Best Online Mattresses 2019
Mattress shopping today is a dramatically different experience than it was just 5 or 10 years ago. While e-commerce has been growing for well over a decade, many people never expected it to reach the mattress industry.
After all, it was assumed that the desire to “try out” a mattress in a store would always confine mattress purchases to brick-and-mortar stores. But that assumption has turned out to be incredibly wrong.
Instead, online mattress sales have exploded with a plethora of companies selling mattresses directly to consumers through their own websites and through third-party retailers. These companies offer a huge range of options at extremely competitive prices and typically with free shipping and the opportunity to try out a mattress risk-free in your own home.
This has spurred more and more competition and better and better values for customers. In addition, online mattress companies have widely adopted a strong orientation toward customer care that stands in contrast to what was often the experience of in-store mattress shopping.
For all these reasons, more people than ever are choosing to shop for and buy a new mattress online. If you've started on this process, you've almost certainly noticed that your options are abundant. To help, we’ve written this guide to direct you to our top picks for the best mattresses online. For more details about the benefits and downsides of buying online and how it’s different from shopping in-store, check out our guide to Buying a Mattress Online.
What Are the Best Online Mattresses?
To get you started with your top picks, we’ve broken them down into a simple table that introduces you to some of their key characteristics including the type, firmness, and price of the mattress.
|Brand||Model||Mattress Type||Firmness||Price (Queen)|
|Puffy||Memory Foam||Medium (5)||$950|
|Brooklyn Signature||Gel Memory Foam||Soft (3) / Medium-Firm (6) / Firm (8)||$949|
|Nectar||Gel Memory Foam||Medium Firm (6)||$699|
|Helix Dusk||Hybrid||Medium (5-6)||$995|
|Bear||Memory Foam||Medium Firm (6.5)||$890|
|DreamCloud||Gel Memory Foam||Medium Firm (6.5)||$1,199|
|Tomorrow Sleep Hybrid||Hybrid||Medium Soft (4) / Medium Firm (6)||$990|
|Layla||Memory Foam||Medium-Soft (4) / Firm (7)||$899|
|Saatva||Innerspring||Plush Soft (4) / Luxury Firm (6) / Firm (7.5)||$1,099|
Online Mattress Reviews
Now that you have a basic introduction to the best mattresses online, it’s time to delve a bit deeper into the specifications of these mattresses and the reasons why they made our list.
Why we like it:
- Close body-contouring
- Great for side sleepers
- Great motion isolation, good for couples
- Backed by a 101-night sleep trial and a lifetime warranty
The Puffy Mattress is a memory foam bed with a 'Medium' feel that alleviates aches and pains for most sleepers regardless of their body weight. Lighter sleepers experience adequate conforming, while heavier individuals feel supported and comfortable without sinking too deeply.
The mattress is constructed with two individual layers. The comfort layer is made of 2.5 gel memory foam and measures 4" thick for close body-contouring. In terms of firmness, the Puffy Mattress is a 'Medium,' or 5 on the 1-10 firmness scale. This material is ideal for side sleepers, who often prefer 'Medium' foam layers for better spinal alignment and pressure relief. A 6" support core made from 1.5 PCF high-density polyfoam reinforces the bed and helps maintain a comfortable, sag-free sleep surface. The Puffy Mattress also has a soft, 100%-polyester cover.
Another benefit of the Puffy Mattress is motion isolation. The foam layers absorb and minimize motion transfer exceptionally well, resulting in fewer nighttime disturbances for couples. The bed also offers better temperature neutrality than many of its all-foam competitors, due in part to its gel-infused top layer.
Puffy has been selling mattresses since 2017 and has an excellent reputation for customer service. Free shipping is offered to customers in the contiguous U.S. and competitive delivery rates are available to those in Alaska and Hawaii. The Puffy Mattress is backed by a 101-night sleep trial, as well as a lifetime warranty against excessive sagging or material defects. A Queen-size Puffy Mattress costs $950 before discounts are applied, which is lower than that of the average memory foam bed.
