Leesa vs. Tempur-Pedic Mattress Comparison

Tempur-Pedic has a longstanding reputation as one of the biggest and best-known manufacturers of mattresses. In particular, the company built its name with its TEMPUR memory foam. In recent years, though, new companies have rolled out all-foam mattresses and have started to rise in the ranks to take on companies like Tempur-Pedic. An example is Leesa, which has thrived in selling mattresses online and directly to consumers as a bed-in-a-box.

Leesa manufactures just two mattresses, its namesake Leesa all-foam mattress and the Sapira hybrid. In this review, we’ll focus just on the Leesa. Tempur-Pedic has a much larger portfolio of mattresses all of which feature TEMPUR memory foam. Some of these mattresses (those in the Cloud and Contour product lines) are all-foam while those in the Flex product line are hybrids with an innerspring support core.

If you’ve been doing your research, it’s not a surprise that you’ve identified these two brands as serious options. In this guide, by reviewing construction, pricing, performance, and more, we’ll help you think through the process of choosing between them.

Mattress Construction Comparison

Mattress performance is the result of how a mattress is built, and for this reason, a comparison should start by examining mattress construction.

Leesa

Leesa Mattress Construction
Leesa’s namesake mattress is 10” tall and its quilted cover is made with a blend of polyester and lycra. There are three foam layers inside the mattress.

The topmost layer is made with Avena foam and is 2” thick. Avena foam is a polyfoam designed by Leesa that is sometimes called a latex-like polyfoam. This means that the while the foam contours to the body, it also has significant bounce, giving it a feel that is more akin to latex than to traditional memory foam (like TEMPUR foam). The density of the Avena foam is 3.5 PCF, and it has an ILD of 20.

Beneath the Avena foam layer is 2” of memory foam that has a density of 3 PCF and ILD of 9. Placing the memory foam beneath the Avena foam augments the responsiveness and pressure point relief of the mattress.

The bottom layer of the Leesa is a 6” thick piece of polyfoam that has a density of 1.8 PCF and serves as the base for the comfort layer.

Tempur-Pedic

 

Tempur-Pedic mattresses are broken down into three main product lines: Cloud, Contour, and Flex. Cloud and Contour mattresses are all-foam, and the Flex mattresses are hybrids.

The Contour and Cloud mattresses all have a top layer of TEMPUR memory foam. Tempur-Pedic established their brand with this material that is known for being high-quality and excellent at contouring to the body. Below the memory foam is polyfoam that acts as the base of support foam for the TEMPUR foam. There is a lot of variation within the Tempur-Pedic products in terms of the the thicknesses and the firmness of these layers, which is why there are more than 10 different mattress models between the Cloud and Contour lines.

The Flex beds also use memory foam as the comfort layer. The support core in the Flex mattresses, though, is not foam. Instead, it is an array of pocketed innerspring coils. Pocketed coils are more responsive than other types of coils because each one can compress independent of the other coils around it. At the same time, the coils provide more bounce and resilience than in the Cloud and Contour mattresses.

Tempur-Pedic does not disclose detailed information about the composition of their mattresses because they classify this as proprietary. For example, they do not publish the thickness of the layers in any of their mattresses. They also do not disclose the density or ILD of their foams.

Firmness Comparison

If you’re going to invest in a mattress -- one that you’ll plan to use every night for many years -- of course you’ll want that mattress to be comfortable. Whether or not you’ll find a mattress comfortable is determined mostly by its firmness. How hard or soft a mattress feels directly shapes how much you’re likely to find the bed to be a welcoming place to rest and recuperate.

The most accepted way to describe mattress firmness is on a scale of 1-10. A 1 on this scale is a mattress that is the absolute softest while a 10 is the hardest. The range of 4-7, which is generally considered to be “Medium Firm,” is the most popular, but some customers prefer beds that are above or below this range.

