The Best Feather Mattress ToppersUpdated on December 2, 2020 While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about our affiliate program here.
These days, mattresses can be found in a whole range of firmness, from ultra-soft to super-rigid. But sometimes, the softest beds don’t have enough support, and even if you order the softest bed on the market, it may still not be plush enough for your needs. That’s where mattress toppers come in. Made out of a variety of materials, these allow you to adjust the firmness, texture, and conformity of your bed without making a permanent change to your mattress or compromising on support.
One of the softest mattress topper materials is feathers. Also called featherbeds, feather mattress toppers are actually made out of a combination of feathers and super-soft down from the underside of a duck or a goose. This plumage comes in a soft fabric encasing, usually made out of a breathable material like cotton, which is often quilted to keep the feathers from clumping.
In this guide, we’ll walk you through the most important things to look out for when you’re shopping for a feather mattress topper, the pros and cons of using a featherbed, and our picks for the top feather mattress toppers available on the market right now.
Our Top Picks
|Down on Top Feather Bed Mattress Topper||– Down top layer, feather bottom layer – 230 thread count, 100% cotton cover – Handles for easy fluffing – Feather-proof fabric – 30-day comfort guarantee, 3-year warranty||$399.99|
|Down Mattress Topper||– Two layers of down and feathers – 100% cotton sateen shell – 3-year warranty, 90-day trial||$359|
|Premium Goose Down Feather Mattress Topper||– Machine-washable – 75% goose down top layer, feather bottom layer – 100% cotton cover||See Best Price|
|Down & Duck Feather 4″ Gusset Topper||– Machine-washable – 95% feather, 5% down fill – 233 thread count, 100% cotton cover||See Best Price|
|Luxe Down and Goose Featherbed Mattress Topper||– Down top layer, feather bottom layer – 300 thread-count cotton cover – Ventilated and hypoallergenic – Machine-washable||See Best Price|
Pacific Coast Down on Top Feather Bed Mattress Topper
Why we like it:
- Handles attached for easy fluffing
- Barrier Weave® feather proof fabric
- 525 fill power Hyperclean down
- Down top layer, feather bottom layer
- 30 night comfort guarantee, allergy-free limited warranty, 3-year limited warranty
If you’re looking for a featherbed that manages to be soft and comfortable while minimizing the fussiness that comes with upkeep, then Pacific Coast’s Down on Top Feather Bed Mattress Topper is an excellent choice. Two of the biggest drawbacks when it comes to mattress toppers filled with down and feathers are their need to be regularly fluffed and the likelihood of feathers escaping. Pacific Coast, however, addresses both of these issues by incorporating handles, which allow you to fluff the cover evenly and easily, and a feather-proof cover, which prevents the stuffing from coming out.
The topper is designed with two layers to ensure optimal softness: a top layer made of 100% down at a 525 fill power (which guarantees a high amount of fluff) and a bottom layer made out of Hyperclean® Resilia™ feathers. At 3’’ tall, this creates a significant amount of cushion, and many reviewers say it greatly decreased their back pain. Other perks: an allergy-free warranty, a 30-night comfort guarantee, and a 3 year warranty.
Like most featherbeds, it needs to be spot cleaned and professionally dry cleaned.
Parachute Down Mattress Topper
Why we like it:
- 100% sateen cover
- 85% 550 fill power down, 15% down and feather mix
- Ethically sourced premium European down
- Two-layer design
- 90 day trial, 3 year warranty
Parachute’s Down Mattress Topper is the best choice for those who prioritize both luxury and ethical shopping. Made out of two layers that total three inches high, this featherbed provides plenty of cushion that’s made out of 85% down and 15% down and feather mix. This down is 550 power fill (which guarantees a high amount of fluff), as well as ethically and sustainably sourced from Europe. The softness extends to the outside as well: the topper cover is made out of 100% cotton sateen, which creates a silky texture.
All of this comes inside a baffle box construction, which cuts down on the clumping that’s unavoidable with featherbeds. Additionally, reviewers report that it fluffs easily (about once a week should suffice) and doesn’t flatten out, comparing it favorably to high-end hotel beds. Other perk include: a 90-day trial, a 3-year warranty, high support, and back and hip pain relief.
Like most featherbeds, Parachute’s Down Mattress Topper needs to be dry-cleaned.
