Since launching their mattresses a few years ago, Layla and Leesa have both gained a reputation for producing well-constructed mattresses at competitive prices.
The Layla mattress is a flippable memory foam mattress infused with copper gel to keep you cool. Each side of the mattress has a different firmness level, so you can choose the one that best suits you. The company recently underwent a rebranding and now puts an emphasis on getting a great night’s sleep so you can live your waking life to the fullest.
Leesa is a respected company in the online mattress world and has tweaked the design of their namesake mattress a few times, most recently unveiling a new type of foam in the top layer. The company has also released a hybrid mattress, although in this review we’ll be focusing on the flagship all-foam Leesa mattress.
In this guide, we’ll cover the pros and cons of the Layla vs. Leesa mattress. Taking into consideration mattress construction, sleeping style, budget, and other factors, we’ll give a brief rundown of the major differences so you can pick the mattress that will give you years of quality sleep.
Mattress Construction Comparison
The Layla mattress is ten inches tall with four layers of foam. This mattress is flippable, with a firm foam on one side and a plush foam on the other. Both foams are infused with copper gel to provide support, diffuse heat, and fight bacteria.
The top layer in the softer side is 3 inches thick, made of high-density (HD) memory foam with a density of 3.5 pounds per cubic foot (PCF). This foam provides a plush cradle that contours to your body. Underneath that is a 2-inch transition layer made of convoluted foam (aka “egg-crate” foam) with a density of 1.8 PCF.
The core support layer is 4.5 inches tall and is made of an HD polyfoam with a density of 2 PCF that limits motion transfer. Lastly is the foam option for the firm side, a 1-inch layer of firmer HD memory foam that also has a density of 3.5 PCF.
The cover is a soft polyester blend infused with ThermoGel, which cools down in response to body heat. As the new cover design is clearly marked with the firm and soft sides, it’s no longer necessary to remove the cover to switch sides. A fire sleeve protects the mattress without the need for added chemicals.
The Leesa is 10 inches tall, with three layers of foam and a polyester-Lycra® blend cover. The first layer is 2 inches of Leesa’s new LSA200 cooling foam. This foam has a density of 3 PCF and an indentation load deflection (ILD) of 13. It’s breathable and more resilient than memory foam, somewhat comparable to latex.
Underneath this is a 2-inch layer of memory foam, also with a density of 3 PCF and with an ILD of 9. Finally, the support core is an HD polyfoam that’s 6 inches tall. It has a density of 1.8 PCF and an ILD of 32. Similar to the Layla, this mattress has a flame-retardant sock that eliminates the need for harsh chemicals.
The firmness of a mattress is one of the major factors that determines how comfortable it will be. It’s a subjective measure, and there’s no universal “best” or “worst” firmness. Your preferred firmness will depend on a combination of factors including your body mass index, sleeping position, and personal preference.
Since it’s difficult to accurately describe firmness, it’s usually given an approximate rating on a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being an extremely soft, or plush, mattress and 10 being extremely hard, or firm.
The firm side on the Layla Mattress ranks about a 7 out of 10 on the firmness scale. There is only 1 inch of memory foam between the firm surface and the dense poly-foam support layer, which provides more resistance while still conforming to your body. The soft side is about a 5 out of 10 and has quite a lot of give. The soft side accommodates side sleepers and combination sleepers, while the firm side will accommodate heavier individuals as well as back and stomach sleepers.
The Leesa only has one firmness option, about a 5 or 6 out of 10 or medium-firm. This is a little plusher than their original mattress, and many people find this firmness to be optimal. However, lightweight individuals may find the mattress doesn’t provide enough sink, while heavier individuals may feel the need for firmer support.
Although the Layla and the Leesa are both all-foam mattresses, each one has slightly different properties that can make a difference to the overall feel. In this section, we’ll compare how the Layla compares to the Leesa in the most important aspects of the sleep experience.
Foam mattresses have a reputation for sleeping hot, but both Layla and Leesa have taken steps to combat this.
Instead of memory foam, the Leesa mattress contains a resilient foam in its upper layer. The proprietary LSA200 foam is breathable and doesn’t contour as closely as memory foam, which leads to a cooler sleeping experience.
People who opt for the soft side of the Layla mattress may find that as the memory foam contours to the body, it traps some body heat. However, the ThermoGel and the copper gel in the Layla counteract this by actively wicking heat away from your body. The grooves in the convoluted foam layer also improve airflow by letting heat escape.
As a result, the Layla and the Leesa perform relatively well on temperature control compared to other all-foam mattresses.
The greatest advantage of memory foam is that it contours locally in response to heat and pressure. This means that it will seamlessly adapt itself to your movements, but your partner won’t feel a thing on the other side of the bed.
Both the firm and soft top layers in the Leesa are made of memory foam, and the bed ranks well on motion isolation. Since the Leesa’s top layer is made of a bouncier foam, the Layla outperforms the Leesa mattress in this aspect.
The material in a responsive mattress compresses proportionally to give more support in the places where it’s most needed. Memory foam is considered the best material for this, as it contours locally in response to pressure and heat.