Brooklyn Signature Mattress
Why we like it:
- Hybrid design combines pressure-relief with responsiveness
- Multiple firmness options
- Sleeps relatively cool
- Free shipping with 120-night sleep trial
Formerly an all-foam mattress, the Brooklyn Signature was recently upgraded into a hybrid model. On a mission to design the #BestMattressEver, the Brooklyn Bedding company engineered a bed with proprietary foams and individually pocketed coils.
The 11.5” bed begins with a 1” layer of quilted gel memory foam. Next comes a 2” layer of TitanFlex polyfoam, a proprietary material infused with cooling gel. Below sits a slightly firmer and denser 2” layer of TitanFlex polyfoam.
At the core of the bed is a 6” layer of up to 1,024 individually pocketed coils. The bed is supported by a 1” layer of high-density base support foam.
The Brooklyn Signature is available in three firmness choices: Soft (3), Medium Firm (6), and Firm (8). The Soft model is best suited for side sleepers or those who prefer additional pressure relief. The Medium Firm is recommended if you are a sleeper who tends to switch positions, while the Firm may be best if you generally sleep on your back or stomach. All firmness levels of the Brooklyn Signature are able to deliver above-average responsiveness, edge-support, and temperature neutrality.
The Brooklyn Signature can be yours at $949 for a queen. The mattress comes with free shipping within the U.S. and Canada, plus a 120-night sleep trial and a lifetime warranty.
Why we like it:
- Doesn't overheat or over-sink like most foam mattresses.
- Contours and relieves pressure well
- Ultra-low price point
- Backed by a 365-night sleep trial
Within the competitive bed-in-a-box industry, the Nectar mattress manages to stand out with its premium construction, ultra-low price point, and generous 365-night sleep trial.
The all-foam bed is available in one firmness: Medium-Firm (6). At The 11” tall, the Nectar is made up of three distinct layers. It begins with a 1” quilted gel memory foam (4 PCF) above a 3” layer of semi-firm, fast-recovery memory foam gel (3.5 PCF). Next comes a 1.75” layer of transition polyfoam above a 5.25” layer of support polyfoam (2.2 PCF). The Nectar is wrapped in a cover of custom-milled tencel, an eco-friendly microfiber made from wood pulp.
The bed introduces technologies designed to eliminate problems associated with conventional foam mattresses, such as overheating and excessive sinking. The tencel cover helps regulate temperature and wick away moisture during the night. Meanwhile, the gel memory foam contours pressure points without allowing you to sink too deeply into the mattress, helping you keep cool and shift positions easily. The Nectar’s foam-based construction also allows for above-average motion isolation.
With its mid-level firmness, the Nectar is a solid choice for light to heavy-weight sleepers of all sleep styles, including back, side, and stomach. It’s also a good choice if you are a sleeper who enjoys the feeling of memory foam, but without the associated overheating or sinking sensation.
As noted, the Nectar comes with a 365-night sleep trial. A queen-size mattress can be purchased for as little as $699 with free shipping throughout the contiguous U.S. The Nectar includes a lifetime warranty.
Helix Dusk Mattress
Why we like it:
- Helix offers a high degree of customization
- Sleeps cool
The Helix Dusk mattress is the most popular of the nine hybrid beds Helix offers. The Dusk is one of two medium firmness mattresses from Helix, but provides additional support compared to its brother the Helix Midnight.
As a hybrid, the Helix Dusk uses an innerspring base that's topped with two layers of foam. Helix uses a Two Touch Design cover that acts to promote airflow and breathability.
The pocketed coils provide a supportive environment that enhances spinal alignment, reducing strain on typical problem areas like your lower back. Helix uses their proprietary Dynamic Foam, which is a latex-foam hybrid that is designed to absorb pressure and contour to areas where your body digs further into the bed, like your shoulders and hips. A transitional layer of polyfoam furthers this cushioning feel and prevents you from sinking through the upper region of the bed.
Helix uses a unique mattress quiz to help you select the mattress that is optimized to your body and sleep style. While the Dusk is their most sought-after model, the other Helix mattresses are built with the same exact quality and care. We recommend you use their quiz to dial in the best mattress for your particular needs.
