Best Down Comforters

For softness and warmth, a down comforter is a tried-and-true favorite.

Down comes from geese and ducks and is the soft material found underneath their plumage. Down’s unique combination of heavy insulation and a lightweight, cozy feel makes it perfectly suited for keeping you warm all year long.

If you’re shopping for a down comforter, though, all of the options may have left you overwhelmed. Many customers struggle to understand the differences between comforters and to find one that meets their needs and budget.

To avoid these pitfalls, we’ll direct you straight to our top picks for the best down comforters. On top of that, our handy guide presents the important background information that you need to be a smart shopper and to identify the top pick for your bedroom.

Our Top Picks

ManufacturerModelType of DownCoverPrice
Down ComforterDuck down100% cotton$175-197.99
Down Duvet Insert85% white goose down, 15% down and feather fibers100% cotton$239-449
Goose Down Comforter100% white goose down100% cotton$139.95-144.95
Goose Down ComforterGoose down100% cotton$139.95-179.95
Goose Down ComforterGoose down100% polyester, peach-skin fabric$60-120

Pacific Coast Feather Down Comforter

Construction

The Pacific Coast Feather Down Comforter is made with duck down with fill power of 550. The company’s Hyperclean treatment rinses away dirt and potential allergens from the down, reducing sensitivities. Baffle-box construction provides plenty of space for the fill to keep its loft.

The cover is 100% cotton with a thread count of 300. This fabric -- called Barrier Weave -- is tightly-woven to help prevent feathers from escaping. A special border design holds the fill toward the center of the comforter.

Features

  • 550 fill power duck down perfect for warmer climates or hot sleepers
  • Breathable 100% cotton cover
  • Design features help comforter maintain fill and shape

Sizes

The comforter is available in Twin, Queen, and King sizes.

Warmth

With a fill power of 550, this comforter is not designed to get you through the coldest winters. Instead, it is best suited for providing moderate warmth to people who run hot or people who live in mild or warm climates.

Cleaning

Dry cleaning is recommended, but the comforter can be machine-washed if it can comfortably fit in the washer.

Affordability

The price depends on the size and ranges from $175 to $197.99.

Trial Period

Pacific Feather offers a 30 night sleep trial. You can get a full refund during this return window, but you are responsible for any return shipping costs.

Warranty

The comforter comes with a 10-year limited warranty.

Pros
  • Hyperclean down limits allergic reactions
  • Moderate fill power offers warmth without overheating
  • Reinforced cotton cover keeps down from poking through
Cons

Parachute Down Duvet Insert

Construction

The fill of the Parachute Down Duvet Insert is 85% white goose down and 15% down and feather fibers. The loft is preserved with double-stitched, baffle-box sewing.

The down complies with the Responsible Down Standard (RDS). RDS requires that the animals are raised humanely and that the down is produced sustainably.

The shell is made with 100% cotton and has a sateen weave for extra smoothness.

Features

  • Goose down with 750+ fill power
  • Available in 2 models: Lightweight or All-Season
  • Meets high standards of RDS certification
  • Luxurious 100% cotton sateen cover

Sizes

The duvet comes in 3 sizes: Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, and King/Cal King.

Warmth

Parachute offers a Lightweight and an All-Season option. The fill power of 750+ is the same in each, but the All-Season is thicker, which means that it offers more loft and warmth.

The All-Season choice is great for people who need a heavy-duty comforter. The Lightweight is better for hot sleepers or moderate climates.

Cleaning

The comforter can be machine-washed and dried at home.

Affordability

The price is $239 to $449 depending on the model and the size.

Trial Period

Parachute provides 60 days for a risk-free in-home sleep trial.

Warranty

The duvet insert comes with a 5-year warranty.

Pros
  • All-Season model is extra warm for cold climates
  • Lightweight model is perfect for warmer sleepers and climates
  • 60 days to test the duvet in the comfort of your own home
  • Humane and eco-friendly RDS-certified down
Cons

Egyptian Bedding Goose Down Comforter

Construction

The Egyptian Bedding Down Comforter is made with 100% white goose down with a fill power of 750+. The baffle-box construction gives ample space for the fill to stay fluffy for maximum insulation.

The cover is 100% high-end Egyptian cotton with a thread count of 1200. Corner loops hold the comforter in place if used with a duvet cover.

