The Best Mattresses for Stomach Sleepers of 2019
While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about our affiliate program here.
If anyone has ever told you that your sleeping position looks like the “dead man’s float,” then you are one of the small minority of people who can be described as a stomach sleeper.
Getting the right amount of support can be a challenge for stomach sleepers. As you may have experienced, sleeping on your belly can cause aches, pains, or stiffness in the back or neck. Without the right mattress, the risk of these issues only gets higher and higher with each passing night.
In this guide, we’ll cover all the key information you need to know ranging from basic facts about stomach sleeping to the most important things to look for when shopping for a new mattress. See our selections for the best mattresses for stomach sleepers below and read through buyer's guide for shopping tips and information.
What Are the Best Mattresses for Stomach Sleepers?
|Manufacturer||Model||Mattress Type||Firmness||Price (Queen)|
|Saatva||Innerspring||3 choices: Plush Soft (3-3.5), Luxury Firm (5-6), Firm (8)||$1,099|
|Nectar||Foam||Medium Firm (6)||$699|
|Avocado||Latex Hybrid||2 choices: Medium Firm (5.5) with pillowtop; Firm (7) without pillowtop||$1,399|
|Signature||Foam||3 choices: Soft (4), Medium (6), Firm (7.5-8)||$949|
|Dusk||Hybrid||Medium Firm (5-6) / Customizable||$920|
Why we like it:
- Multiple firmness options, including a Firm model best for most stomach sleepers
- Coil-on-coil design provides responsiveness and resilience
- Comfort layer cushions the body without too much sink
- Free installation and removal of an old mattress
The Saatva is an innerspring mattress, but it’s not like the innersprings of yesteryear. Instead, it employs a coil-on-coil design that gives stomach sleepers the support and comfort that they need.
The bottom two layers of the Saatva are both made of innerspring coils. The base layer is either 4” or 7” thick depending on which height you select. This support core has steel Bonnell coils that are the building block for the rest of the mattress. Above this is another, yet distinct, layer of coils.
Resting on top of the steel coils is a 4” layer of individually-wrapped micro-coils that have plenty of bounce but with an excellent ability to respond to the body’s weight and pressure. Foam wraps around this layer to provide robust edge support.
A layer of polyfoam, a lumbar pad made of memory foam, and a quilted euro-style pillowtop with foam and fiber fill all work together to give added comfort and contouring to the Saatva. Just how soft these materials will feel depends on your comfort preference. You can choose between Plush Soft (3-3.5), Luxury Firm (5-6), and Firm (8). Most stomach sleepers get the best results from the Firm mattress.
Unlike most mattresses purchased online, the Saatva comes with white-glove delivery included in the purchase price. This means that it’s not a bed-in-a-box; instead, it will be brought to your home and installed in your bedroom. If you have an old mattress to get rid of, the white-glove service includes hauling it away.
The Saatva comes with a sleep trial of 120 nights with no break-in period. In the event that you decide to return the mattress, Saatva does deduct $99 from your refund as a return shipping fee.
Why we like it:
- Combination of foam layers avoid excessive sink or softness
- Memory foam cushions key pressure points
- Extended 365-night sleep trial to test out the mattress
While some people assume that stomach sleepers can only do well on a very firm bed, the truth is that some stomach sleepers get excellent results with a medium firm bed that has enough responsiveness to properly cushion the body.
The Nectar mattress offers the mixture of contouring and firmness that can be a game-changer for stomach sleepers who are fed up with sleeping on extra-firm beds. The Nectar employs three layers of different memory foams to cushion the body while resisting the “quicksand” feeling that can be problematic for stomach sleepers.
The top layer of the Nectar is quilted memory foam, the second layer is a gel-infused memory foam, and the third is the company’s Adaptive Hi Core memory foam. The top two layers help with pressure-point relief while the Adaptive Hi Core foam bolsters those layers with more firmness and bounce.
By including multiple types of unique memory foams, the Nectar captures benefits of this material, such as responsiveness, motion isolation, and comfort without the downsides like excessive hug and heat buildup. The combined effect is a mattress that can deliver great results for stomach sleepers, especially those under 230 pounds who will not sink as deeply into the foam.
Another huge benefit to the Nectar mattress is that it comes with a no-risk, 365-night sleep trial. When you receive the mattress, you are required to keep it for 30 nights. After that, the trial begins, giving you a full-year after the break-in period to see how well it works for you. The mattress also comes with a lifetime warranty covering any defects in materials or manufacturing.