An exceptionally built hybrid mattress at the price of the Helix is an offering we strongly recommend you consider.
Why we like it:
- Works well for sleepers of almost any weight or sleeping position
- Good pressure relief and motion islolation
- Celliant fabric cover relieves minor aches
The Bear Mattress is a mixed foam mattress marketed towards sleepers with a more active lifestyle. This bed is 10" thick and rated at medium firm (6.5). Bear produces their mattresses to work universally among all types of sleepers—subscribing to a 'one size fits all' type of model.
The Bear mattress is constructed with three different layers of foam. The comfort layer consists of a 1″ layer of 4 PCF Memory Foam and a 2.5″ layer of 3 PCF Polyfoam. The support core is made of a 6.5″ layer of 1.8 PCF Polyfoam. All of the foam is topped by a cover made of Polyester and Celliant fabric.
These strategically placed layers of foam achieve what foam mattresses are intended to do best, provide a comfortable, pressure-relieving experience with great motion isolation. What sets Bear apart the most is its versatility among different sleepers. This mattress performs well with just about any sleeping position and weight class. Further, the Celliant synthetic fabric in the cover has been shown to increase oxygenation in body tissue, relieving minor aches and pains brought on by physical activity.
For for the high performance and versatility mentioned above, the Bear mattress comes at a very reasonable price point, costing only $890 for a queen mattress. This bed ships free in the contiguous US but will go anywhere in the US and Canada except for Puerto Rico. Finally, it comes with a 100-night sleep trial and a 10 year warranty.
This is a perfect mattress for those with chronic pain, athletes, and fans of foam beds of just about every weight and sleeping position-preference. Plus, its affordable price makes it a much more realistic option than many beds on the market.
Why we like it:
- Great Support and pressure relief
- Good choice for those with chronic injuries
- Cashmere pillowtop is extremely comfortable.
- 365-night sleep trial with a lifetime warranty.
One of the latest hybrid beds to join the marketplace, the DreamCloud blends performance memory foam with an advanced microcoil support system. Like the Nectar, the DreamCloud mattress comes with an ultra-generous 365-night sleep trial and relatively affordable price point.
The 15” mattress features a 2”, hand-tufted cashmere blend cover that acts as a European-style pillowtop. Beneath the cover, there are two thin layers of memory foam: a .5” gel-infused memory foam above a 1.75” quilted memory foam. Next up is a .5” layer of hypoallergenic natural latex above a .25” layer of high-density standard memory foam and 1.2” layer of even denser (5 PCF) memory foam.
Below the foam layers is an 8” system of microcoils, arranged to provide zoned support to different layers of the body. Finally, a high-density (5 PCF), 1.5” foundation of memory foam functions as the bed’s base.
The DreamCloud is available in Medium-Firm (6.5). The bed’s firmness and construction make it suitable for sleepers of all sizes, especially back sleepers. The mattress is also reviewed favorably by sleepers with chronic injuries who require additional support. However, some light sleepers found the DreamCloud overly firm.
The DreamCloud can be purchased for $1,199 for a queen, and comes with free shipping throughout all 50 states. The mattress also includes a 365-night sleep trial and a lifetime warranty.
Tomorrow Sleep Hybrid Mattress
Why we like it:
- Hybrid design provides both support and pressure relief
- Great edge support compared to other beds containing foam
- Sleeps cool
- Full year sleep trial
Tomorrow Sleep was launched by Serta Simmons, a powerhouse company in the world of mattress manufacturing. This mattress represents their push into selling mattresses online and directly to consumers.
The Tomorrow Sleep Hybrid mattress is available in two models with a slightly different design intended to provide each with its own firmness feel. The Medium Soft mattress falls as a 4 on the typical firmness scale, and the Medium Firm is a 6.
Both have a support core of 6” of pocketed innerspring coils made with carbon steel, and that innerspring layer is stabilized by a 1” base layer of support polyfoam. The comfort layers are made up of memory foam and gel-infused polyfoam. In the Medium Firm mattress there is also an additional layer of transition foam between the innerspring coils and the top two comfort layers. A layer of foam surrounds the outside of the coils, providing reinforced edge support that is often lacking in many foam and hybrid mattresses.
