Nectar vs. Allswell Luxe Mattress Comparison

Updated on September 21, 2020 While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about our affiliate program here.
 

If you are looking for an affordable, high-quality mattress, chances are you have come across Nectar and Allswell. Both Nectar and Allswell focus on manufacturing affordable mattresses with premium materials. These online companies offer the popular bed-in-a-box option that makes shipping and assembly easier.

Allswell is a home brand launched by Walmart in 2018. The company offers 3 hybrid mattress styles: the Allswell mattress; the Luxe mattress; and the Supreme mattress. This review will focus on the Allswell Luxe mattress. Allswell also offers bedding and sleep accessories, including pillows and blankets. The company focuses on stylish luxury products at an affordable price point. Allswell also partners with charitable organizations, with 70% of their mattress donations going to foster care organizations.

Nectar launched in 2017. It currently only offers one memory foam mattress style, the Nectar mattress, which we review in this comparison. The company has also expanded its product line to include bed frames and bedding. As a popular bed-in-a-box option, Nectar pairs premium materials and high-quality construction with affordability. Nectar also backs their mattress with a 365-night sleep trial and a forever warranty.

Mattress Construction Comparison

Nectar

The Nectar mattress is an 11-inch tall memory foam mattress with four layers of foam. The mattress is covered with a breathable Tencel fabric cover for added air circulation.

The top layer of the Nectar mattress is 1-inch of quilted gel memory foam. This layer is more breathable than traditional memory foam, and gel-infused for a cooling feel. As memory foam can retain heat and sleep hot, this layer offsets that for better temperature regulation.

Below the quilted gel memory foam is a 3-inch layer of gel memory foam with a density of 3.5 pounds per cubic foot (PCF). This layer also offers a cooler feel than traditional memory foam. The top two layers of memory foam provide cushioning support and pressure point relief by gently contouring to the shape of your body.

The third layer is 1.75 inches of adaptive hi-core memory foam. Nectar is the only direct-to-client mattress company that uses this foam, as it is heavy and expensive. However, it provides optimal pressure point relief, full-body support, and more bounce than traditional memory foam.

The support base of the Nectar mattress is 5.25 inches of high-density support foam with a density of 2.2 PCF. This provides additional support.

The unique combination of cooling gel memory foam and adaptive, high-density foams provides full-body support and cushioning. The foams used are CertiPUR-US certified and made without the use of harmful chemicals or toxins.

Allswell Luxe

The Allswell Luxe is a 12-inch tall hybrid mattress that combines innerspring support with memory foam. The mattress is comprised of four layers for full-body support.

The top layer is a plush, quilted layer with Allswell’s signature cooling SwirlFoam. The second layer is 2 inches of copper gel-infused memory foam. This layer is antimicrobial and relieves pressure points and joint aches and pains. It is also cooler than traditional memory foam. Below the copper gel-infused memory foam is 1 inch of high-density foam for added support and firmness.

The base layer of the Allswell Luxe mattress is individually wrapped coils. This layer provides full-body support. The individually wrapped coils help to minimize motion transfer. The perimeter is reinforced with higher-gauge coils.

Allswell does not disclose the density of the foams used. The mattress is CertiPUR-US certified and made without harmful chemicals or toxins.

The innerspring foundation and memory foam comfort layers provide a balance of cushioned comfort and proper support.

Allswell Supreme Construction

Firmness Comparison

Understanding mattress firmness is essential to selecting the right mattress for you. Mattress firmness relates to how comfortable the mattress is, which affects your overall sleep experience. This is subjective and depends on additional factors including personal preference, sleeping position, and weight. It is also important to note that firmness and support are not the same. Both soft and firm mattresses can provide optimal support, as support is a measure of how well your spine is kept in alignment. Since firmness affects everything from temperature regulation to motion transfer, it is important to find the right firmness for you.

Though firmness is subjective, it is typically rated on a scale from 1 (extremely soft) to 10 (extremely firm). Medium-firm mattresses tend to appeal to the widest audience, as they provide contouring support without allowing you to sink too far into the mattress. Both the Nectar mattress and the Allswell Luxe mattress are considered medium-firm.

The Allswell Luxe mattress is described by the company as medium-firm in the range of 4.5 to 6.5 out of 10 on the firmness scale. The combined layers of memory foam, high-density foam, and coils result in a firmer feel that is closer to a 6.0. The top layers of memory foam provide contouring support and cushioning. The high-density foam transition layer prevents the feeling of sinking into the mattress too far. The innerspring spring support base of individually wrapped coils provides a firm foundation for the mattress.

