show up to your doorstep?

Bed in the box mattresses use advanced technology to compress materials. Once the mattress is flattened, it’s rolled or folded into a size that can be easily placed into a box for shipping. For protection, most mattresses will be covered in a plastic casing and then placed in a box. Once a mattress is delivered to your home, all you have to do is bring the mattress to your desired room location, unbox the mattress, and allow it to expand. On average mattresses take 24 to 48 hours to fully decompress and will be at their full potential 30 days after your initial unboxing.

Select brands have brick-and-mortar stores with a selection of mattresses. If you opt for online shopping you can expect your mattress to be delivered in 2-14 business days.

How to Buy a Bed-in-a-Box 

After you’ve done your research and decide which bed-in-a-box is best for you the purchasing process is simple. Bed-in-a-box mattresses can be bought online or at select stores.

  • Online: Purchasing a mattress online is the most convenient way to buy a mattress. Buying online makes comparison shopping simple, as you can view various mattress companies’ websites at one time. Skipping the trip to mattress stores also allows you to avoid notoriously pushy mattress salespeople. 
  • In-Store: Many bed-in-a-box brands have brick-and-mortar stores in major cities throughout the United States. Select brands can also be found in various retail stores such as Target or Macy’s Home. Shopping in-store gives you an opportunity to try out mattresses first hand, take advantage of knowledgeable employees, and take home your mattress the day of purchase.

Unboxing a Bed in a Box 

The final step before enjoying your bed-in-a-box mattress is unboxing. Your mattress will arrive at your door in a large rectangular box. Inside the box will be your mattress rolled up and covered in plastic packaging. First, remove your mattress from the box and then carefully cut the plastic away. Some mattresses are tightly wrapped, so be sure to take your time cutting away the plastic making sure you don’t puncture the mattress itself. Once you’ve removed the plastic casing, unroll your mattress to let it air out and decompress.

Decompression times vary from brand to brand. During this stage, your mattress may off-gas a bit, and then expand to its final shape. Your mattress should be functional after no more than 48 hours. Brands typically give their mattresses 30 days to be at their full potential, and some brands require customers to use their mattresses for at least 30 days before initiating a return. Once your mattress is decompressed, put on some sheets and enjoy a good night’s sleep!

 

Top picks

1Brooklyn Bedding Signature$949
2Puffy Mattress$1,150
3Nectar Mattress$799
4Tuft & Needle Mint$995
5Casper Mattress$1,095
6Leesa Hybrid$1,699
7WinkBed$1,599
*Prices without discount/promo applied.
Click for best price.