Innerspring Mattress Reviews
Innerspring mattresses have been around since the 1930s, and for decades held the top spot as far-and-away the most prominent and popular mattress type on the market. While competition from other mattress types has chipped away at that advantage, innersprings remain common today.
Innerspring mattresses have earned their staying power due to their simplicity, affordability, and their ability to serve as a usable bed for sleepers in all sleeping positions. While older models were often bare-bones in their design, newer options have added features and addressed many of the main complaints about innersprings such as their tendency to sag, short lifespan, noisiness, and lack of motion isolation.
Some of these newer options can also be classified as hybrid mattresses. In our top picks, we’ve included some choices that can be considered hybrids, and we’ve done so because these beds have coils as a main component and because they are the best options for capturing the feel of a traditional innerspring while taking advantage of modern designs.
Because of the abundance of innerspring mattresses on the market both in brick-and-mortar stores and online, customers often struggle to be able to effectively separate the wheat from the chaff.
This guide is here to help and leads you directly to our top picks for the best innerspring mattresses. In addition, we’ll provide a primer on innerspring mattresses including their components, their pros and cons, and the types of sleepers who are best suited for them.
What Are the Best Innerspring Mattresses?
Innerspring mattresses are the most numerous and traditionally the most popular type of mattress. As a result, there are dozens of brands and hundreds of models and styles. For customers who know they like the feel of an innerspring mattress, it can be hard to know where to start to pick the best one.
To streamline this process, we’ve narrowed the list down to our top 5 best innerspring mattresses that are listed -- in no specific order -- in the table below.
|Saatva||Memory foam + Polyfoam + Micro-coils||3 Choices: Plush Soft (3-3.5), Luxury Firm (5-6), Firm (8)||$1,099|
|The Winkbed||Specialty polyfoam + micro-coils||3 Choices: Soft (4.5), Luxury Firm (6.5), Firm (7.5)||$1,599|
|The Allswell||Memory foam||Medium (5-6)||$345|
|DreamCloud||Memory foam + Latex||Luxury Firm (6.5)||$1,199|
|Midnight||Memory foam + specialty polyfoam||Medium (5-6)||$995|
*Listed price does not include discount. Click for discount information.
The following section goes into more detail about our top picks and why they made our list.
Why we like it:
- Significant support system from coil-on-coil design
- Added pressure relief from foam materials in euro-style pillow top
- Three levels of firmness to choose from
- Free white glove delivery
Saatva is a well-known name in the online mattress industry, and the flagship Saatva mattress has earned a solid reputation for customer satisfaction. Though its design is distinct from a traditional innerspring, this mattress nevertheless stands out as a clear choice for our list of the best innerspring mattresses.
The Saatva is offered in two heights -- 11.5” and 14.5” -- and three firmness options -- Plush Soft (3-3.5), Luxury Firm (5-6), and Firm (8). In the taller model, the innerspring support core, made with steel Bonnell coils, is 7” thick; in the smaller model, it is 4” thick.
Above the support core is another layer of coils, but these are 4” thick and made with pocketed micro-coils. A foam layer surrounds these micro-coils to provide additional cushioning and edge support.
Layered above the micro-coils is a combination of memory foam in a lumbar pad, responsive polyfoam, and fiber fil quilted into a euro-style pillow top mattress cover. The exact composition and thickness of these layers depends on the firmness choice.
By combining two layers of coils, the Saatva provides both stability and responsiveness while maintaining a high level of bounce. The foams in the top layers supplement this responsiveness and boost comfort at the same time.
Saatva offers free delivery that includes setup of your new mattress and haul-away of your old one. With a price tag under $1,100, the Saatva is a solid value and a no-brainer for our list of the top 5 best innerspring mattresses.
Why we like it:
- Two layers of pocketed coils deliver the feel of an innerspring
- Specialty polyfoam top layers add contour and motion isolation
- Fantastic edge support
- Choice of Soft (4.5), Medium Firm (6.5), and Firm (7.5) comfort levels
The WinkBed puts a new spin on the traditional innerspring mattress by upgrading to pocketed coils and adding a layer of micro-coils and specialty polyfoams to boost its contouring without losing springiness or comfort.
The WinkBed has two foam layers in its comfort system. Both of these layers are 1.5” thick and made with a gel-infused specialty polyfoam that has latex-like features. These foams provide cushioning for pressure points but without permitting too much sink or eliminating the bounce generated by the underlying coils.
Underneath the foam layers is 2.5” of foam-encased microcoils that boost the bounce and responsiveness of the mattress. The bottom layer is 7.5” of pocketed coils that have a foam encasement around the exterior to create significant edge support that helps distinguish the WinkBed from many of its competitors.
