Best ComfortersUpdated on January 11, 2020 While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about our affiliate program here.
A comforter is a treasured piece of bedding. It plays an essential role in making a bed feel part of a cozy den, a place where you can relax and rest even during the coldest and darkest days of winter.
While any comforter can add a layer of warmth, not all comforters are created equal. For example, some deliver more heat, have a softer feel, offer more breathability, or have more style. For this reason, finding the right comforter for you can seem like an arduous task.
In this guide, we’ll highlight the best comforters that we’ve found through our research, and we’ll tell you about why they made the cut. In addition, we’ll go over the most important information for you to be aware of when looking for a new comforter.
Our Top Picks
|Down Duvet Insert||85% white goose down, 15% down and feather fibers||Lightweight or All-Season (750 fill power) option, Fill complies with Responsible Down Standard||$239-449|
|Cloud Comforter||Eco-Fiber (Synthetic)||Lofty fill made with recycled plastics, Natural Eucalyptus-based cover material||$130-200|
|Arcadia Duvet||Down Alternative||Choose between Medium and Heavy warmth, 100% cotton cover with 330 thread count and sateen weave||$245-410|
|Down Alternative Comforter||Down Alternative||Standout price-to-warmth ratio, Baffle box sewing||$33.90|
|Wool Comforter||Eco-Wool||Humanely produced Eco-Wool fill, Naturally moisture-wicking||$399-549|
Parachute Down Duvet Insert
European white goose down forms 85% of the fill for the Parachute Down Duvet Insert. The other 15% is a mixture of down and feather fibers. All of the material is produced in accordance with the Responsible Down Standard (RDS), a certification that upholds sustainable and ethical production practices.
Baffle-box sewing provides more breathing room for the down, letting it better hold its loft. Double-stitched seams reinforce this stitching.
The cover is 100% cotton with a sateen weave. It is only available in the standard white and is designed to be used with a duvet cover.
- 750 fill power for serious warmth
- Choice of All-Season or Lightweight options
- Responsible Down Standard certified fill
- 100% cotton shell with smooth sateen weave
The duvet is available in 3 sizes: Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, and King/Cal King.
You can choose either a Lightweight or All-Season option. Both have a fill power of 750. The Lightweight duvet is thinner, which means that this down is more compressed and less insulating. This option is best for people who run hot or live in warmer climates.
The All-Season version is loftier and fluffier and is a better choice for cold climates or people who want the warmest duvet possible.
The duvet insert can be machine-washed and dried on low or delicate settings.
The price ranges from $239 to $449 depending on the size and density (Lightweight or All-Season).
You have 60 days to try out the duvet with the option to return it for a full refund.
Parachute offers a 5-year warranty on this duvet insert.
- Significant fill power and warmth
- Two month no-risk trial
- Premium RDS-certified down
- Soft and smooth sateen shell
- Higher price point
- Only one color; best used with a duvet cover
Buffy Cloud Comforter
In the Buffy Comforter, both the fill and shell utilize materials that make this comforter distinct.
The fill is eco-fiber, a polyester synthetic produced with recycled plastic bottles. On average, 50 bottles are recycled in each comforter.
The cover is made with rayon derived from the eucalyptus plant and has a thread count of 300. These fibers are soft and breathable for use in all seasons.
- Eco-conscious fill made with recycled plastics
- Eucalyptus-based cover is light and soft
- Breathable materials prevent overheating
Three sizes are available: Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, King/Cal King.
The Buffy comforter is warm but not overpoweringly so. It has lofty fill but will not have the same insulating power as down. Its materials are breathable, so this is a top choice for people who tend to sleep hot or who live in climates with mild winters.
Buffy recommends dry cleaning this comforter. Washing and drying at home can damage the comforter. It can be washed in a larger, commercial washing machine and line-dried.
The Buffy Comforter costs between $130 and $200 depending on the size.
You can try the Buffy Comforter at home for 30 nights.
There is no standard warranty. After the 30-day sleep trial, manufacturing defects may be covered on a case-by-case basis.
- Production of eco-conscious fill recycles plastics and reduces water consumption
- Eucalyptus-rayon shell is soft and breathable
- Perfect for hot sleepers or warmer climates
- May lack warmth for very cold climates
- No defined warranty
Sferra Arcadia Duvet
The Sferra Arcadia Duvet uses a down alternative fill called Pluma-fil. This synthetic is light and soft but with substantial heating power. Baffle-box construction preserves loft and warmth.
The shell is 100% cotton with a thread count of 330. A sateen weave provides a smoother and softer feel. It can be used as-is but is designed to be placed inside a duvet cover. Corner loops hold it securely in place inside a cover.
