Leesa vs. Tuft & Needle Mattress
If you’ve been investigating your options for buying a new mattress online, you’ve probably found that Tuft & Needle and Leesa are two extremely popular and successful online mattress sellers. These companies have years of experience under their belts and a long list of positive customer reviews.
Tuft & Needle and Leesa both manufacture multiple mattress models (including the Mint by Tuft & Needle and the Sapira by Leesa); however, for the purposes of this review, we’re focusing on their original, flagship mattresses.
These flagship offerings are all-foam mattresses, but they have differences in the types of foam that they use and the way that the foams are layered within the mattress. There are also differences in price and feel that may swing your decision about which mattress is the better fit for you. In this comparison, we’ll give you all the background that you need to assess the benefits and downsides of these two well-known mattresses so that you can select one for your bedroom.
Mattress Construction Comparison
Tuft & Needle
The flagship, original mattress from Tuft & Needle is 10 inches tall and has a cover made with a blend of rayon and polyester. The interior of the mattress has a simple design with just two foam layers. The top layer is 3” thick and is made with Adaptive foam, a proprietary foam developed by Tuft & Needle. The density of this foam is 2.8 PCF. Adaptive foam was designed to have enough conforming to relieve pressure points but without as much sink or heat retention as traditional memory foam. The bottom layer is 7” of support polyfoam with density of 1.8 PCF that provides the base for the comfort layer.
Leesa’s flagship mattress is 10” tall and comes with a soft, quilted cover made with a blend of polyester and lycra. The internal construction features three foam layers. The topmost layer is 2” of a proprietary polyfoam designed by Leesa called Avena foam. Avena foam has clear contouring properties, but it has much more bounce, giving it a feel that is more like latex than traditional memory foam. The Avena foam has a density of 3.5 PCF and an ILD of 20.
Under the Avena foam, the second layer is 2” of memory foam with a density of 3 PCF and ILD of 9. Using memory foam in this way supplements the responsiveness of the mattress and allows it to further cushion the body’s pressure points. The bottom layer is 6” thick and is made with support polyfoam with a density of 1.8 PCF.
One of the primary ways of selecting a mattress is finding one that has the right feel for you. After all, your bed should be welcoming and relaxing, and it makes no sense to buy a mattress if it isn’t comfortable.
Comfort is determined primarily by firmness, which is how hard or soft a mattress feels. As you shop for mattresses, you’ll see terms like “soft,” “plush,” “medium firm,” and others used in different ways. To try to give some clarity to these terms, we use the typical firmness scale, which ranks the feel from 1-10. 1 is the softest that a mattress can be while 10 is the hardest.
Comfort is extremely subjective since every person has a different preference about how their mattress should feel. In general, medium-firm mattresses between 5 and 7 are preferred by the largest number of people, but there are also many models that are considerably firmer or softer.
The firmness level of the original Leesa and Tuft & Needle mattress is very similar. Both are considered to fall between 6 and 7 on the traditional firmness scale. The Tuft & Needle’s Adaptive foam has a reputation for feeling slightly firmer than the Leesa’s Avena foam, but by and large, the comfort feel is similar between these two options.
For any mattress comparison, it’s important to think not just about firmness but also about other elements of the performance of the mattress. In this section, we’ll compare and contrast the Leesa and Tuft & Needle with regard to some of the most important criteria that affect this sleep experience.
Sleeping hot can be problematic for many people as it can make it harder to get a good night’s sleep. It can also just be uncomfortable to wake up in a sweat. As a result, temperature control can be an important consideration when shopping for a mattress.
Sleeping hot usually happens when there is no airflow around the body which can happen if the mattress is pressed too closely up around the skin. In addition, overheating can be exacerbated by some mattress materials that hold in heat (such as traditional memory foam).
The Tuft & Needle and Leesa mattresses are both above average when it comes to temperature control. Neither has the kind of sink or heat retention issues associated with classic memory foams. Because the Tuft & Needle doesn’t hug the body as much, there is room for airflow, and because the Leesa has more bounce and resilience, it is easier to avoid sinking too deeply into the bed. There is a bit more contouring with the Leesa than the Tuft & Needle, which may cause it to sleep just slightly hotter, but this should only be perceptible to people who are already inclined to sleep hot.
Motion isolation is above average for both the Leesa and the Tuft & Needle mattresses. Most customers have no issues with motion from one partner being felt by another partner in the bed. Since the Leesa has a bit more bounce, it may transfer more motion, but in general, both of these mattresses are great choices for people who want strong motion isolation.
Responsiveness is a way of describing how supportive a mattress is. If a mattress is responsive, it provides tailored cushioning to the body, compressing more to accommodate the heavier parts of the body (such as the shoulders or pelvis). By providing this kind of support, the mattress can help maintain proper spinal alignment and avoid aches and pains, specifically those in the lower back.