Avocado Green Mattress
Why we like it:
- High-end, natural, and certified-organic materials
- Pocketed innerspring coils with resilient latex comfort layer
- Two firmness options
- 25-year warranty
The Avocado Green Mattress is a latex hybrid that can give stomach sleepers the firm, responsive, and comfortable sleeping surface that they need.
Each Avocado mattress is built with a support core of 8” thick innerspring coils. These coils are arranged in zones to provide different levels of cushioning, adding a degree of responsiveness while improving edge support at the same time. The coils rest on a 1” thick layer of latex that gives added stability to the support core.
Above the coils is a comfort layer made of latex. In the Standard model, this comfort layer is made of one 2” thick layer of latex produced with the Dunlop method. In the Pillow Top model, there are two 2” thick layers of latex. Tufted organic wool is included beneath an organic cotton cover in both models.
The Standard Avocado mattress is Firm (7 on the firmness scale) and tends to be the better choice for stomach sleepers. For stomach sleepers of a lighter body weight or who like a softer feel, the Pillow Top is Medium Firm (5.5). Both deliver the moderate contouring of latex that can offer relief at pressure points while maintaining plenty of bounce.
Avocado only uses 100% GOLS organic certified latex, and the wool and cotton are both certified to meet the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS), demonstrating that these materials meet rigorous standards for green production.
Avocado offers a 100-night trial for you to test out the mattress with the option to return it for a refund. The company requests, but does not require, that you keep the mattress for at least 30 days to give your body time to get accustomed to it. Over the long-term, the mattress is protected by a 25-year warranty.
Brooklyn Bedding Signature
Why we like it:
- Soft, Medium, and Firm options for mattress feel
- Targeted cushioning from quality foam layers
- Hybrid construction prevents excessive sink into mattress
The Signature mattress from Brooklyn Bedding gives stomach sleepers the right mix of firmness, responsiveness, and resilience thanks to its balanced, hybrid design.
The Signature employs a support core of 6” of individually-encased innerspring coils. The coils rest on a 1” layer of support polyfoam for extra stability. These layers work together to give the mattress a base level of firmness, responsiveness, and bounce.
Above the coils are two foam layers. The top layer is 2” of TitanFlex, a specialty gel-infused polyfoam. The TitanFlex foam has moderate levels of conforming, so it cushions the body without giving way. The gel helps keep this layer from accumulating heat through the night. The second foam layer is 2” of Energex foam that provides extra resilience, enhancing the springy feeling of the coils.
Most stomach sleepers have the best results with the Firm option, which is around an 8 on the typical firmness scale, but Soft (4) and Medium (6) options are available as well. The firmer models work to prevent the abdomen from sinking too far into the bed and out of alignment with the body.
Brooklyn Bedding has a long-standing reputation for quality in the mattress industry, and the Signature represents the most recent redesign of their flagship mattress. Other mattresses in the Brooklyn Bedding lineup, including the Bowery, Aurora, and Spartan mattresses, may also be considerations for stomach sleepers.
The Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress comes with a 10-year warranty and a 120-night sleep trial that allows you to return the mattress if you aren’t satisfied with it. However, this trial does have a mandatory 30-night try-out period before you can initiate a return.
Why we like it:
- Innerspring coils and resilient foam promote spinal alignment
- Choose between Standard and more feature-full Luxe model
- Online Sleep Quiz helps identify best model for you
Helix offers an extensive product line of mattresses built around the hybrid design concept. The Dusk represents just one of their models, and it can provide the support stomach sleepers need to get a great night’s sleep.
The Dusk is offered in both a Standard and a Luxe model. Both utilize a support core of individually-wrapped innerspring coils that have reinforced edges to improve support around the perimeter. A base layer of high-density polyfoam underneath gives extra cushion to buttress these coils.
Above the coils is a layer of Helix Dynamic Foam, a specialty polyfoam that blends the characteristics of memory foam and latex. For this reason, it has enough give to relieve pressure for a stomach sleeper, but it doesn’t feel like sleeping on quicksand. In the Luxe model, a high-density layer of gel-infused memory foam is included for added contouring.
The Dusk mattress is medium firm and falls between a 5 and a 6 on the typical firmness scale. This firmness level will work best for stomach sleepers who weigh under 130 pounds and don’t sink as deeply into the bed. Stomach sleepers of a higher body weight can take the Sleep Quiz on Helix’s website and let its proprietary algorithm determine if a different hybrid mattress model would better suit their needs.