Puredown Premium Goose Down Feather Mattress Topper
Why we like it:
- Machine-washable and dryable
- 75% down top layer, feather bottom layer
- 100% cotton fabric cover
Puredown’s Premium Goose Down Feather Mattress Topper is an excellent choice for those who want an affordable featherbed with a high percentage of down that’s also machine-washable and dryable. Like the most cushioning and supportive mattress toppers, Puredown’s is made out of two layers. The top is filled with 75% goose down, while the bottom is made out of goose feathers. This stuffing comes encased in a 100% cotton fabric cover, and clumping is minimized by the baffle box construction.
Of course, a relatively low price tag doesn’t come without its cons. In Puredown’s topper’s case, it’s the thickness. Sitting at only 1.5 inches thick, it’s half the height of more luxurious featherbeds. However, some reviewers still said it provided enough cushioning to alleviate their back pain. Another drawback is the “baking” period. Puredown recommends letting the topper spread out and “bake” in the sun for a few days before use for optimal thickness.
Bluestone Down & Duck Feather 4″ Gusset Topper
Why we like it:
- 4’’ tall gusset
- 233 thread count, 100% cotton cover
Bluestone’s Down & Duck Feather 4’’ Gusset Topper is an excellent choice for those who want a super-thick feather-bed that’s both machine-washable and affordable. While some of the more luxurious mattress toppers only stack up to 3 inches, Bluestone’s feather-bed is 4 inches thick. The cover is made out of 100% 233 thread count cotton, which makes sure it’s soft.
Whereas many brands try to fill their feather-beds with as much down as possible, Bluestone fills theirs with 95% duck feathers and only 5% down. This means it won’t be as soft as feather-beds with a higher percentage of down, and you may beable to feel feathers poking through the fabric. Still, it will be soft enough to alleviate back pain.
Allied Essentials Luxe Down and Goose Featherbed Mattress Topper
Why we like it:
- 300-thread count, 100% cotton cover
- 75% down clusters
Allied Essentials’ Luxe Down and Goose Featherbed Mattress Topper is an excellent choice for those who want an affordable, machine-washable, and high-percentage-down feather-bed, with the added benefit of it being hypoallergenic and ventilated. This means the mattress topper is guaranteed to sleep cooler and with fewer allergens.The turtle-top quilting and double-layer construction means there’s a lot of cushioning The top layer is made out of 75% down clusters at a 550 power fill (which guarantees a high amount of fluff), while the bottom is made out of RDS goose feathers.
Compared to mattress toppers that total 3 inches and even 4 inches, it sits at a thinner 2 inches. This may not be thick enough for some sleepers, with its thickness similar to that of a comforter. It is still a great and affordable option for those looking to make their mattress softer.
Feather Mattress Topper Buyer’s Guide
If your bed is too firm, but you don’t want to completely overhaul your mattress, a feather mattress topper is a faster and cheaper way to get a good night’s sleep. Lightweight and comfortable, they provide an extra layer of cushioning between you and the mattress’ comfort layer. Not only can they soften your mattress, but they can also improve your sleep environment by being hypoallergenic, cooling, and resilient enough for sex. In this section, we’ll outline all the differences between feather mattress toppers and those made out of other materials, and why you might want to buy one over the other.
What is a Mattress Topper?
As the name suggests, a mattress topper goes on top of your mattress, right over the soft comfort layer. This isn’t to be confused with a mattress pad, although the two products have similar functions and the terms are sometimes used interchangeably.
While both mattress toppers and pads go over mattresses, mattress toppers are generally far thicker. Although not as thick as mattresses, of course, they provide an extra layer of cushioning that is a lot more noticeable than a mattress pad. Designed for those who need their beds to be softer, more supportive, and more conforming, they act as an extra comfort layer for your mattress.
What is a Feather Mattress Topper?
Mattress toppers come in a number of different materials, including memory foam, latex, wool, cotton, synthetic polyblends, and, of course, feathers. These materials all serve different purposes, with memory foam mattress toppers providing mattresses with more conformity, and latex mattress toppers providing more bounce.
What sets feather mattress toppers apart is their exceptional softness. This softness comes from the combination of feathers and down (usually from a duck or a goose) inside the fabric cover, which varies percentage-wise from topper to topper. Their main purpose is to alter the firmness of a mattress to make it plusher and more comfortable. Since they’re both thick and lightweight, they’re an excellent choice for sleepers who want to soften their mattress without dealing with the cumbersome weight of a latex or foam memory topper.