WinkBeds offers this mattress in three comfort choices -- Soft (4.5 on the typical firmness scale), Luxury Firm (6.5), and Firm (7.5).
Another compelling offering from WinkBeds is the WinkBed Plus. This mattress is designed specifically for people who weigh over 300 pounds. It utilizes a layer of latex instead of the micro-coils in order to offer additional support to people with a higher body weight. The comfort feel of the WinkBed Plus mattress is Medium Firm (6.5).
By utilizing a number of new and innovative materials, the WinkBed provides a refreshing twist on the innerspring mattress with a price tag that won't break the bank. As a result, it easily cleared the bar to make our list of the best innerspring mattresses.
Why we like it:
- Memory foam comfort system keeps pressure points cushioned and the spine aligned
- Gel and copper infusions prevent memory foam from overheating
- Long sides of the mattress are reinforced for extra edge support where you most need it
- Incredible price point for a solid hybrid mattress
The Allswell is a budget option that is a fantastic choice for customers who want a high-performing hybrid and are trying to stretch their mattress dollar. But don’t let the low price tag fool you: the Allwell is a thoughtfully designed and well-built mattress, and it performs better than many mattresses that cost double its price or more.
The support core of the Allswell mattress is made with sturdy pocketed innerspring coils. These coils deliver a strong, stable base while contributing significant responsiveness. Another benefit of the coils is that they are configured to provide reinforcements around the perimeter, specifically the long edges where you are more likely to sleep or sit. As a result, the bed offers excellent edge support without sacrificing comfort or cushioning for spinal alignment. Customers note that these coils are especially quiet relative to other innerspring beds.
The contouring and pressure-point relief of the Allswell is enhanced by a 2” layer of copper-gel infused memory foam above the coils. This memory foam layer improves spinal support and motion isolation, resolving a complaint that many customers have about innerspring mattresses.
The cover of the Allswell is quilted cotton that is breathable and supplements the inviting feel of the mattress. The Allswell comes in one firmness level, which is around a 6-7 on the firmness scale.
Customers who want a firmer bed may be interested in the Allswell Luxe Hybrid. Like the Allswell, it is built around a core of zoned, pocketed innerspring coils, but it is taller, has a firmer feel, and costs $645 in a Queen.
Allswell offers free nationwide shipping and a 100-night sleep trial. With its extremely competitive price point, it’s hard to find a better value in the mattress industry than the Allswell.
Why we like it:
- Luxurious feel with cashmere blend cover
- 8-layer construction delivers inviting and supportive sleep surface
- Thick innerspring layer preserves bounce and resilience
- 365-night sleep trial and lifetime warranty
For customers looking for a luxury innerspring design at a reasonable price, the DreamCloud is a top pick.
The DreamCloud mattress is powered by a support core of 8” of pocketed innerspring coils. Those coils are organized into five zones to provide tailored support to the body. The coils are buttressed by a half-inch of memory foam on each side, reducing noise and adding further stability.
Above the support core, the DreamCloud takes advantage of a diversity of materials to deliver high-end performance. The cover is an extra-smooth blend of Cashmere and polyester. Between the cover and the support core are four layers including quilted memory foam, gel-infused memory foam, standard memory foam, and latex.
Together these materials create a feel that is extremely responsive and can reduce the chance you’ll experience backaches or pain. At the same time, the DreamCloud is resilient, and you won’t feel like you’re sleeping in quicksand. The combined effect of the multi-layered design is that there is enough contouring to relieve pressure points and isolate motion while also having the bounce that innersprings are known for.
The DreamCloud is only offered in one firmness level, which is Medium Firm or around a 6.5 on the typical firmness scale.
As an added benefit, this mattress comes with a full-year sleep trial, so you have ample time to test it out in your own home with the ability to get a full refund. It is backed by a lifetime warranty that assures you’ll be taken care of if there’s any defect in the mattress.
Why we like it:
- Notable bounce and responsiveness from support core of wrapped coils
- Online sleep quiz helps match your needs to the right mattress configuration
- Medium Firm feel in the Midnight with choice of other models that have different firmness levels
The Helix Midnight mattress is one of our best bets for people looking for a new innerspring mattress. It is one of the multiple offerings from Helix, a company that has set itself apart from the competition through its focus on helping each customer find the best fit for their needs.
The Midnight mattress is 10” tall and has a Medium-Firm feel that is around a 5-6 on the firmness scale. The support core is made with innerspring coils that are individually wrapped to give them greater ability to compress independently of the surrounding coils. This provides the bed a level of targeted cushioning that recognizes that you usually need more cushioning in some places than in others.
The perimeter of the support core is reinforced to bolster edge support for when you sit or lie near the perimeter of the bed. Underneath the coils is a layer of support foam that adds sturdiness and reduces noise that could come from the coils.