All of the Helix mattresses come with a 100-night sleep trial. The trial has a 30-night break-in period, but after those 30 nights, you have the rest of the 100-night trial to determine if you want to send the mattress back for a full refund.
Best Mattresses for Stomach Sleepers Buying Guide
About Stomach Sleeping
Sleep research has found that stomach sleeping is the least common of the main sleeping positions with fewer than 10% of people sleeping in this way. In this basic position, many stomach sleepers put their hands up under their head, turn their neck to one side, and/or bend a knee up toward their head.
Stomach sleeping is considered by the majority of experts to be the worst sleeping position with far greater downsides than benefits. The meager benefit from a health perspective is that it can help limit airway obstruction, which can mean a decrease in snoring. The downsides to stomach sleeping are that it can create undue pressure on the spine from the stomach sinking lower into the mattress and out of line with the rest of the body. In addition, ff you turn your neck to be able to breathe, this can cause stiffness in the neck from holding it in a twisted position for hours at a time.
What Are the Most Important Mattress Considerations for Stomach Sleepers?
While sleeping on your stomach is not generally recommended, for some people, it remains the most comfortable sleeping position, and this can be hard to change. For committed stomach sleepers, it makes sense to try to configure the sleeping surface — including the mattress and pillows — to reduce potential negative impacts from this position. In this section, we’ll review the most important factors for stomach sleepers to think through to optimize their bed.
The amount of support that a mattress provides is determined by how responsive it is to the body’s weight and pressure. A responsive mattress provides cushioning in proportion to the body’s position on the mattress. In doing so, it helps align the spine without excessive bending or curvature. Stomach sleepers need a mattress that is responsive enough to cushion the torso but without allowing the abdomen to sag so deeply as to warp the spine’s alignment.
While firmness can influence support, it refers more specifically to the softness and feel of the mattress from a comfort perspective. Stomach sleepers should be very wary of mattresses that are extremely plush because sinking into the mattress may make it harder to breathe while face-down and because it may cause the body to trend toward a “U” shape. At the same time, extremely firm mattresses may be too hard for a stomach sleeper to get positioned on comfortably. Most stomach sleepers do best with medium to medium-firm mattresses that fall between a 4-7 on the typical firmness scale. The higher the person’s weight, generally the higher they should go on that 4-7 firmness range.
Look for reviews from other stomach sleepers since their experience with a mattress is most likely to be meaningful for predicting how well a mattress will work for you. In addition, make sure to only give serious weight to reviews that are from verified purchases and/or from independent product evaluators.
Since a mattress is a product that you plan to use day-in and day-out for years, it’s important that it be able to stand up to regular use. If a mattress starts to break down soon after it’s purchased, the most likely consequence will be a weakening of the mattress in the center where the most pressure is normally applied. For stomach sleepers, this could be an enormous problem as this could cause an extreme amount of sagging of the abdomen into the mattress. To avoid this, we suggest looking for mattresses built with an emphasis on great materials and on products that have a history of durability.
What Mattress Features Should Stomach Sleepers Look For?
When shopping for a new mattress, you may be overwhemed by all the different features and mattress design elements. These are the features that are the most important to look for:
If you’re hoping to make a delicious dinner, it’s not just about having the right recipe — you also need to use great ingredients. The same is true for mattresses. While the design or layering of a mattress is important, the materials that go into building that design are absolutely crucial. A mattress that is built with shoddy components is going to be more likely to have defects, to break down with regular use, or to just simply not meet your expectations.
To examine the materials quality, start by looking up the detailed specifications of the mattress. These should be easy to find on the website of the company selling or manufacturing the mattress. If this information is buried online or not available at all, consider it a red flag.
Once you’ve found the specifications, look at the thickness of each layer and the materials used (including the density and/or ILD of any foams that are used). If you notice that any layer appears to have substandard components, take caution because even just one weak layer can drag down the overall strength of the mattress.
Well-Designed Comfort Layer
You should be skeptical of any mattress that has an extremely thin comfort layer. Even if it is built with top-quality foam, a comfort layer that is only an inch thick is not likely to be able to offer the support you need. Whenever you can, try to opt for a comfort layer (or combination of comfort layers) that is at least 3” thick.
You should be able to get a high quality mattress without breaking the bank. In order to get the best value that you can, do some comparison shopping after you’ve narrowed down to 1-2 top choices. If a mattress costs considerably more than comparably-designed mattresses, make sure that it has features — such as the materials quality — that truly set it apart. You can also often boost the value of your purchase by doing a thorough search for coupons or discounts before making a final purchase.
