The Best Fiber Mattress ToppersUpdated on October 26, 2020 While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about our affiliate program here.
If you’re not happy with the softness or firmness of your bed, there are a couple of things you can do. You could go shopping for an entirely new mattress, or you could opt for a mattress topper or mattress pad. A less permanent solution than switching mattresses altogether, a mattress topper can completely alter the feel of your bed at a fraction of the cost.
When it comes to mattress toppers, you have a lot of materials to choose from, each with their specific pros and cons. Latex mattress toppers tend to be the thickest and most conforming while still staying cool, but they can cost upwards of $300. Polyfoam mattress toppers, on the other end, can cost as low as $10, but they also break quite easily, are hard to clean, and won’t do much in the way of pain and pressure relief.
Averaging $60-100, fiber mattress toppers are a great middle-ground. These lightweight toppers provide all the softness, fluffiness, cushioning, and pressure relief of a feather topper, while staying vegan-friendly and hypoallergenic. Here are our top choices for 2019.
Our Top Picks
|Down Alternative Topper||– 3’’ thick – Dual-chamber, baffle-box stitching – 100% sateen cotton – Hypoallergenic – 3-year warranty, 90-day trial – USA-made||$169 – $269|
|Overfilled Plush MattressTopper||– Machine-washable – Fully elasticized – Hypoallergenic, Antimicrobial, & Antibacterial – Overfilled Micro-plush||$99|
|Down Alternative Mattress Topper||– 100% microfiber – Hypoallergenic – Baffle-box construction – Anchor bands – 2’’ thick||See Best Price|
|Ultra Plush Mattress Topper||– Bamboo-rayon cover – 60% polyester, 40% bamboo rayon fill – Quilted design – Hypoallergenic – Machine-washable and dryable||See Best Price|
Parachute Down Alternative Topper
Why we like it:
- Thicker than most fiber mattress toppers, at 3’’
- Dual-chamber design, with 3D baffle-box stitching
- 100% sateen cotton and hypoallergenic
- Comes with a 3-year warranty and 90-day trial
- Made in the USA
Parachute’s Down Alternative Topper is a popular vegan-friendly luxury topper that solves a lot of the problems known to plague fiber mattress toppers. At 3’’ thick, it’s fluffier than the majority of fiber-beds, and also sleeps a lot cooler than most. A cover made out of 100% sateen cotton provides additional cooling properties, and the 100% hypoallergenic microfiber fill prevents dander and allergens from building up.
Many reviewers praised it for being indistinguishable from real down, having a “cloud-like” softness, and providing plenty of cushioning to transform too-firm beds. It also received high ratings for not sinking or sagging, and is recommended for side sleepers, as well as those with back issues.
The Down Alternative Topper is dry-clean only, and comes with a 90-day trial and a 3-year warranty.
Linens and Hutch Overfilled Plush Mattress Topper
Why we like it:
- Fully elasticized
- Hypoallergenic, Antimicrobial, & Antibacterial
Linens and Hutch’s Overfilled Plush Mattress Topper is the best suited for sleepers who want a fiber mattress topper that feels just like down but is far less high-maintenance. Although it’s “over-filled” with plush microfiber to recreate a down-like softness and cushioning, it’s also 100% hypoallergenic, antibacterial, and antimicrobial, which many featherbeds are not.
At the same time, the featherbed-like design solves a lot of the issues down alternative toppers are known for. Unlike many fiberbeds, this one neither sleeps too hot nor flattens over time. Reviewers say it retains its thickness and fluff, even when used by sleepers over 300 lbs.
The Overfilled Plush Mattress topper is 100% machine-washable and comes with elastic straps to keep it snugly attached to a mattress. If you’re not sure about your purchase, you can return it within 60 days for a full refund.
Home Sweet Home Dream Down Alternative Mattress Topper
Why we like it:
- Filled with 1000 grams of 100% microfiber
- Hypoallergenic microfiber cover
- Gusset baffle-box construction
- Elastic anchor bands
Home Sweet Home’s Dream Down Alternative Mattress Topper is a good choice for sleepers who want an affordable fiber mattress topper that’s great for back pain. Although it’s only 2’’ thick, it’s filled with 1000 grams of 100% microfiber, enough to keep the topper staying fluffy and cushioning enough for pressure point relief.
Additionally, it’s hypoallergenic, which makes it suitable for those with allergies and sensitive skin. It also comes with elastic anchor bands to keep it from shifting on mattresses.
Being priced at the lower end of the spectrum, the Dream Down Alternative Mattress Topper won’t fix every issue commonly found in fiber mattress toppers. For example, some reviewers found it trapped too much heat, even for the winter, and others reported that it has to be constantly fluffed to retain its shape.
That said, it’s 100% machine-washable, and can accommodate thick mattresses up to 18’’ deep.