This hybrid mattress design garners the benefits of innerspring coils (support and bounce) along with the benefits of memory foam (contouring and pressure point relief). Either model is viable for side sleepers, and the Medium Firm can work well for many back and stomach sleepers as well. Another plus is that the mattress includes features -- such as phase-change material (PCM) and gel-infused foam -- that can help keep you from having problems with sleeping hot.
This mattress comes with a sleep trial of a full year, which far outpaces the industry-average sleep trial. This gives you ample time to try it out risk-free. As it costs less than $1,000 for a Queen, the Tomorrow Sleep Hybrid also represents an excellent value relative to many hybrids on the market.
Why we like it:
- Flippable Design with two firmness options
- Great pressure relief and motion isolation
- Sleeps cooler than most foam mattresses
- Affordable with a non-prorated warranty
The Layla Mattress is a memory foam bed distinguished by its flippable design. Made of copper-infused memory foam, this 10.5" bed features two firmness options in one, a medium-soft (4) surface on one side and a firm (7) on the other. Comfortable, versatile and affordable, the Layla is an all-around hit.
The Layla has a support core sandwiched between two different comfort layers on each side. The soft side's comfort layer is made up of one 3" layer of 3.5 PCF Copper-infused Memory Foam on top of 2″ of 1.8 PCF Convoluted Polyfoam. The firm layer just includes 1" of the 3.5 PCF Copper-infused Memory Foam. Between these layers is a support 4.5" core of 2 PCF Polyfoam. This is all wrapped in a cover made out of a polyester blend.
Like most foam mattresses, the Layla delivers in bringing great pressure relief and motion isolation. Unlike other foam mattresses, however, the copper-infused design of the Layla makes for a cooler sleep surface. Additionally, the flippable design is great for those who like different firmness from night to night or those who are unsure about their preferred firmness.
At just $899 for a queen mattress, the Layla comes at a lower price point than most of its competitors. Additionally, it features a lifetime non-prorated warrant, a 120-night sleep trial and free shipping in the contiguous US.
We recommend this mattress to light and medium-weight side, back and stomach sleepers who are attracted to memory foam mattresses and the dual sided design. Generally, the firm side is best for back and stomach sleepers while the soft side is perfect for side sleepers.
Why we like it:
- More supportive and body-conforming than standard innersprings.
- Bouncy and responsive, great for sex
- Eco-friendly materials
- Free shipping, 120-night sleep trial and 15 year warranty
Saatva is an innerspring mattress thriving in a world full of foam and latex. This impressive mattress provides an excellent night of sleep packaged with both luxury and affordability. Additionally, Saatva is known for their both their sustainability and free white-glove delivery, making them one of the preeminent, direct to consumer mattress companies.
The Saatva comes in three firmness options: Plush Soft (4), Luxury Firm (6) and Firm (7.5). These beds feature a support core made 13" recycled bonnell coils. On top of that is a comfort layer that includes a layer of 14.5-gauge recycled steel pocket coils under layers of polyfoam and memory foam. Finally, these mattresses are topped by a pillowtop made of polyfoam, dacron and fiber with an organic cotton cover. Some aspects of these layers depend on the firmness (i.e. coil count, foam thickness, etc.).
With its unique coil-on-coil construction, the Saatva provides better support and body-contouring than standard innerspring mattresses. Best of all, this mattress has a very high-degree of bounciness and responsiveness, making it excellent for sex. Additionally, it has great edge support.
With an exceptionally eco-friendly construction, this mattress is great for consumers looking to invest in more sustainable products. With recycled steel in the coils, bio-based foams and organic cotton in the cover, the production of this bed has a significantly smaller environmental footprint than most.
Saatva offers a free full-service delivery, making their affordable price of $1,099 even more appealing. Further, they offer a 120-night sleep trial and a 15-year non-prorated warranty.
*Prices without discount/promo applied.
Click for best price.