Features

  • Hefty insulation from 100% down with 750+ fill power
  • Baffle-box sewing to maximize loft
  • Extra-soft and durable 100% cotton cover

Sizes

This comforter is available in two sizes: Full/Queen and King/Cal King.

Warmth

The one-two punch of 750+ fill power and loft-maintaining baffle-box sewing generates powerful insulation that makes this warm enough for all-season use.

Cleaning

Dry cleaning is the recommended method for washing this comforter.

Affordability

The price range is $139.95 to $144.95 depending on size.

Trial Period

If you purchase this comforter on Amazon, you are covered by Amazon’s 30-day return policy.

Warranty

There are no explicitly listed warranty terms for the Egyptian Bedding comforter.

Pros
  • Heavy-duty insulation for all-season warmth
  • Excellent price for 100% down
  • Soft cover of 100% Egyptian cotton
Cons

Snowman Goose Down Comforter

Construction

The Snowman Goose Down Comforter has 100% white goose down fill. The fill power is 700+, and the stitching uses the baffle-box style to assure enough space for the down to keep its loft.

The fill is held inside by a shell of 100% cotton with a thread count of 600. 8 exterior loops can be used to keep the comforter in place within a duvet cover.

Features

  • Ample warmth with 700+ fill power
  • Soft and smooth cotton cover
  • Available in multiple colors

Sizes

This comforter is sold in 3 sizes: Twin, Queen, and King.

Warmth

The 700+ fill made with 100% goose down offers plenty of warmth for most climates and sleepers.

Cleaning

Cleaning this comforter requires taking it to a dry cleaner.

Affordability

The price ranges from $139.95 to $179.95 depending on the size and color that you pick.

Trial Period

You have 30 days to return the product for a refund if it is purchased through Amazon.

Warranty

There is no listed warranty information from Snowman Bedding.

Pros
  • 100% goose down
  • 700+ fill power for cozy warmth
  • Shell available in colors other than white
Cons

Basic Beyond Goose Down Comforter

Construction

The Basic Beyond comforter is made with 100% down. It comes in two options that have different levels of fill power. The Lightweight has 600+ fill power, and the All-Season has 650+. Baffle stitching holds down in place without compromising loft.

The cover is 100% polyester with a peach-skin feel. This means the polyester is brushed to make it tufted and softer, but it is not quite as thick as microfiber.

Features

  • Cozy softness from peach-skin feel shell
  • Available in Lightweight and All-Season options
  • 100% goose down

Sizes

Basic Beyond offers this comforter in Twin, Queen, and King sizes.

Warmth

The Lightweight has 600+ fill power and is better for hot sleepers and people in moderate climates.

The All-Season model, with 650+ fill power, provides additional warmth but is less insulating than other, more heavy-duty down comforters.

Cleaning

Basic Beyond recommends dry cleaning for this comforter.

Affordability

The price ranges from $60 to $120 depending on the model and size.

Trial Period

You have 30 days to use the comforter in your home as part of a sleep trial.

Warranty

There is no listed warranty information for the Basic Beyond down comforter.

Pros
  • Extremely affordable for 100% down
  • Sufficient warmth for majority of sleepers
Cons

What You Need to Know When Buying a Down Comforter

Down comes from underneath the exterior feathers of ducks and geese. It has long been associated with luxury in bedding and is known for distinct benefits and downsides.

What Are the Benefits of Down?

Down is a powerful insulator. Its fibers trap heat and prevent cold air from reaching your body and cooling you down. It is far more effective at heat retention than most other fill materials.

At the same time, down is extremely light. As a result, it offers a superior warmth-to-weight ratio.

Down feels plush and is a perfect choice for people who want their bed to feel extra cozy.

Though it feels delicate, down has a long lifespan if it is well cared-for. This generally requires regular fluffing and only washing according to the manufacturer’s instructions.

What Are the Downsides of Down?

Down can provoke allergic reactions, so it is not a viable fill material for people with these sensitivities. Some down may be specially treated to try to eliminate allergens.

Down requires regular maintenance. Because it tends to bunch and compress, a down comforter needs to be frequently fluffed. Cleaning requires careful attention and may be more costly than with other types of comforters.