- High-performance and hypoallergenic synthetic fill
- 330 thread count cotton shell with sateen weave
- Choose from two warmth options (Medium or Heavy) based on your needs
This duvet comes in Twin, Queen, and King sizes.
Select from either a Medium or Heavy density depending your preference. People who live in mild-to-warm climates may prefer the Medium. The Heavy comforter works better for people who run cold or need extra insulation during a colder winter.
This comforter can be machine-washed and dried.
The price ranges from $245-$410 depending on the size and thickness option.
Sferra will accept returns within 30 days if the duvet is still in its original condition and has the original packaging.
There is no clearly stated warranty policy listed by Sferra.
- Hypoallergenic yet plush down alternative
- Medium and Heavy warmth choices to suit your needs
- High thread count 100% cotton shell
- Only available in white; goes best with duvet cover
- No warranty and more restrictive sleep trial
- Higher than average price for synthetic material
Hanna Kay Down Alternative Comforter
The Hanna Kay Down Alternative comforter is made with 100% polyester in both the fill and shell.
The fill is microfiber — a type of brushed polyester — that has a soft feel for plushness and warmth. 77 ounces of this synthetic fill is used in each comforter and is held in place with baffle-box sewing.
The cover is 100% polyester. Though less breathable than cotton, it is stretchy and easy to wash and maintain.
- Microfiber fill is cozy and warm enough for mild climates
- Baffle-box construction to preserve loft
- Hypoallergenic and easy to wash
This comforter is currently only available in Queen size.
Though nowhere near as warm as a material like down, the Hanna Kay Down Alternative Comforter can provide sufficient insulation for most seasons and climates. In colder places it can be layered with other blankets for extra warmth.
100% polyester construction makes the Hanna Kay comforter a breeze to clean. It can be machine-washed and dried.
With a price point around $30 for a Queen, this comforter is a tremendous value and affordable even to shoppers with extremely tight budgets.
If purchased on Amazon, you have a 30-day return window.
No specific warranty terms are listed by Hanna Kay.
- Low price delivers incredible warmth-to-cost ratio
- Easy to clean and hypoallergenic
- Softness and warmth from 77 ounces of microfiber fill
- Limited insulating power for colder climates
- Only presently available in Queen size
- No long-term warranty
PlushBeds Wool Comforter
The fill of the PlushBeds comforter is 100% Eco-wool that is humanely-produced and free of dyes and chemicals that can alter the material’s composition.
The shell is 100% cotton with a smooth sateen weave. Each comforter is tufted and stitched by hand.
- Insulating and breathable, wool fill is all-season ready
- Sustainably produced fill made without fillers or allergens
- Soft and smooth cover made with 100% cotton
The comforter comes in 3 sizes: Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, and King/Cal King.
Wool is naturally temperature regulating. When it’s cold, it insulates and holds in heat. But if you start to overheat and sweat, it quickly wicks moisture away and permits cooling airflow. As a result, this comforter can be used year-round in virtually any climate.
This comforter requires careful cleaning. PlushBeds only recommends spot cleaning with mild detergent and then air-drying.
The price range for the PlushBeds comforter is from $399 to $549 depending on the size.
There is no trial period, and returns are not accepted for the PlushBeds comforter.
No warranty is offered for this product. Pros Cons Pros
- Premium wool delivers comfort and heat regulation
- 100% cotton cover adds softness and enhances breathability
- Difficult to clean without risking damage to materials
- No warranty or sleep trial
What You Need to Know When You’re Buying A Comforter
It’s natural to want to be a savvy shopper who can find the best product and price. This guide covers all that you need to know so that you can shop for a new comforter with confidence.
A comforter should cover your entire bed. In most cases, the size is clearly labeled, and you only need to buy the one that matches your bed. Sometimes, though, comforters have abnormal dimensions. To be safe, check the listed dimensions to make sure you won’t have any problems.
The inner material is the fill, and this will play a huge role in the performance of your comforter.
Down is the material taken from underneath the feathers of ducks or geese. Pound-for-pound, down provides the most heat. It is extremely light, but its lofted fibers have tremendous insulating power. At the same time, down is soft, so it feels luxurious inside a comforter.
Down can be in the form of feathers or clusters, which are extra-puffy centrally-connected fibers. The higher the percentage of down clusters, the warmer a comforter will typically be.
Goose down is normally loftier and warmer because geese are bigger than ducks. But some goose down comes from younger geese, in which case the insulation difference is minimal. Both goose and duck down produce very warm comforters.
The downsides to down are its cost and potential to cause allergic reactions. Down comforters tend to cost significantly more than other materials, especially synthetics, and some people may have sensitivities to the feathers.
Polyester is the primary synthetic used as a fill material. Not all polyester is the same: the quality and characteristics change based on how it is produced.
Down alternative polyester synthetics are made to mimic the feel of down. Comforters with this fill will be light, lofty, and warm but typically to a lesser degree than actual down. Down alternative fill is hypoallergenic and compared to down, generally much more economical.
More basic polyester that is not intended to feel like down can also be used as a fill material. This material offers limited warmth but can be viable for warmer climates or for people with a very limited budget.
Microfiber is a type of brushed polyester that is thicker and softer and may be used to give a plusher feel to synthetic fill material.
Wool comes from sheep and has many desirable properties. It naturally regulates temperature by offering insulation when it’s cold while pulling away moisture when it’s hot. It resists smells and bacteria and has a cozy feel.
Wool is not as lofty as down or down alternative, so a wool comforter may be heavier in order to offer the same warmth. Wool can be expensive to produce, especially if it is made according to high standards.
High-quality wool avoids using excessive processing with chemical treatments. Many customers prefer wool that is produced in accordance with humane standards for the raising and shearing of sheep.
Cotton does not have the insulating capabilities of many other comforter materials, but it can serve as a good fill material for people who want something breathable and light to use during summer or in warmer areas.
Silk is used as fill in some summer comforters. It is naturally cooling, soft, and light, but it has limited heat retention abilities. Given the high price for silk, a comforter with enough silk fill to use during winter would be too expensive for most shoppers.
In short, fill power describes how warm a comforter is likely to be. It is most helpful when evaluating down comforters although it may be used in describing other types of fill.
Fill power is determined by measuring how much volume is taken up by 1 ounce of down. With more volume and loft, the down will provide greater insulation.
In general, look for a fill power of 600-800. If you live in a colder climate and plan to use the comforter during the winter, err toward the higher end of that range.
Shell / Cover
Another important piece of comforter construction is the cover, also known as the shell.
Cotton is one of the most popular fabrics used for shells. Its softness and breathability makes it an excellent complement to robust fill.
Polyester has less breathability but is inexpensive to produce, light, and easy to wash. Bamboo-rayon is a stretchy, semi-synthetic fabric that wicks away moisture and retains a soft feel. These two materials may be blended together, or polyester may be blended with cotton.
Thin layers of wool can be found in some shells because of wool’s excellent moisture-wicking characteristics. Silk, despite its price, can be valued as a shell material because of its smoothness and cooling properties.
With cotton shells, look for the thread count, which is sometimes abbreviated TC. Thread count describes the density of cotton yarns in that fabric. A denser shell with higher thread count normally will have a softer feel and a longer lifespan.
Not all manufacturers count yarns the same way. Some yarns may be double-counted, which can make a thread count seem extremely high. Typically, a thread count of 300-500 is plenty for a comforter.
How the comforter is sewn can affect its performance and appearance.
In most comforters, the top and bottom of the cover are connected at points in order to create compartments that hold fill in place. “Sewn-through” is when the top and bottom are directly connected, and “baffle box” is when another small piece of fabric is used to connect them.
Sewn-through stitching holds the fill more tightly in place. This decreases how often you need to fluff the comforter but decreases loft and insulation.
If the top and bottom are connected around the edge of the comforter, then it has gusseted stitching. Many customers find gusseted comforters hold their shape and loft more consistently.
Cotton fabrics are a combination of horizontal and vertical yarns. If these are layered one-by-one over each other, it is a percale weave. If the layering places multiple horizontal yarns over a vertical yarn, it is a sateen weave.
Percale has a matte finish while sateen has a noticeably smoother feel and shinier appearance. Sateen is slightly heavier and less breathable than percale.
Cleaning and Care
Proper maintenance and cleaning is important for the performance, longevity, and appearance of your comforter. Care instructions from the manufacturer should always be closely followed to prevent damage to the fill or shell.
Some comforters can be machine-washed and dried; however, in some cases, they may be too large to safely wash in a smaller machine at home. This may require taking it to a commercial laundromat. In some cases, dry cleaning is required.
For small stains on the shell, spot cleaning is more convenient and poses fewer risks to the integrity of the comforter.
In general, down, wool, and silk require more delicate washing than cotton or synthetic fill materials.
Fluffing a comforter is part of its regular care. This helps redistribute any bunched-up fill and in the process adds loft and more evenly-distributed warmth. Down requires more regular fluffing especially if it has baffle-box stitching.
Return Policy and Warranty
Many comforters come with a sleep trial that lets you test it before making a long-term commitment. Ideally, you’ll have at least 30 days to try the comforter risk-free.
Beyond the sleep trial, a warranty can offer protection against faulty materials or workmanship. Although not always available, look for a comforter with a warranty of 3 years or more.