Cheer Collection Ultra Plush Mattress Topper
Why we like it:
- Bamboo-rayon cover
- Hollow fiber made out of 60% polyester, 40% bamboo rayon
- Quilted design
- Hypoallergenic and chemical-free
- Machine-washable and dryable
Cheer Collection’s Ultra Plush Mattress Topper is best for sleepers who want a premium down-alternative fiber-bed designed specifically for a cool night’s sleep. The cover is made out of 100% bamboo-rayon, a breathable semi-natural fabric known for its softness, durability, and moisture-wicking properties. The filling is made out of a hollow fiber mixed from 60% polyester and 40% bamboo rayon. This prevents heat from being trapped, as can happen with 100% polyester and other micro-fiber fills, making it suitable for year-round use.
Reviewers assigned it high ratings for its comfort, fluffiness, and thickness, with many saying that it feels just like a luxury pillow top mattress. It also received plenty of praise for being exceptionally soft and durable, and comes with an anti-bacterial and hypoallergenic coating to keep allergens, germs, and stains at bay.
The Ultra Plush Mattress Topper is 100% machine-washable and dryable.
Fiber Mattress Topper Buyer’s Guide
Lightweight, hypoallergenic, and super-soft, a fiber mattress topper can completely change the feel of your mattress. Although they’re only two inches thick at most, these mattress toppers can add a surprising amount of cushioning, relieving pressure points and helping you get a good night’s sleep.
But not all fiberbeds are made equal, and there are a lot of things to consider before you make your final choice. We’ll go over the differences between a mattress topper and a mattress pad, the pros and cons of a fiber mattress topper compared to other materials, what determines their price-point, and some other frequently asked questions.
What is a Mattress Topper?
If you want to alter the top layer of your bed without completely switching mattresses, adding a mattress topper can be a more affordable, low-commitment fix. Think about them like stand-alone comfort layers. Unlike mattress pads, which tend to be too thin for such purposes and act more like padded mattress protectors, mattress toppers are several inches thick.
Among their many benefits, they can make your bed softer, change it to be more suitable for sex, add more cushioning, isolate motion, help you sleep cooler, and more. What changes they can make to your bed depends mostly on what they’re made of: mattress toppers come in latex, memory foam, wool, feather and down, fiber, and polyfoam.
What is a Fiber Mattress Topper?
As the name suggests, fiber mattress toppers can be made out of both natural and artificial fibers like polyester, cotton, rayon, microfibers, polyblends, and more. They’re frequently used as “down alternatives,” and share many of the same benefits as toppers filled with feathers and down. Like featherbeds, fiber mattress toppers (or fiberbeds) are lightweight, soft, fluffy, and can add a noticeable amount of cushioning to your mattress.
The differences lie in the level of maintenance required, the suitability for those with sensitive skin and allergies, and the temperature control. While featherbeds are quite breathable and can keep you sleeping cool, they also tend to require professional cleaning and trigger reactions in those allergic to feathers and down. Fiberbeds, on the other hand, tend to trap heat, but they can be thrown in the washer and dryer, and are mostly hypoallergenic. Generally speaking, fiberbeds are the best choice for those who want all the benefits of a featherbed, without the animal products.
What Are the Pros and Cons of a Fiber Mattress Topper?
|Affordable: Fiber mattress toppers are some of the most affordable types of mattress toppers out there. On average, only those made out of polyfoam cost less.||Sleep hot: Fiber mattress toppers tend to sleep hotter than those made out of latex, feathers, and wool. Their lack of breathability means they trap heat.|
|Hypoallergenic: Unlike mattress toppers made out of feathers and down, many fiber mattress toppers are hypoallergenic.||Inferior motion isolation: Due to their relative thinness and lack of conformity, fiber mattress toppers don’t isolate motion very well. Consider another material if you share a bed.|
|Machine-washable: While other types of mattress toppers, like those made out of latex and memory foam, have to be spot- or dry-cleaned, fiber mattress toppers can be thrown in the wash.||Thin: Fiber mattress toppers tend to be 2 inches thick at most. Consider another material if you need more cushioning.|
|Good for sex: Being lightweight, non-conforming, and relatively thin, fiber mattress toppers won’t make you sink into the material, which makes them good for sex.||Non-conforming: Due to their material and thinness, fiber mattress toppers don’t conform to the body as well as those made out of latex or memory foam.|
|Vegan-friendly: Fiber mattress toppers tend to be made out of materials like polyester, cotton, and other down alternatives, making them free of animal products.||Needs to be regularly replaced: On average, fiber mattress toppers tend to break down and lose their shape earlier than more expensive types of mattress toppers, requiring them to be more regularly replaced.|
How Much Does a Fiber Mattress Topper Cost?
One of the top selling points of a fiber mattress topper is the cost. They tend to be the most affordable types of mattress toppers out there after those made from cheap polyfoam. This is also why they make excellent down and feather alternatives, as they provide many of the same benefits at around half the cost.
Of course, the final price tag of your fiber mattress topper depends largely on its specific materials. Fiber mattress toppers made with organic, GOLS and OEKO-TEX certified, hypoallergenic, and anti-microbial materials all tend to cost more.
|Average Latex Topper Price||$100-400|
|Average Wool Topper Price||$150-300|
|Average Memory Foam Topper Price||$100-250|
|Average Feather Topper Price||$100-150|
|Average Fiber Topper Price||$60-100|
|Average Polyfoam Topper Price||$10-30|