Of these two mattresses, the Leesa is more responsive but only by a very small margin. Each mattress has enough responsiveness to provide a comfortable and supportive sleeping experience for sleepers in any sleeping position, including for side sleepers who tend to have more pronounced pressure points.
Resilience and Bounce
If the foam in a mattress springs back to its original shape quickly after pressure is removed from it, is has a bouncy feel and can be described as resilient. Some sleepers like a resilient mattress because it can be easier to move on the bed. This can be beneficial for avoiding feeling “stuck” in the mattress and can also be a boon for sexual activity.
The design of the Avena foam in the Leesa mattress gives it more bounce with a feel that is more comparable to latex. At the same time, the Tuft & Needle mattress also has average to above-average resilience. As a result, even though the Leesa is more resilient, most customers are still satisfied with the bounce offered by the Tuft & Needle.
For people who spend a lot of time on the edge of their mattress, whether sitting or lying down, the Leesa and Tuft & Needle may not offer sufficient support. Both are weak around the edges of the mattress. With less foam to offer support, the edge can feel like it is caving in when weight is applied there, and neither mattress has any design to add reinforcement to the edges to try to resolve this issue. If edge support is critical for you, you may find both of these mattresses to fall short of your needs.
Off-gassing and Smell
When you unbox and unpackage a foam mattress, it is a near certainty that there will be some initial smell that comes from the foam as it decompresses. This smell is not harmful and goes away quickly (usually within a few hours). Both of these mattresses will likely have a smell of this nature.
Shipping, Trial, Warranty, and Returns
When it comes to logistics of your purchase -- shipping, the sleep trial, returns, and the warranty -- the Leesa and Tuft & Needle are quite similar. You can review these policies in the table below.
|Tuft & Needle||Leesa|
|How is it shipped?||Bed-in-a-box||Bed-in-a-box|
|White glove delivery||No||No|
|Old mattress removal?||No||No|
|Sleep trial length||100 nights||100 nights|
|Return cost and process||No cost; company picks up||No cost; company picks up|
|Warranty length||10 years||10 years|
Prices, Sizes, and Value
One key differentiator between the Tuft & Needle and the Leesa is the price. You can review the prices for these mattresses in each of the offered sizes in the table below.
|Mattress Size||Tuft & Needle||Leesa|
The Tuft & Needle mattress offers more value than virtually any other mattress on the market. While you can find cheaper options, none of those bargain basement mattresses have the same attention-to-detail in their design nor the track record of satisfied customers as Tuft & Needle. If price is your key decision criteria, it’s hard to argue with the Tuft & Needle.
That said, the Leesa still represents an excellent value, and you can often pay a lower price than listed in the table through promotions or discounts offered by the company. The Leesa is more affordable than many other foam mattresses, and this particular mattress has a proven track record of customer satisfaction that many find easily makes it worth the cost.
Tuft & Needle Mattress vs. Leesa Mattress – Which One Should You Buy?
When it comes down to decision time, it can be tough to know which mattress is the right one to pick. There are a lot of factors to try to understand and balance, and it can be an overwhelming process to try to pick among two strong contenders like the Leesa and Tuft & Needle. In this section, we’ll try to give some clear differentiators that can help you select the mattress that’s most likely to work for you.
Buy the Tuft & Needle mattress if:
- Price and value are paramount: the Tuft & Needle costs significantly less than the Leesa and without any major sacrifice in terms of performance or track record. There’s arguably no better value in the mattress industry than the Tuft & Needle, and if you are price-conscious, it makes sense to take advantage of this.
Buy the Leesa mattress if you:
- Like more bounce: the resilience of the Avena foam in the Leesa mattress gives it a bouncier feel. If you prefer this springiness in your bed, then the Leesa is more likely to be the top choice for you.
- Want a denser foam: the foams in the Tuft & Needle are of lower density than those in the Leesa. While this may not noticeably affect the feel of the mattress, it may affect the long-term durability as a higher-density foam is likely to hold up better over time.
- Want to support a cause: Leesa has a policy to give back by donating one mattress to people in need for every 10 mattresses that they sell.
As all-foam mattresses with comparable firmness levels and performance, the Leesa and Tuft & Needle mattresses have more similarities than differences. If you’ve narrowed down to these, at the very least, you know you’re choosing between two excellent options.
The fact that each comes with a long sleep trial also should offer some insurance that you have the option to try it out in person and that you aren’t married to the first mattress you choose. Even though you aren’t locked into any choice, whether it’s the Tuft & Needle or the Leesa, we expect you to love the bed you pick.