What Are the Pros and Cons of a Feather Mattress Topper?
|Exceptional softness: Due to the combination of down and feathers, as well as the plush fabrics chosen for their covers, featherbeds are some of the softest mattress toppers available. The higher the percentage of down, the softer the topper.||Lumpiness: Although many featherbeds are quilted to prevent the feathers and down from clumping, some amount of unevenness and lumpiness over time is still unavoidable. This can be prevented somewhat with fluffing, but it’s not a perfect fix.|
|Lightweight: Unlike mattress toppers made out of foam and latex, feather mattress toppers are incredibly lightweight, feeling as light as a thick comforter.||Smell: Since featherbeds are made out of an animal product, some of them can smell quite strong and musty, especially if they get wet and don’t dry properly.|
|Affordable: Ranging on average between $100 and $150, feather mattress toppers are affordable and can be cheaper than latex, foam, and wool alternatives by $200.||Lack of conformity: Due to the looseness and lumpiness of a featherbed’s filling, this type of mattress topper won’t contour to the body compared to one made out of latex or foam.|
|Cooling: Since the down and feather filling of a featherbed is quite loosely packed, and the cover is often made out of a breathable fabric like cotton, this type of mattress cover doesn’t trap heat the way other materials do.||Lack of motion isolation: Because featherbeds are so loosely packed and lack conformity, they won’t cushion your movement and you should expect the same amount of motion transfer as provided by your mattress.|
|Good for sex: Due to their high amount of bounce and resilience, featherbeds are quite good for sex, or at the very least, won’t impede the bounce of the mattress underneath.||Not hypoallergenic: While the cover of a feather mattress topper can certainly be made out of a hypoallergenic material, like cotton, the feathers and down themselves still pose an allergy risk, and are also known to trap allergens.|
|Warm: Although they don’t trap heat and are quite breathable, featherbeds are also naturally very warm. This makes them usable year-round, regardless of weather.||Hard to clean Feather mattress toppers are rarely machine washable, with dry-cleaning being the most common cleaning method.|
Feather vs. Down Alternative Mattress Toppers
For those who might be allergic to feathers and down, or simply don’t want to purchase anything made with animal products, mattress toppers filled with a down alternative are a great choice. Made out of both synthetic and natural stuffing that’s designed to mimic the texture of down, these vegan alternatives retain most of the softness and fluff without posing the ethical and allergy issues that come from featherbeds.
Of course, down alternatives come with their own set of pros and cons. Generally speaking, they can be made to be 100% hypoallergenic, machine-washable, and are also considerably cheaper than mattress toppers made out of duck and goose feathers. On the other hand, they tend to be heavier, less fluffy, less breathable, less durable, and not as warm.
Therefore, we’d recommend feather mattress toppers for sleepers who:
- Tend to sleep hot and need something that won’t trap heat
- Need a mattress topper that keeps them warm during the winter
- Need a mattress topper that’s lightweight
- Want the extra-fluffiness that can only come with duck and goose feathers and down
- Don’t mind paying for regular dry-cleaning
Meanwhile, we’d recommend down alternative mattress toppers for sleepers who:
- Are ethically opposed to buying down and feather products
- Are allergic to down and feather products, or have sensitive skin
- Don’t mind a heavier mattress topper
- Would prefer something machine-washable
- Are willing to replace their mattress topper more regularly
How Much Does a Feather Mattress Topper Cost?
A lot goes into the making of a feather mattress topper, from the raising of the ducks and geese that provide their stuffing, to the labor that goes into plucking the feathers and down. As a result, featherbeds don’t come cheap. On average, they tend to set you back around $100-150, with this price tag only going up with ultra-soft featherbeds that contain a high percentage of down. This doesn’t include the extra price-tag that comes with dry-cleaning, which is the norm for most featherbeds. That said, they still cost a lot less on average than mattress toppers made out of latex, wool, and memory foam, which can set you back between $250 and $400.
|Average Latex Topper Price||$100-400|
|Average Wool Topper Price||$150-300|
|Average Memory Foam Topper Price||$100-250|
|Average Feather Topper Price||$100-150|
|Average Fiber Topper Price||$60-100|
|Average Polyfoam Topper Price||$10-30|