The Leesa is a Medium Firm mattress that falls as a 6-7 on this scale. Tempur-Pedic’s mattresses are available in a broad range of firmness levels. The Cloud and Contour lines have options from 3-8 on the firmness scale, and the Flex line has options from 4-6.

Sleep Experience

The performance of a mattress can be difficult to judge on the whole. While we can and do look at overall customer satisfaction, it’s important to remember that the sleep experience is made up of many components. In this section, we’ll delve into how the Leesa and Tempur-Pedic compare with regard to many of those components. Depending on which are most important to you, it may help clear up which mattress would be better for you.

Temperature Control

Temperature control primarily has to do with whether or not a mattress sleeps hot. Sleeping hot can be a major barrier to getting a full night’s sleep. Overheating has two main causes: lack of airflow around the body and heat retention by the materials in the mattress.

The Leesa mattress has a major advantage compared to the Tempur-Pedic mattresses when it comes to temperature regulation. TEMPUR foam has a tendency toward heat retention, and its deep level of hug also can prevent air from moving around and cooling down the skin. Though Tempur-Pedic has worked to modify their materials to reduce heat retention, it remains an issue for many customers.

On the other hand, the Leesa’s Avena foam does not have significant heat buildup issues, and because it has a lot of resilience and only moderate sink, it is rare for customers to find that it reduces airflow in a significant way.

Motion Transfer

Motion isolation is a desirable mattress characteristic especially for couples or anyone who regularly shares a mattress with someone else (or even a pet!). Motion isolation prevents the movement on one part of the bed from being felt strongly on other parts of the bed.

Tempur-Pedic mattresses have fantastic motion isolation properties. They are among the best choices available for people who prioritize motion isolation because of the way that memory foam compresses and contours. The Leesa mattress is good at motion isolation, but the added bounce in the Avena foam and the more limited sink both mean that more motion is transferred than on the Tempur-Pedic beds. The motion isolation from the Leesa is enough for most couples, but for sleepers who are easily disrupted by movement, the Tempur-Pedic beds have an edge.

Responsiveness

To keep the body aligned, a mattress has to be responsive, which means that it contours to the body. Contouring in this context refers to how effectively the comfort layer of a mattress compresses in response to the amount of pressure that is applied at different points of the mattress. A mattress that can give more cushioning to the shoulders and hips is more likely to be able to keep the spine aligned and prevent issues with back pain.

Contouring is a strength of both of these mattresses and the Tempur-Pedic models in particular. Memory foam, which is used in both brands, promotes responsiveness, and the Tempur-Pedic beds have a long track record of pressure point relief. The Leesa mattress has earned a strong following because of its ability to be responsive without giving the feeling of sinking deeply into the mattress. Customers who want more hug are better off with the Tempur-Pedic, but both of these brands deliver excellent results when it comes to support.

Resilience and Bounce

Mattress foams are designed to compress when weight is placed on them and then to go back to their original size when the weight is taken off. Resilience is determined by how quickly that return to normal size happens. The more resilience, the faster the foam springs back, which can confer more bounce to the sleeping surface.

The Leesa mattress has more bounce than the Tempur-Pedic mattresses because of the latex-like Avena foam. This foam was designed by Leesa in large part for this feature because bounce can prevent feeling stuck in the bed. It can also be a boon for sexual activity since it facilitates easily moving on top of the bed.

The TEMPUR foam in the Tempur-Pedic mattresses generally is slow to rebound to its main shape. There is more bounce in the Flex hybrids -- a byproduct of the innerspring coils -- but this is still dampened by the memory foam.

Edge Support

The Flex hybrids from Tempur-Pedic have quality edge support, but the all-foam Tempur-Pedic mattresses and the Leesa all struggle when it comes to offering enough support at the edge of the bed. These all-foam beds do not have edge reinforcements, and the foam can feel unstable when you lie down or sit near the edge.

Off-gassing and Smell

Both the Leesa and Tempur-Pedic mattresses will have some issues with off-gassing immediately after they are brought into your home. These issues are comparable to other foam mattresses on the market. There is no health risk from this, but there may be an odor that lasts from a few hours to at most a few days.