Down tends to be expensive, and higher-quality down can cause a comforter’s price to exceed the budget of many customers.

Fill

Types of Down

All down shares similar characteristics -- such as warmth, softness, and lightness -- but there are ways of distinguishing between types of down.

Down can come from either geese or ducks. Goose down is more common in comforters. Because geese are larger, goose down normally has larger fibers and more heat retention. This is not a given, though, because the size of the fibers can depend on the breed of duck or goose, its age, and its size.

A comforter may list the country where the down came from, but there is no assurance that down from a specific region is of a higher quality.

Down clusters are made up of several fibers around a central point. These provide the greatest insulation, so a comforter with a higher percentage of down clusters will offer more warmth.

Fill Power

Fill power tells you how much insulation the down provides. It is calculated by measuring the space taken up by 1 ounce. The more space, the better the down can trap heat.

Lightweight down comforters may have fill power between 500 and 600. These work well if you don’t need heavy-duty insulation.

All-season comforters are made with loftier down so that they are effective throughout the winter. Fill power between 600 and 700 is enough for most customers. This fill power provides plenty of warmth but without stifling heat.

Fill power between 700 and 800 translates to substantial warmth. These comforters are best for people who sleep cold, live in colder climates, or keep their bedroom temperature low.

Shell

The shell is the cover that surrounds the down fill. Normally a down comforter is placed inside a duvet cover, so you will rarely have the shell directly against your skin.

A quality shell should be strong enough to contain the down and to help protect it from spills or stains. It can add to the softness of a down comforter as well.

Cotton is extremely popular in shells. It is durable, breathable, and soft. When tightly-woven, it is effective at preventing down from poking out through the shell.

Polyester may be used for a lower-cost shell. It is easier to wash but typically is less soft and breathable. It may be brushed to give it a softer feel.

Rayon, a material that is frequently derived from bamboo, is a synthetic that provides an excellent combination of stretch, softness, and airflow. It normally is blended with polyester when used in a shell.

Silk is naturally cooling and extremely soft to the touch, making it desirable for a shell. However, it is expensive and more challenging to clean.

Stitch design

The style of stitching plays a major role in the performance of a down comforter because it plays a role in how the material is held together.

Sewn-through stitching sews the top to the bottom directly, holding them more tightly together. This compresses the down, reducing its ability to hold in heat. At the same time, it makes fluffing less necessary because the down better stays in place.

Baffle-box stitching connects the top and bottom with a smaller piece of fabric. With more room to move, the down stays loftier, but it can also become bunched and require more frequent fluffing.

If the edge is gusseted, it means there is fabric connecting the top and bottom around the outside of the comforter. This can enhance loft and thickness.

Thread count

For cotton shells, the thread count tells you the density of the cotton. A thread count of around 300 is usually sufficient for softness and for holding the down inside the comforter.

Extremely high thread counts can be misleading because they typically indicate that some yarns have been double-counted.

Weave

Cotton can be woven in numerous ways, but the most common in shells are sateen and percale. Percale is a simpler style in which one vertical yarn is woven over each horizontal yarn. The end result is a tight weave with a slightly stiffer feel.

Sateen weaves are not one-to-one but layer a horizontal yarn over multiple vertical yarns. Weaving in this way exposes more of the horizontal yarn, creating a sleek and soft feel.

A sateen weave layers a horizontal yarn over several vertical yarns. Doing so has a smoothing and softening effect and can give these sheets a shinier appearance.

Cleaning and Care

In order to preserve the down and the shell, cleaning must be done with caution. Step one is trying to reduce how often you need to clean a comforter at all. Using a duvet cover can reduce stains as well as buildup of dirt and sweat.

When you do need to wash it, always follow manufacturer instructions. If possible, only spot clean the cover where necessary.

If the whole comforter must be washed, be aware that it may require dry cleaning. Some comforters can be machine-washed and dried, but it is important that they not be crammed into the machine as this can cause damage during the wash and dry cycle.

Return Policy and Warranty

Given the delicate nature of down, not all of these comforters come with a home sleep trial. However, a flexible return policy can be an added bonus when available since it lets you test out the comforter in your own home.

Warranties can protect your purchase as well. Down should last for several years, and most comforters have an excellent lifespan. That said, a quality warranty can provide a remedy if the fill or shell is faulty.