The comfort layer of the Helix Midnight is made with two layers. One layer is Memory Plus Foam that can give just the right about of responsiveness to make sure the body gets the support it needs. It is slightly more resilient than traditional memory foam to prevent too much sinking into the bed. The second layer is Helix Dynamic Foam, a specialty polyfoam that is responsive but with more bounce to augment the feel from the coils.
The two foam layers work in conjunction with the support core to promote spinal alignment and a luxurious feel without “bottoming out” or getting stuck deep in the mattress. The materials retain the bounce but not the stiffness of a traditional innerspring.
In addition to the Helix Midnight standard mattress, Helix offers the Midnight Luxe. The Luxe comes with a quilted pillow top, zoned innerspring coils for heightened lumbar support, and an additional layer of gel-infused memory foam for added contouring. The gel memory foam and a phase-change material -- a fabric that helps absorb and dissipate heat -- in the cover of the Luxe both work to help it stay cool throughout the night.
In addition to the Midnight Luxe, Helix has an extensive product line of innerspring mattresses that have different comfort feels and features. You can take the company’s Sleep Quiz on their website to identify which is the best fit for you.
All of the Helix mattresses come with free shipping and a 100-night sleep trial to let you experience the mattress for yourself in your own bedroom.
Innerspring Mattress Buying Guide
If you’re in the market for a new mattress, you may be the type of person who wants to understand the nitty-gritty details so that you can make a savvy purchase. The following sections get into those details and provide the background you need to make an informed decision about an innerspring mattress.
What is an Innerspring Mattress?
An innerspring mattress uses metal coils to form the backbone of the mattress. These coils can compress and rebound as a person lies down, stands up from bed, or moves on the mattress.
With that basic definition out of the way, it’s important to talk terminology. The term “innerspring” refers to the coil support core inside the bed. These coils give the bed its characteristic bounciness and provide support and pressure relief for the sleeper.
Historically, innerspring mattresses were made with these coils, a cover, and little else. Over time, more layers were often added, especially on top of the coils, to help differentiate one innerspring model from another.
Today, there are many mattresses with a coil-based support core that bear little resemblance to the bare bones innerspring mattresses of yesteryear. When there is a robust and dynamic comfort layer above the coils, we frequently refer to these mattresses as hybrids. But distinguishing between a hybrid and an innerspring can be tricky business.
While a mattress with coils and only a thin layer above it is clearly an innerspring, it can be hard to say whether a more complex mattress -- like some of those in this guide -- are truly an innerspring or a hybrid. For this reason, we sometimes use the descriptors hybrid and innerspring to refer to beds that have significant coil-based support cores and a mix of materials above those coils to add extra cushioning.
What Are the Types of Innerspring Mattresses?
Every innerspring mattress has a core made of coils. By and large, an innerspring bed will use one of the four coil types listed below.
Bonnell coils are the oldest and cheapest coils, and mattresses with these coils are widely available. Bonnell coils have an hourglass shape and are reinforced with spiral-shaped wires (called helicals) and thick, low-gauge wire to handle high levels of compression.
What Are Other Characteristics of Innerspring Coils?
Besides the type of coil used, you can learn about the quality of an innerspring mattress by looking at the gauge, coil count, and pitch.
- Gauge refers to the thickness of the innerspring coils and wire in the support core. The lower the gauge, the thicker the wire. Gauge typically ranges from 18 on the thin end to 12 on the thick end. A mattress with a thicker gauge wire will generally have a firmer feel. Lower-gauge coils tend to be more durable as well. Some innersprings use lower-gauge wire around the outside of the support core to offer more edge support.
- Pitch describes the angle of the coils and wires in relation to the mattress surface.
- Coil count ranges from 300 to 2,000. Up to 1,000, the coil count correlates with a better contour ability, longer lifespan, and higher cost, but past 1,000, it may not be noticeable to the majority of sleepers. A bigger bed size will by necessity have more coils than a smaller bed of the same brand and model.
What Other Components Are in an Innerspring Mattress?
While the central element of an innerspring mattress is its coil support core, there are other components that can go into the mattress construction as well.
Above the coil support core, an innerspring bed may have comfort layers that are designed to offer a different level of firmness or support. The comfort layer can be made of polyfoam, memory foam, latex, fiberfill, cotton, wool, or another fabric. Some comfort layers can incorporate micro-coils to add responsiveness while preserving bounce.
In most innerspring mattresses, especially low-cost options, the comfort layer will be thin and have limited ability to fundamentally change how the mattress feels. However, in our top picks and in hybrid mattresses, the comfort system can dramatically improve support, motion transfer, and comfort while preserving the bounce of the innerspring layer.
