Best Mattresses Under $500

While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about our affiliate program here.

Need a new mattress on a $500 budget? Here's what you should know.

As you begin your search for a new mattress, your budget is probably a foremost concern. When looking for a $500 mattress, you must consider your sleep position, whether you sleep alone or with a partner, how hot you sleep, the materials you prefer, and what feels comfortable to you.

If you do your homework, you can find a quality mattress on this modest budget. Some features of a good bed are ones that keep your spine properly aligned, contour your body, allow you to “sink-in” just the right amount, and provide a restful night of sleep.

You will find your best deal on a mattress online. Brick-and-mortar mattress stores charge excessive markups because of high overhead costs, and the quality is no better than manufacturers that sell online. Shopping on the web means you can take advantage of information and reviews to help you decide. Most mattress companies offer sleep trials to ensure you find the best bed for you.

We’ve looked at lots of mattresses and found three top picks for the best mattress under $500. We considered the mattress materials, firmness, comfort, customer service, returns policy, and verified customer reviews. Browse through this guide to learn about what to expect in a bed of this price range.

Our Top Five Mattress Picks for Under $500

Manufacturer Model Mattress Type Firmness Price*
Signature Hybrid Hybrid Medium firm (6) $345
Original Tuft & Needle** Foam Medium firm (6.5) $595
iCoil Extra Firm 12” Hybrid Firm (7-8) $346.50

*All prices are based on a Queen mattress

**Though above $500 mark, discounts and coupons usually apply to bring listed prices below $500 or less.

Allswell Signature Hybrid

Why we like it:

  • Moderate contouring for pressure relief
  • Multiple design elements for sleeping cool
  • Reinforced perimeter for edge support
  • 100-night risk-free sleep trial

 

 

The Allswell Signature Hybrid is a tremendous value for its low price of just $345 for a Queen. It features three layers to achieve above-average edge support and motion isolation along with comfort and support.

This mattress from Allswell is 10” tall and has a comfort system that is 3” thick. That system is composed of two elements: a 1” quilted cotton pad and 2” of gel-infused memory foam. The cotton gives the mattress softness and breathability while the memory foam delivers contouring and enhanced relief of pressure points.

The support core is 7” thick and made with pocketed innerspring coils. Because these coils can compress based on how weight is applied to the bed, they work along with the memory foam and cotton to create a responsive sleeping surface that can reduce the risk of spinal misalignment. Coils are thicker around the exterior of the mattress, a feature that boosts edge support.

The Allswell Signature Hybrid is Medium Firm, falling around a 6 on the firmness scale. This comfort feel has broad appeal and works best for side sleepers. It can be a good fit for stomach and back sleepers as well, especially if they weigh under 230 pounds.

The cotton and the coils promote airflow, and the foam is gel-infused to reduce heat retention. As a result, the mattress stays cool. The comfort layer effectively isolates motion, and the bounce from the coils makes the Allswell a good choice for customers who prioritize a good mattress for sex.

Each Allswell mattress comes with a 100-night sleep trial that has no required break-in period. The mattress is covered by a 10-year limited warranty.

Given the impressive design and materials, the Allswell is a clear-cut choice for our list of the top mattresses under $500.

Tuft & Needle Original

Why we like it:

  • Great blend of contouring and bounce
  • Solid fit for sleepers in most positions
  • Proven track record of customer satisfaction

 

Tuft & Needle

Tuft and Needle

The Original mattress from Tuft & Needle is one of the most tried-and-true options on the market, especially for shoppers looking for a great value. While its base price is above $500 ($595 for a Queen), other sizes are under $500, and discounts and promotions frequently bring the Queen under $500 as well.

Tuft & Needle has been at the forefront of the trend of online mattress shopping, and with thousands of customers served, Tuft & Needle retains a great reputation for customer support and overall satisfaction.

The design of the Tuft & Needle is straightforward. It is 10” tall and has two foam layers. The top layer is 3” thick and made with Adaptive Foam. Adaptive Foam is the name Tuft & Needle has given to their proprietary blend of polyfoam. This foam was formulated to have moderate contouring and bounce, and this combination makes the bed responsive enough to relieve pressure yet resilient enough to keep from ever feeling stuck in the bed.

The support core is made with high-density polyfoam that is 7” thick and helps to prop up the Adaptive Foam while giving some additional strength at the edges.

The comfort feel is Medium Firm, around a 6.5 on the firmness scale, so virtually all sleepers can get comfortable on the Tuft & Needle Original. Side sleepers of almost all body weights typically love the mattress, and back and stomach sleepers of average or lower weight also frequently find that they get excellent support from this bed.

The Adaptive Foam does not have serious problems with heat retention, and it is above-average at motion isolation. The resilience of this foam prevents the mattress from posing barriers to sexual activity.

With an accessible price point, the Tuft & Needle Original is a proven winner for people who are mattress shopping on a budget. It comes with a 100-night sleep trial that allows you to return the mattress at any point during that time for a full refund. A 10-year non-prorated warranty offers comfort that your purchase is protected over the long term in the event of any defects.

Zinus iCoil Extra Firm 12”

Why we like it:

  • Hybrid design with individually-wrapped coils
  • Firm feel that is great for back and stomach sleepers
  • Materials resist heat retention

Zinus is a well-known name to bargain shoppers looking for bedroom furniture, and their Extra Firm iCoil 12-inch mattress is a top choice for people looking for a solid mattress under $500. With a hybrid design and a price tag under $350 for a Queen, the iCoil is especially compelling for stomach and back sleepers or anyone who prefers a firmer mattress feel.

The Zinus features three layers in its internal construction. The top layer is 1.5” of a comfort polyfoam with light contouring. The second layer is 2.5” of a higher-density support foam that primarily adds firmness and resilience.

