Casper vs. Loom & Leaf Mattress Comparison

While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about our affiliate program here.

The Casper mattress and the Loom & Leaf mattress are both popular mattresses by well-established brands.

Casper launched in 2014 and quickly gained attention for its bed-in-a-box mattresses. The Loom & Leaf mattress is produced by Saatva, which launched in 2011. Saatva focuses on producing mattresses using eco-friendly materials.

The following comparison will focus on the flagship mattress offered by each company. While Casper also offers the Wave and the Essential, this comparison will focus on the original Casper. Saatva also produces the Zenhaven latex mattress and the Saatva innerspring mattress. However, this comparison will focus mainly on the Loom & Leaf mattress.

While the Casper and Loom & Leaf mattresses have some similarities, they also vary on some important factors. Comparing the Casper mattress and the Loom & Leaf mattress on construction, sleep experience, and product information can give you the insight you need to make the best decision for you.

Mattress Construction Comparison

Casper

The Casper mattress is 12 inches high and features four layers of premium memory foam for cooling, comfort, pressure relief, and alignment.

The top layer of the mattress uses breathable, open-cell comfort foam to provide airflow and promote a cooler night’s sleep.

The Casper’s second layer uses high-density memory foam for pressure relief.

The third layer is a Zoned Support transition layer that provides targeted support to crucial areas. The foam is soft under the shoulder area to relieve pressure, while being firm under the hip area to support spinal alignment.

The base layer is composed of dense foam for added support and durability. If you select the hybrid version of the mattress, this base layer uses springs instead of foam to offer greater bounce and breathability.

The mattress was formerly 9.5 inches tall but was recently changed to 12 inches. Specifications on the thickness and density of the layers are not currently available on the Casper website.

 

Casper Mattress Construction

Loom & Leaf

The Loom & Leaf mattress is constructed of several foam layers designed to provide comfort, support, and breathability. The mattress is around 12 inches high; however, this can vary slightly between because of production and shipping factors.

The Loom & Leaf mattress’s top layer uses 2 inches of 4 PCF (pounds per cubic foot) proprietary Spinal Zone Gel. This layer aims to provide lumbar support. It is composed of breathable foam infused with a cooling gel to promote a cooler night’s sleep. The next layer uses 2.5 inches of high-density 5 PCF premium memory foam.

The support layer uses 5.5 inches of 1.8 PCF polyfoam and 2 inches of 1.6 PCF polyfoam. This layer offers deep contouring for comfortable support. The cover is composed of breathable quilted organic cotton that is pulled and set in place by hand.

 

Firmness Comparison

Mattress firmness refers to how hard or soft a mattress feels and how well it keeps the sleeper's spine in alignment. The right firmness can provide both comfort and proper alignment. Firmness levels are often rated on a 10-point scale. A rating of 1 is assigned to ultra-soft mattresses, while 10 refers to the hardest possible mattress.

A mattress’s materials and construction play a role in the overall firmness. Materials like memory foam have a reputation for being soft. However, construction also contributes to firmness. Memory foam and other soft materials can be layered to create a firmer mattress.

Firmness is a personal preference. However, most sleepers find a medium-firm mattress acceptable since this is a mid-range option. The sleeper’s weight can also affect the optimal firmness. Sleepers who weigh less than 130 pounds might require a softer mattress in order to sink in, while sleepers who weigh over 230 pounds may need a firmer mattress to provide the necessary support.

The Casper mattress rates around 6-7 on the firmness scale, making it a medium-firm option that will have wide appeal to a variety of sleepers.

The Loom & Leaf is available in two firmness options: Relaxed Firm and Firm. The Relaxed Firm mattress is about 5.5 on the firmness scale, so it is considered medium-firm. The Firm rates at about 8, so it is a truly firm mattress. The Relaxed Firm may be appropriate for the average sleeper, while the Firm mattress may be a good option for sleepers who prefer a firmer sleep surface or who weigh over 230 pounds.

Sleep Experience

Your overall sleep experience can greatly affect the quality, comfort, and enjoyability of your sleep. When comparing mattresses, it is important to consider how each option will perform in key areas like temperature control, motion transfer, responsiveness, resilience and bounce, edge support, and off-gassing. Below, we’ll compare the Casper mattress and the Loom & Leaf mattress on these factors.

Temperature Control

Temperature control refers to whether or not a mattress retains heat. Since foam mattresses contour to the body, they may trap heat against you, making you sleep hot. However, many foam mattresses have adopted technology to prevent this.

The Casper mattress uses open-cell polyfoam in its top layer to allow for better airflow. Since the Casper mattress isn’t excessively soft, it also prevents excessive sink and therefore associated heat retention.

Some owners feel the Loom & Leaf mattress retains heat. However, it does feature some features that attempt to provide a cooler night’s sleep. Loom & Leaf uses a layer of Spinal Zone Gel that offers lumbar support while providing cooling properties.

If you tend to sleep hot, Casper may have a slight edge in providing better temperature control.

Motion Transfer

Motion transfer occurs when one partner moves and that motion is felt on the other side of the bed. Both the Casper mattress and Loom & Leaf mattresses are composed entirely of foam, so they perform well in motion isolation.

While most foam mattresses earn praise for motion isolation, the Loom & Leaf mattress is exceptional in this area, so it may be a good choice for you if your partner moves a lot during the night.

Responsiveness

Responsiveness is how a mattress adjusts to the weight of your body parts to provide appropriate cushioning. A responsive mattress will allow your wider, heavier body parts, like your hips, to sink in. Because it adjusts to your shape, a responsive mattress can help promote spinal alignment.