The cover of an innerspring mattress can also affect its feel and performance. Some innersprings have a pillow-top that puffs up from the top of the mattress and includes extra material for added softness. The cover may have materials designed to enhance breathability and softness such as cotton, rayon, or wool.
What Does it Feel Like to Sleep on an Innerspring Mattress?
In general, innerspring mattresses provide less contour and pressure relief than latex and foam beds. They tend to be firmer and stiffer in their overall feel. Some sleepers may find that they are more likely to have aches and pains from the lack of pressure relief on a more spare, traditional innerspring.
The coil support core gives innerspring beds their bounciness. This bounce is ideal for sex, but it comes with downsides. These include a noisier, squeakier mattress and a higher amount of motion transfer that can rouse light sleepers during the night.
Innerspring mattresses retain very little heat, and because they do not contour as closely to the body, they do not restrict airflow as much as foam beds. Because of this, innerspring mattresses tend to sleep cooler. They have better edge support because they do not compress as much around the perimeter of the mattress.
What Are the Pros and Cons of Innerspring Mattresses?
The following list of pros and cons can help you determine whether an innerspring mattress will suit your personal sleep needs.
As you review this list, remember that the diversity in innerspring beds, especially the changes that have come to mattress design in the past few years, can make it harder to say that all innersprings will share these benefits and downsides.
Innerspring models are abundant in brick-and-mortar stores and online, which means you have a ton of options for where you purchase the mattress as well as for mattress brand, model, and features.
The average innerspring bed is much more affordable than latex or memory foam beds, although pricier high-end models are available.
Cool sleeping surface
Innerspring mattresses sleep cooler than any other bed because of how they permit airflow and resist heat retention.
Bounciness suitable for sex
The majority of people agree that innerspring mattresses are a great bed for sex thanks to their naturally bouncy support core.
How Much Does an Innerspring Mattress Cost?
Innerspring mattresses are usually the cheapest option on the market with prices as low as $200. A quality Queen innerspring mattress will usually cost about $500 to $800, which is notably less expensive than many other mattress types.
Of course, mattress pricing can vary significantly and will depend on the materials used in the comfort layer and the type of coil in the support core. Bonnell and continuous wire coils are the cheapest, pocket coils are the most expensive, and offset coils are somewhere in the middle. Innersprings with more developed comfort systems likely will come with a higher price tag.
How Long Does an Innerspring Mattress Last?
Generally, the usual innerspring mattress lasts about 5 years, which is two to three years shorter than other mattress types.
The coil gauge will impact the longevity of an innerspring bed. Low-gauge wire and tempered steel coils last longer than high-gauge wire and coils made of non-tempered steel. Pocketed coil support cores provide the best contour, but they may not last as long as bonnell and offset coils.
Innerspring Mattress Warranties
Purchasers of innerspring beds should take special care to note the terms of the warranty, especially in regards to sagging. Many manufacturers will replace the mattress for free if the sagging reaches a certain depth.
Despite their shorter lifespans, warranties for innerspring mattresses may last up to 20 years. However, the fine print is important. At a certain point during the warranty, only part of the cost of the mattress may be covered (a prorated warranty), or the purchaser may be required to pay for certain transportation or replacement fees.
What Type of Sleeper is Best Suited to an Innerspring Mattress?
Overall, the variety of ways that innerspring mattresses can be built, especially in the contemporary mattress industry, makes it hard to say that innersprings are always or almost always good or bad for certain types of sleepers.
While innerspring mattresses are not known for excellent pressure point relief, they are preferred by some sleepers. Medium-firm innerspring beds can alleviate moderate back pain, and they also provide adequate spinal support for back and stomach sleepers and individuals who weigh over 230 pounds.
Newer designs of innerspring mattresses commonly have comfort layers that up the ante as far as support and pressure point relief. This can make many innerspring models a good fit for side sleepers as well.
Innerspring mattresses can be great for couples because of how well they facilitate sex, but their noise and motion transfer can be a downside. In some models, the comfort layer reduces motion transfer while maintaining enough bounce for sex.
Innerspring Mattress FAQ Checklist
As you begin shopping for an innerspring mattress, keep the following checklist of questions handy to make sure you find a quality mattress that supports your sleep needs.
- How thick is the support core?
- What type of coils are used in the support core? Is the gauge and coil count listed?
- What materials are used in the comfort layer?
- How noisy is this bed to sleep or have sex on?
- Is there significant motion transfer on the mattress?
- Will this mattress provide me with adequate support, given my body weight and preferred sleeping position?
- How long should I expect this mattress to last?
- Is there a trial period? What is the return policy?
- What is the warranty length? What are the terms and do they cover sagging?
*Prices without discount/promo applied.
Click for best price.