With the added advantage of the copper, which becomes firmer when compressed, the memory foam in the Layla mattress provides support for heavier areas like the shoulders and hips. This promotes proper spinal alignment and reduces pressure points. The HD polyfoam in the core layer ensures a healthy amount of support.
The LSA200 foam in the Leesa’s top layer provides contouring, although not on the same level as memory foam. The memory foam in the second layer acts as a cradle, keeping the spine aligned and complementing the more resilient foam in the top layer.
Resilience and Bounce
A resilient mattress springs back quickly when pressure is no longer being applied. This “bouncy” quality makes a mattress great for moving around in bed, getting in and out of bed, and sex. Although memory foam has many desirable qualities, its exceptional contouring ability comes at the expense of bounce.
The Layla is a memory foam mattress. This means it does a fantastic job of conforming to the body but has little to no bounce.
In contrast, the Leesa’s top layer is more resilient than memory foam and will provide more bounce. If you hate the feeling of sinking into your bed and want to easily move around on top, you’ll be better off with the Leesa.
Neither the Layla nor the Leesa mattresses have reinforced edges. As all-foam mattresses, they will compress under pressure. This makes it difficult to sit or sleep on the edge of the bed, as you will feel like you’re falling off.
The firmer side of the Layla will have more edge support than the softer side. However, if you’re a heavy individual or if you spend a lot of time on the side of the bed, you may want to consider other mattresses.
Off-gassing and Smell
The Layla and the Leesa are CertiPUR-US certified, which means they are free of ozone depleters and low in volatile organic chemicals (VOCs).
It’s common for foam mattresses to emit a faint “off-gassing” odor when they are first unpacked, and the Layla and Leesa are no exception. The smell is harmless and should disappear within a few days to a week.
Shipping, Trial, Warranty, and Returns
Choosing a mattress is a big decision! If you feel like you may need to sleep on it, the trial period, warranty, shipping, and return policies may play a significant role in your purchase.
|Delivery fee||Free in the contiguous U.S., $125 in Alaska and Hawaii, $225 in Canada||Free|
|How is it shipped?||Bed-in-a-box||Bed-in-a-box|
|Old mattress removal?||No||Included with white glove delivery|
|Sleep trial length||120 nights; 2-week break-in period||100 nights|
|Return cost and process||Free; local charity picks up
Shipping fees to Alaska, Hawaii, and Canada not refunded
|No cost; company picks up|
|Warranty length||Lifetime||10 years|
Prices, Sizes, and Value
Price is another factor to consider when comparing the benefits of the Leesa mattress vs. Layla mattress.
The prices for the Leesa vs. Layla mattresses are on a par with other leading bed-in-a-box mattresses.
The Layla and the Leesa are almost identical in price, with the exception of the King and California King sizes. The Leesa retails for about $100 more in these larger mattress sizes, which may be a consideration if you’re purchasing a bigger bed.
Both companies have been known to offer discounts for major holidays like Memorial Day, President’s Day, Black Friday, Cyber Monday, and the Fourth of July. If you’re lucky, you might also get a few free pillows with your order.
Layla Mattress vs. Leesa Mattress – Which One Should You Buy?
Come this far, but still can’t make your mind up? Here are some easy indications as to whether you’d be better off with a Layla or Leesa mattress.
Buy the Layla mattress if you:
- Want options: One of the downsides to ordering a mattress online is that you can’t be sure how you’ll like the firmness before trying it out. Layla offers a choice between a medium-firm or plush mattress. This can come in handy if you’re not sure which you prefer, or if you envision using the mattress in a guest room.
- Are a side sleeper: The plush side of the Layla mattress provides excellent pressure relief for side sleepers under the hips, shoulders, and lower back.
- Want that memory foam hug feeling: Both sides of the Layla mattress feature memory foam in the top layer. If you can’t get enough of the contouring properties of memory foam, or if you share the bed and don’t want to feel your partner’s movements, then the Layla may be the right choice for you.
- Need a lifetime warranty: Layla’s lifetime warranty is well above the industry standard and will give you peace of mind if you plan on using your Layla mattress for a long time. In the meantime, the high-quality foams used in the Layla mattress should last you a good while.
Buy the Leesa mattress if you:
- Want more bounce: Thanks to its resilient upper layer, the Leesa makes it easier to move around in bed without feeling restricted. This is helpful for sex and for combination sleepers.
- Are a stomach sleeper: The resilient foam in the Leesa’s top layer is ideal for stomach sleepers who want a comfortable surface without sinking too much into the mattress.
- Want White Glove delivery: For a fee, Leesa offers the option of White Glove delivery and old mattress removal. Foam mattresses are fairly easy to set up, but old mattress removal can be a pain, so this might be worth taking advantage of.
- Want to donate to charity: Leesa is a socially responsible Certified B corporation that adheres to high social, environmental, transparency, and accountability standards. The company plants a tree for every mattress sold and donates a mattress to charity for every ten mattresses sold.
Congratulations! If you’ve narrowed it down to either the Layla mattress or Leesa mattress, you’re well on your way to choosing a great mattress.
Both the Layla mattress and the Leesa mattress feature an attractive price point and high-quality materials that promise to deliver many years of restful nights. All that’s left is to consider your own personal needs so you can be confident you’re picking the best mattress for you.