The Nectar mattress is also medium-firm, and is rated as a 6.0 out of 10. The top four inches of memory foam provide comfort by gently contouring to the shape of your body and relieving pressure points. The high-density foam foundation provides additional support.

Both mattresses are designed to provide a balance of cushioning and support for all sleeping positions.

Sleep Experience

In addition to mattress firmness, the following elements are important for a comfortable sleep experience. How well a mattress regulates temperature, prevents motion transfer, and responds to pressure should be considered when deciding which mattress is right for you. It is also necessary to consider resilience and bounce, edge support, and any potential off-gassing. See how the Nectar mattress and Allswell Luxe mattress perform below.

Temperature Control

In order for a mattress to regulate temperature, the materials and construction should promote airflow. As memory foam responds to both heat and pressure to contour closely to the shape of your body, it can tend to sleep hot. The more closely it conforms, the less airflow there is around your body as you sleep. Both the Allswell Luxe and Nectar mattresses use memory foam in their comfort layers but offset heat absorption in unique ways.

The Allswell Luxe mattress has a top layer of cooling SwirlFoam and a quilted top panel for added airflow. The second layer of copper gel-infused memory foam sleeps cooler than traditional memory foam. Additionally, the pocket coil support layer increases air circulation throughout the mattress.

The Nectar mattress has a quilted memory foam top layer that also promotes airflow around the body. The Tencel fabric cover wicks away both moisture and heat for a cooler feel. The gel memory foam distributes heat better than traditional memory foam, and the breathable base layer improves overall airflow.

Motion Transfer

How well a mattress absorbs movement and isolates it to one area depends on the materials used. Excellent motion isolation prevents movements from transferring from one area of the bed to another. This is an important consideration for those who share the bed with a partner, and those who are easily disturbed by movement or noise throughout the night. Memory foam is known for its ability to absorb motion and prevent it from transferring to other areas of the bed.

The Allswell Luxe mattress has a quilted foam cover and a memory foam comfort layer that absorb motion. Though innerspring mattresses typically facilitate movement, the individually-wrapped pocket coils of the Luxe mattress reduce motion transfer.

The Nectar mattress has an all-foam construction that reduces motion transfer. The top layers are 4 inches of memory foam that absorb and isolate motion exceptionally well.

Responsiveness

In order to provide cushioning and support, a mattress should respond proportionately to pressure. Memory foam is a responsive material, as it reacts to heat and pressure to conform to the shape of your body. This contouring relieves pressure points while keeping your spine aligned.

The Allswell Luxe mattress has a 2-inch layer of copper gel foam that relieves muscle and joint pain. The top layers of foam provide gentle contouring to reduce pressure on the hips, shoulders, and back. The individually pocketed coils are more responsive than traditional innersprings. The dense base prevents the feeling of sinking in.

The Nectar mattress has thicker layers of memory foam for additional contouring. The adaptive hi-core foam layer is soft and supportive, and the foam construction contours to the shape of your body. This provides pressure point relief and cushioning for the hips, shoulders, and back.

Resilience and Bounce

Resilience measures how quickly the mattress returns to its original shape after pressure is applied. Higher-resilience mattresses have more bounce and return to their shape quickly when you move or leave the bed. This helps to facilitate movement and is better for sexual activity. As memory foam is designed to reduce motion transfer and absorb movement, it tends to be low-resilience. This can inhibit movement.

Though the Allswell Luxe mattress uses memory foam in its comfort layers, the medium-firmness prevents the feeling of sinking in or being stuck in the mattress. The support layer of pocketed coils adds bounce to the mattress, which helps facilitate movement.

The Nectar mattress has a lower resilience due to its thick layers of memory foam, but the adaptive hi-core foam layer adds rebound and bounce. The medium-firm feel also prevents the feeling of sinking into the mattress.

Edge Support

Proper edge support increases the sleepable surface area of the bed, as the perimeter should be as supportive as the center of the bed. A reinforced perimeter helps to prevent sinking or sagging along the edges of the mattress, especially if you are prone to sleeping or sitting at the edge of the bed.

The Allswell Luxe mattress has a reinforced perimeter with higher-gauge coils in the innerspring layer. This adds edge support to the mattress. The memory foam comfort layers respond to pressure, so you may notice the perimeter feels slightly softer if you sit on the edge.

The Nectar mattress is designed to be medium-firm from edge to edge. The high-density foam base adds support throughout the mattress. However, the perimeter is not reinforced. This is most noticeable when sitting on the edge of the mattress.