Keep in mind that any shipping costs need to be factored into your total purchase price. You’ll find that the vast majority of online mattress companies include shipping for no addition cost.
Easy, No-Risk Returns
A common feature offered by online mattress sellers is a no-risk return policy. As part of this policy, companies usually offer a sleep trial during which you can use the mattress in your own home for a set period of time. This time period can range from 30 to 365 nights, although most companies offer a sleep trial of around 100 days. During this trial period, you can return the mattress to get a refund, and frequently the company pays for any return shipping as well. However, there can be limiting terms to a sleep trial such as a minimum number of nights that you have to keep and try the mattress. Make sure to read the terms carefully, and if you can, choose a mattress that offers truly no-risk and simple returns.
What Else to Take Into Account?
Other factors that stomach sleepers should be thinking through include:
Pillow selection is important for sleepers in any position, but it takes on added importance for stomach sleepers because many traditional bed pillows can exacerbate spinal misalignment. Most stomach sleepers do best by using no pillow at all, using only a very thin pillow, or keeping their pillow only under their forehead. Some stomach sleepers also use pillows to get extra support for other parts of the body, for example, by placing a thin pillow under the pelvis or abdomen to try to improve alignment.
If you’re a stomach sleeper who turns your neck to the side in order to breathe, be aware that this can lead to problems. Keeping the neck in any one position for an extended period can strain the muscles that support the neck, so you may want to consider a stretching routine before bed, after waking up, and/or during the day to help keep those muscles loose.
What Types of Mattresses Are Available?
Though there are hundreds of mattress brands and models on the market, virtually every one of these can be categorized into one of 5 types:
- Foam: these are made only of foam. There may be different types of foam, such as polyfoam and viscoelastic foam (memory foam), that are organized into distinct layers. The softness of the mattress and how much it compresses under weight and pressure depends on the thickness and type of foams used and how they are arranged inside the mattress.
- Latex: using either natural rubber or rubber that is synthetically-produced, mattresses built only with latex may also be labeled as “true latex” or “all-latex.” Historically, these were more expensive, but the price of many latex mattresses has come down in recent years. The most well-known characteristic of latex is its bounce, but this material can also provide responsive support to the body.
- Innerspring: this type of mattress has been the stalwart of the industry, and it uses a support core composed of metal coils that can compress and spring back as weight is applied and removed. Depending on the number and type of coils, an innerspring mattress can have different characteristics, but the most common is a bouncier support base. Most innerspring mattresses also have foam, latex, or fabric layered on top to offer some further cushioning.
- Hybrid: like an innerspring mattress, a hybrid uses a core of metal coils to serve as its base layer. In a hybrid, though, there is a more extensive use of other materials like latex, memory foam, or polyfoam. As a general rule, we count a mattress as a hybrid if these other materials are 3” or more in thickness above the innerspring support core. The design concept behind most hybrids is to benefit from the strong base from coils while adding greater contouring support from the complementary materials.
- Airbed: there are many fewer brands of airbeds, but these are a well-known mattress type. In an airbed, the feel of the mattress is determined by a remote or an app that can add or remove air from a chamber inside the mattress. This gives customers a great deal of control over the feel of their mattress and the ability to modify that feel in short order. Some airbed models may also have top layers of foam or latex designed to offer greater support.
Which Mattress Types Are Best For Stomach Sleepers?
Because there can be a wide range of mattress designs within the categories or types, it is difficult to say that one type is always better or worse for stomach sleepers. It’s important to look at the details of each individual mattress model. But as a general guide, here’s how we rank the best mattress types for stomach sleepers.
Responsive foam, especially medium-firm foam that won’t permit excessive sinking into the mattress, is a great option for most stomach sleepers. This could be memory foam or a similarly designed polyfoam. The responsiveness of these materials can accommodate the unique pressure points of stomach sleepers.
Honorable Mention: Hybrid, Latex
Most hybrids, depending on their design, and latex mattresses offer a high level of responsiveness. The enhanced bounce in a latex or hybrid may also be useful for permitting movement on top of the mattress, which is important since many stomach sleepers move more in the night than people who sleep in other positions.
Proceed With Caution: Innerspring, Airbed
For many stomach sleepers, an innerspring or an airbed can offer sufficient support, especially if they have a more responsive comfort layer added to the support core. However, in general, these mattresses are less responsive, so we suggest that stomach sleepers proceed with caution and look very closely at the comfort layer before moving forward in buying one.