The top two layers of the Casper mattress work together to provide good contouring, compressing in the right areas to promote proper alignment. The Zoned Support transition layer provides added responsiveness by providing support and softness where each is needed.

The Loom & Leaf’s layer of proprietary Spinal Zone Gel is designed to provide ideal lumbar support to promote proper alignment. Both the Casper and the Loom & Leaf mattresses should be responsive enough for most sleepers.

Resilience and Bounce

Resilience refers to how quickly a material regains its shape. If it regains its shape quickly, it’s said to have “bounce.” In mattresses, resilience and bounce can make it easier to enjoy sexual activity and change position during the night.

The Casper’s polyfoam comfort layer gives it more resilience and bounce than many memory foam mattresses. The Loom & Leaf mattress’s foam layers are designed primarily for contouring and support, so they may offer less resilience and bounce.

Edge Support

Edge support can allow you to sit or sleep close to the edge of the bed. Like most other all-foam mattresses, neither the Casper nor the Loom & Leaf offers reinforced edges. This could make the edge of the bed feel unstable if you try to sit or sleep near the edge.

Off-gassing and Smell

Either mattress may have a slight odor when first introduced to your home. The smell isn’t harmful and should dissipate within a few hours to a few days as long as you keep the mattress in a well-ventilated space. However, since the Loom & Leaf mattress is not compressed for shipment, it may air out more quickly.

Shipping, Trial, Warranty, and Returns

A company’s policies and procedures can impact the overall convenience and value of your purchase. Comparing delivery fees, shipping methods, old mattress removal, trial length, return cost, and warranty length might help you decide whether the Casper mattress or Loom & Leaf mattress is right for you.

Casper Loom & Leaf
Delivery fee Free shipping in the contiguous U.S. Free shipping
How is it shipped? Bed-in-a-box, optional white glove delivery for a fee in select markets White glove delivery
Old mattress removal? Included with white glove delivery Yes
Sleep trial length 100 nights 120 nights
Return cost and process No cost; company picks up $99
Warranty length 10 years 15 years

Prices, Sizes, and Value

Price may ultimately be a deciding factor in your mattress purchase. Even if your mattress budget is unlimited, the best value for your money can help you find a balance of quality and cost. The following table will show how the Casper mattress and the Loom & Leaf mattress compare on price.

Mattress Size Casper Loom & Leaf
Twin $595 $849
Twin XL $645 $999
Queen $895 $1,399
Full $995 $1,499
King $1,195 $1,799
California King $1,195 $1,799

Across all mattress sizes, the Casper mattress is less expensive than the Loom & Leaf mattress. Casper also frequently offers coupons that drop the price even more.

While the Casper is more affordable, the Loom & Leaf mattress aims to compete with more high-end mattresses. The Loom & Leaf website compares the mattress to the TEMPUR-Cloud Luxe Breeze, which retails for over $4,000, so the Loom & Leaf mattress may present a good value by comparison.

Depending on your needs and preferences, both the Casper mattress and the Loom & Leaf mattress could be considered good values.

Casper Mattress vs. Loom & Leaf Mattress – Which One Should You Buy?

Even knowing more about each mattress’s construction, sleep experience, and more, deciding which mattress is right for you can be challenging. Both the Casper and Loom & Leaf mattresses have clear advantages that may make them your best option. We’ve compiled a list of key differentiators that might make your decision easier.

Buy the Casper mattress if you:

  • Want more temperature control: The Casper’s polyfoam comfort layer is breathable and prevents excessive sinking, so it may provide a cooler sleep surface. This can make it a good option for those who tend to sleep hot.
  • Want a more affordable option: The Casper mattress is a lower-priced option, which may make it a good choice for shoppers on a budget. To save more money, wait until you find an appropriate coupon offer.
  • Want the option of free returns: The Casper mattress offers free returns, so you’ll have to opportunity to change your mind at no cost if the mattress doesn’t meet your needs or preferences.

 

Casper Mattress

Buy the Loom & Leaf mattress if you:

  • Want superior motion isolation: The Loom & Leaf mattress is particularly well-rated for motion isolation, so if you have a partner who tosses and turns during the night, the Loom & Leaf mattress may be a good option.
  • Value eco-friendly materials: The Loom & Leaf mattress uses natural materials in its construction, including an organic cotton cover, natural thistle flame retardant, and natural foams. If sustainability is a major factor in your mattress decision, this may give the Loom & Leaf mattress an edge.
  • Prefer a mattress that wasn’t compressed: The Loom & Leaf mattress isn’t compressed for shipment, so it is less likely to suffer from problems associated with compression, like off-gassing and taking time to regain its intended shape.
  • Want more firmness options: The Loom & Leaf mattress comes in two firmness levels, giving you the opportunity to select your firmness. This may allow you to choose a mattress that more closely meets your firmness preferences.

 

 

The Casper and Loom & Leaf mattresses are both solid choices. The Casper mattress is a lower-priced option, but it also offers some other clear benefits. Like most foam mattresses, it offers good contouring and motion isolation. Plus, the open-cell polyfoam comfort layer allows for better airflow than many foam mattresses, promoting a cooler night’s sleep.

The Loom & Leaf mattress comes in at a higher price point. However, its use of eco-friendly materials and its two firmness options can make it an appealing choice. Additionally, its motion isolation is exceptional.

Both the Casper mattress and the Loom & Leaf mattress provide some terrific features. Which mattress is best for you depends entirely on your needs and preferences.

Table Of Contents

Read Our In-Depth Reviews