The support core is 7.5” thick and made with individually-wrapped innerspring coils. In the Queen, there are 936 coils, and because they are individually-wrapped, sleepers find a higher level of responsiveness and considerably less motion transfer than on traditional innerspring beds.

This is an Extra Firm mattress with a feel that is around a 7-8 on the typical firmness scale. Because of this firmness and only minor contouring, the iCoil is not the best fit for sleepers with extremely sharp pressure points. However, it tends to serve back and side sleepers extremely well, offering just enough responsiveness for support and spinal alignment.

Customers who purchase the Zinus through Amazon are covered by Amazon’s 30-day return window, allowing for risk-free returns if you aren’t satisfied with the bed. Zinus provides a 10-year limited warranty to provide a remedy in case any defects arise over time.

If you’re looking for a stable, robust mattress with a firm feel, the Zinus iCoil is a great choice and provides significant value for customers who want to spend less than $500 on a new mattress.

Buying Guide: Best Mattresses Under $500

How Far Will $500 Go?

If your budget is limited, that’s okay. You can still find a quality mattress for around $500 if you shop carefully. Shopping online offers the chance to get a higher quality mattress for far less money than you would spend in a mattress store, furniture gallery, or department store.

Selecting a mattress is subjective, so your personal preferences are key. If you’re a side sleeper, you’ll usually have more adaptability to a bed. Stomach and back sleepers must be more particular. If you’re a hot sleeper, you’ll need to be mindful of the choice of materials.

When comparing a less costly mattress to a high-end mattress, there are some differences, but you can still find a bed that meets your needs. Understanding how beds are made and what materials offer the best comfort, support, and durability is vital to understanding what you’ll get. Here’s a glimpse at what you can expect in a $500 mattress including durability ratings, materials, support, and added features.

Best-mattress-under-500-e1520875854831

Durability

Some materials are more durable than others, and knowing this can help you assess the potential longevity of a bed. A lower-cost mattress may have a shorter lifespan, but in most cases, you can still expect it to last at least 6 years.

The lower the quality of the materials, the less durable the mattress will be. Be sure to read the materials and mattress types sections below to learn more about what to expect for performance from each type of bed and how it relates to mattress longevity.

Components

There are four basic mattress types. Foam, latex, or innerspring are what are in all standard beds, or you can get a hybrid which is a mix of components. See more on these in the mattress types section below.

Foam quality is affected by the type and density of the foam, and innerspring quality is affected by the coil material and design. Latex is a luxury material and rare in this price range. For $500, you can get quality materials and construction if you shop carefully and from an informed perspective.

Comfort and Support

Even with a $500 budget, you can find a mattress that offers both comfort and support. Remember that comfort and support are different. Comfort is how a bed feels to you; support is how the bed holds up your body and aligns your spine as you sleep.

Comfort is directly related to firmness, which is rated for each mattress on a scale of 1-10 with lower numbers representing softer, plusher beds. Individual sleepers may find comfort anywhere on this scale, but Medium Firm (5-7) has the broadest appeal.

The top part of a mattress is the comfort layer. Under that is the support core. These two layers together determine how comfortable the bed feels to you and how well it maintains the proper alignment of your spine.

Special Features

Some features of a mattress will drive up the price. When looking at the best beds under $500, it’s important to know that your access to specialization and other upgrades may be limited. If you’re looking for an organic mattress made with all-natural materials, for example, you might need to spend more.

Some mattresses offer custom configuration based on your specifications to tweak the arrangement of the layers. Removable covers are a nice option if you’re prone to spills or muddy pet paws.

These are nice features in a mattress, but at $500, you will likely not find them. White glove delivery and installation are a nice service but can run $100 or more on top of the mattress cost.

Warranties

Although mattress warranties vary, these don’t guarantee that your bed will last as many years as the duration of the warranty. Warranties are more about mistakes in craftsmanship or materials, and a warranty may not cover a bed that simply wears out after frequent use.

At the $500 price range, you can expect a more modest warranty for manufacturing defects compared to higher-cost beds. You can also expect a 70 to 100-night sleep trial to assess the bed and make sure your bargain bed sleeps well.

Can You Get a Good Mattress For $500?

Yes, you can buy a quality mattress for less than $500 if you read reviews, comparison shop, and choose wisely. If you choose a foam or hybrid mattress, you can expect quality foam with good durability, meaning the mattress should last at least 6-8 years.

Foam and hybrid beds fall into the $500 mattress range, but an all-latex bed will typically not be of good quality in this price range. Browse the section below on types of mattresses and consider our top three picks for the best choices among mattresses under $500.

What Types of Mattresses Are Available?

As we mentioned above, there are four standard types of mattresses. These are innerspring, latex, foam, and hybrid. Airbeds, which use an inflatable air chamber for adjustable firmness, are another mattress type but are virtually never available in this price range.

Advancements are made all the time in materials and technology making it increasingly easier to find inexpensive mattresses of higher quality. No matter what type of mattress you choose, the best mattress under $500 should provide you with a good night’s rest on quality materials, the level of support that your body demands, strong stitching so the ticking stays put, a reasonable sleep trial period, and fair warranty and return policies.

Learn more about the types of mattresses:

Foam

Foam mattresses can be memory foam, polyurethane foam (polyfoam), or both. Most foams are made from petrochemicals although some brands now promise they are made of soy or plant-based oils.

Memory foam was originally developed by NASA and has impressive abilities to compress in response to body weight. Polyfoam can be formulated to have more or less contouring and bounce. As a result, foam mattresses come in a wide array of firmness and comfort. Foams that are made with a higher density, measured in pounds per cubic foot (PCF), tend to have a longer lifespan.

Latex
Innerspring
Hybrid