Shipping, Trial, Warranty, and Returns

You can compare and contrast the policies for shipping, returns, warranties, and more for both the Leesa and Tempur-Pedic mattresses in the following table.

Leesa Tempur-Pedic
Delivery fee Free $25
How is it shipped? Bed-in-a-box White glove delivery
Old mattress removal? No Included with $25 delivery fee
Sleep trial length 100 nights 90 nights
Return cost and process No cost; company picks up Customer responsible for return shipping cost
Warranty length 10 years 10 years

Prices, Sizes, and Value

Not every Tempur-Pedic mattress is available in the 6 standard mattress sizes. As a result, we’ve listed the price range for the available mattresses from Tempur-Pedic at each size. These are included side-by-side with the prices for the Leesa in the table below.

Mattress Size Leesa Tempur-Pedic
Twin $525 $1,299 - $2,299
Twin XL $695 $1,299 - $4,299
Full $855 $1,649 - $3,649
Queen $995 $1,799 - $4,799
King $1,195 $2,499 - $8.599
California King $1,195 $2,499 - $8.599

The Tempur-Pedic mattresses are among the more expensive options on the market, and many of the models from Tempur-Pedic are clearly designed to be luxury purchases. By comparison, the Leesa mattress is affordably priced and within the budget of a much larger number of customers. Though the higher price of the Tempur-Pedic is worth it for many people who are prepared to invest in a mattress in a big way, from the perspective of value alone, the Leesa clearly wins the day.

Leesa Mattress vs. Tempur-Pedic Mattress – Which One Should You Buy?

The Tempur-Pedic and Leesa mattresses have a lot going for them, and if you’re reduced your choices down to these two brands, you’ve homed in on two top brands in the mattress industry. You may be wondering how to pick between them, and if that’s the case, we’ve got you covered.

Buy the Leesa mattress if you:

  • Want more bounce: the Avena foam in the Leesa is much more resilient than TEMPUR foam, so it makes a better comfort layer for people who want a springier feeling in their mattress.
  • Are worried about sleeping hot: the Leesa rarely has issues with overheating thanks to the design of its Avena foam. Compared to the Leesa, the Tempur-Pedic mattresses get many more customer complaints about sleeping hot.
  • Are focused on price and value: you can save a pretty penny by choosing the Leesa mattress, which delivers great performance for the price and is accessible to most budgets.
  • Like supporting companies with a social cause: for every 10 mattresses that they sell, Leesa donates one to a person in need.

 

Leesa Mattress

 

Buy the Tempur-Pedic mattress if you:

  • Trust in the track record: Tempur-Pedic was one of the first companies to bring memory foam to the market and has a solid and long-held reputation as a manufacturer of mattresses that deliver comfort and support. If you put a lot of faith in buying from a company with tenure and experience, the Tempur-Pedic is your choice.
  • Prefer more options: with three product lines and multiple models within each of those lines, the Tempur-Pedic brand is a better fit if you like having lots of choices.
  • Put a priority on motion isolation: no material isolates motion as well as memory foam, and the TEMPUR foam is especially well-known for this feature.
  • Want more hug: if you like the feeling of sinking into the mattress or being hugged by the foam, then the Tempur-Pedic mattresses are more likely to meet your expectations.
  • Want white-glove delivery: the $25 delivery fee for the Tempur-Pedic mattresses covers white-glove delivery, meaning they set up your new mattress and haul away your old one.

 

The Leesa and Tempur-Pedic mattresses are both well-designed and well-constructed, and not surprisingly, both get great reviews from customers. Though both are solid options, their differences -- in terms of price and performance -- can dictate which will better meet your needs, and by evaluating your priorities, you can make a savvy pick for your next mattress.

See some of our other mattress comparisons:

Table Of Contents

Read Our In-Depth Reviews