Off-gassing and Smell

Off-gassing is common in mattresses with memory foam construction and vacuum-sealed packaging. Both the Nectar mattress and the Allswell Luxe mattress are CertiPUR-US Certified and made without the use of harmful chemicals. As both are bed-in-a-box styles that are compressed and vacuum-sealed, there may be a noticeable smell when first unboxed. This smell is not considered harmful and typically dissipates within a few hours in a well-ventilated room. At most, the smell may last a couple of days.

 

Shipping, Trial, Warranty, and Returns

When shopping online for a mattress, it is important to consider delivery fees, sleep trial lengths, and the returns process. These factors can provide additional peace of mind when you are not able to try out the mattress before purchasing. Read on for key details regarding Nectar’s and Allswell’s policies.

NectarAllswell Luxe
Delivery feeFree shipping in the contiguous United States and $150 shipping fee for Alaska and HawaiiFree shipping in the contiguous United States and $50 shipping fee for Alaska and Hawaii
How is it shipped?Bed-in-a-boxBed-in-a-box
Old mattress removal?White Glove Delivery and old mattress removal is $149White Glove Delivery is $99 and old mattress removal is an additional $50 unless the sleep trial is waived at checkout
Sleep trial length365-Night Trial 100-Night Trial
Return cost and processFree returns and company coordinates pick-upFree returns and company coordinates pick-up
Warranty lengthForever Lifetime Warranty10-Year Limited Warranty
 

Prices, Sizes, and Value

A high-quality mattress is an investment that should last a reasonably long time. When deciding which mattress is right for you, it is important to take your budget into consideration.

Mattress SizeNectarAllswell Luxe
Twin$499$395
Twin XL$569$445
Full$699$545
Queen$799$645
King$999$845
California King$999$845

Both Nectar and Allswell are dedicated to offering high-quality mattresses at an affordable price point. As a result, both are less expensive than the industry averages for memory foam and hybrid mattresses. Though the Allswell Luxe mattress is slightly less expensive than the Nectar mattress, Nectar often has promotions and discounts available. Nectar also offers a longer sleep trial and lifetime warranty, making it a valuable investment. Both companies use premium materials while minimizing costs, making them great options for those looking for a luxurious mattress on a budget.

 

Nectar vs. Allswell Luxe Mattress – Which One Should You Buy

Even after considering all of these factors, it can be difficult to decide whether the Nectar or the Allswell Luxe is the right mattress for you. Though they do have some similarities, there are key differences that set each apart. We compiled the list below to help simplify the decision-making process.

Buy the Nectar mattress if you:

1. Want an all-foam bed

The all-foam construction of the Nectar mattress provides contouring support and excellent motion isolation. If you know you prefer the feel of a solid foam mattress, the Nectar may be a better choice for you.

2. Want a longer sleep trial

Nectar backs their mattress with a 365-night trial, giving you a full year to decide if the mattress is right for you. This trial length is significantly longer than Allswell’s 100-night sleep trial.

3. Prefer a lifetime warranty

The generous Forever Warranty of the Nectar mattress protects the mattress in the event of defects in workmanship or material for life. While both mattresses are built to last with high-quality, durable materials, the lifetime warranty of the Nectar mattress provides additional peace of mind.

 

Buy the Allswell Luxe mattress if you:

1. Budget is your first priority

With a focus on affordability, the Allswell Luxe mattress is slightly less expensive than the Nectar mattress. While both cost less than the industry average, the Allswell Luxe has a slight advantage when it comes to cost.

2. Want a little more bounce

The Allswell Luxe mattress combines the benefits of a memory foam mattress and an innerspring mattress. The comfort layers provide gentle contouring support, while the innerspring coils add bounce and resilience. This helps to facilitate movement and is better for sex or those who struggle to get out of bed without pain.

3. Want to support a charitable cause

Allswell partners with Good360 and donates mattresses to foster care organizations. In addition, Allswell donates $25 to Good360 for every verified product review (up to $250,000 per year).

Allswell Luxe mattress

Nectar and Allswell are both well-known for creating high-quality mattresses at an affordable price point. The Nectar mattress provides full-body support with responsive memory foam. Nectar’s generous 365-night trial and lifetime warranty provide additional peace of mind. With gel memory foam and a breathable base layer, the Nectar mattress sleeps cooler than traditional memory foam mattresses.

The Allswell Luxe mattress is a luxury hybrid mattress with contouring memory foam comfort layers. The individually pocketed coils reduce motion transfer and provide additional support. The 100-night trial gives you a chance to adjust to the mattress and determine if it is right for you, and the 10-year warranty covers any defects in workmanship and material. The Luxe mattress also sleeps cooler due to its innerspring layer and gel-infused memory foam. Either mattress would be a great choice for a comfortable night’s sleep.

See how the Nectar compares to other mattresses: