Nectar vs. Allswell Mattress Comparison

While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about our affiliate program here.

Nectar and Allswell are two well-known names in the online mattress industry. Both companies offer quality products at attractive price points that will appeal to a wide range of sleepers.

The Nectar mattress was inaugurated in 2017 and features an all-foam construction with plush layers of gel-infused memory foam. Nectar only makes one mattress, although the company also sells bedding and bed frames.

Allswell is a new online mattress company backed by Walmart. The company launched in 2018 and currently offers a range of bedroom accessories including three mattresses: the Allswell, the Allswell Luxe, and the Allswell Supreme. For this review, we’ll be focusing on the flagship Allswell hybrid mattress.

In this Nectar vs. Allswell review we’ll look at how each mattress provides a different sleep experience, giving you all the information you need to decide which mattress is right for you.

Mattress Construction Comparison

Nectar

The Nectar mattress has an all-foam design with four layers in total. It’s 11 inches tall and features a Tencel cover with a non-slip bottom. There’s also an inch of gel memory foam quilted into the top cover, which enhances airflow and gives the mattress a luxurious feel.

The next layer is 3 inches tall and features a semi-open gel memory foam with a density of 3.5 pounds per cubic foot (PCF). Under this is a transitional layer made of Adaptive Hi-core Memory Foam. This layer supplies some support and resilience to counteract the layers of memory foam.

The support core consists of a thick layer of high-density (HD) polyfoam. This foam has a density of 2.2 PCF and has been perforated with extra channels to help it breathe.

 

Allswell

The Allswell is a 10-inch tall memory foam hybrid mattress. The cover is made of 90% polyester and 10% spandex and feels smooth to the touch.

Quilted into the cover is a ¾ inch layer of gel memory foam. This is a proprietary CoolFlow™ open-cell foam that is breathable and helps the mattress sleep cool. Underneath this is a 2-inch transitional layer of HD polyfoam with a density of 1.5 PCF.

The mattress has a 6-inch tall support core made with pocketed coils. The edges use higher-gauge coils with a tighter turn that help provide reinforced edge support. Under the coils there is another thin layer of the same HD polyfoam.

 

Allswell construction

Firmness Comparison

The first thing you’ll probably notice about a mattress is how hard or soft it feels, otherwise known as its firmness level. Everybody has their own preference when it comes to the “perfect” mattress firmness, and a mattress that feels firm to one person may feel plush to another. Your body type, sleeping position, and other factors all play a role in determining what kind of mattress you’ll prefer.

To help describe how firm or plush a mattress is, we usually give it a number from 1 to 10, with 10 being the firmest. The majority of people prefer a medium-firm mattress, around a 6.5 out of 10.

The Nectar mattress is just that, approximately a 6.5 on a scale of 1 to 10. This mattress is a good choice for side sleepers, who will find that the memory foam provides ample cushioning under pressure points like the hips and shoulders.

The Allswell mattress falls around a 7.5 on the firmness scale, a little on the firmer side. The comfort layer is plush but fairly thin - possibly too thin for lighter-weight side sleepers, who may feel some pressure points. The firm polyfoam layer should help prevent the hips from sinking in too far when sleeping on your back or stomach.

Sleep Experience

Due to the variations in the way they’re made, the Allswell and Nectar mattresses will each offer a different sleep experience. Below are some important things to take into consideration when choosing a mattress.

Temperature Control

Depending on the materials used and the way they are constructed, some mattresses will naturally retain more heat than others. If you’re someone who tends to sleep hot, you’ll want to look for a mattress that doesn’t trap heat.

Memory foam contours so closely that it doesn’t leave much room for airflow. In order to prevent it from trapping too much heat, the Nectar mattress has a breathable Tencel cover and gel-infused memory foam. The channels in the base layer will also increase breathability.

The gel memory foam in the Allswell mattress doesn’t trap as much heat as traditional memory foam, and the polyfoam transition layer will prevent sleepers from sinking in too far and restricting airflow. The pocketed coils also allow for great airflow that should prevent the mattress from sleeping hot.

Motion Transfer

Usually, people who share the bed with a partner prefer a mattress that does a good job of isolating motion to the immediate area. Memory foam is considered one of the best materials for preventing motion transfer due to its ability to contour locally in response to pressure and heat.

The Allswell mattress has individually pocketed coils, which move independently of each other and won’t transfer movement across the bed like typical innerspring coils do. The memory foam layer also helps isolate motion.

All-foam mattresses tend to excel at motion isolation, and the Nectar mattress is no exception. The thick memory foam comfort layers will absorb most motion and let you sleep soundly even when your partner is tossing and turning.

Responsiveness

A responsive mattress should allow the heavier parts of the body to sink in just enough to eliminate pressure points, while still providing support to keep your spine aligned.

The thin memory foam layer in the Allswell mattress will cradle your body, but you won’t get much of a “hug” feeling as you would with a thicker layer. The pocketed coils in the support layer underneath will provide contoured support for your spine.

The memory foam in the Nectar mattress will compress in response to pressure, relieving pressure points and providing support where it’s needed. In turn, the polyfoam base layer will ensure that your spine is properly supported.

Resilience and Bounce

The resilience of a mattress refers to how fast the material springs back after pressure is lifted. This “bouncy” quality is advantageous for sex and for combination sleepers, as both of these are activities that require moving around on the bed. Mattresses with low resilience can sometimes lead to the feeling of being trapped in the bed.

Thanks to the pocketed coils and the fact that the memory foam layer is relatively thin, the Allswell mattress should have plenty of bounce. It will be easy to move around on top of this mattress, which makes it suitable for sex and for sleepers who frequently reposition throughout the night.

The transition layer in the Nectar mattress does provide some bounce. However, because it has so many layers of memory foam, the Nectar mattress won’t present a very resilient sleeping surface.

Edge Support

The Achilles heel for many mattresses is the perimeter, which will often feel unstable when you’re lying or sitting on the edge of the bed. Some mattress models will naturally provide strong edges, while others will have to rely on creative techniques to reinforce the edges.

Hybrid mattresses usually enjoy strong edge support due to the strong base layer. The Allswell also uses thicker-gauge coils in the support layer to provide reinforced edge support on two sides, so you should be able to comfortably share the bed or sit on the edge without falling off.

Due to the nature of their construction and the way the foams compress, foam mattresses often suffer from weak edges. While the firm base layer will ensure the mattress doesn’t sag too much at the edges, the Nectar lacks dedicated edge support. As a result, this is not the best choice for people who spend a lot of time on the edge of the bed.

Off-gassing and Smell

Most foam mattresses will emit a faint off-gassing smell when you first unwrap them, and you may notice this with the Allswell and Nectar mattress. This smell is harmless and should disappear within a few hours, or a few days at the very most, in a well-ventilated room.

The foams used in both the Allswell and the Nectar mattresses are CertiPUR-US® certified, which guarantees them to be low in volatile organic compound (VOC) emissions. The cover of the Nectar mattress also carries the OEKO-TEX® Standard 100, Class 1 label, which certifies that it’s free from harmful substances.

Shipping, Trial, Warranty, and Returns

The logistics of purchasing and receiving a mattress can be confusing. Knowing a company’s policies can help you ensure you have the buying experience you want.

Nectar Allswell
Delivery fee Free for the contiguous United States; $150 for Alaska and Hawaii Free to contiguous U.S.
How is it shipped? Bed-in-a-box White glove delivery
Old mattress removal? Included in the $149 white glove delivery service At additional cost
Sleep trial length 365-Night Trial 100-Night Trial
Return cost and process Free returns and company coordinates pick-up Free returns and company coordinates pick-up
Warranty length Forever Lifetime Warranty 10 Years

Prices, Sizes, and Value

When shopping for a mattress, it’s important to find a balance between quality and affordability. With any luck, you’ll be sleeping on it for many years, so you want to invest in a product you can trust.

Nectar
Allswell
Mattress Size Price
Twin $499
Twin XL $569
Full $699
Queen $799
King $999
California King $999
Mattress Size Price
Twin $245
Twin XL $265
Full $315
Queen $345
King $420
California King $420

The Nectar and the Allswell mattresses both offer great value for money. The prices of both mattresses fall below the industry average for mattresses of this quality, and you may even find further discounts during major holidays.

If you’re on a tight budget, then it’s hard to argue with the Allswell mattress. However, the durable materials, as well as the generous sleep trial and warranty of the Nectar mattress, suggest that this mattress is built to last.

Nectar Mattress vs. Allswell Mattress – Which One Should You Buy?

Still having trouble deciding between the Allswell vs. Nectar mattresses? Here’s a quick overview of their main differences. If you identify very strongly with something on this list, it could indicate you’d be better off with that mattress.

Buy the Nectar mattress if you:

1. Are a side sleeper

The Nectar mattress has several thick layers of memory foam that should do a fantastic job of relieving pressure points when sleeping on your side.

2. Have a restless sleeping partner

Thanks to the memory foam, the Nectar mattress does a great job of minimizing motion transfer. This will come in handy if your sleeping partner can’t stay still, or if you yourself have a habit of nighttime visits to the bathroom.

3. Value peace of mind

Nectar Sleep stands behind its mattress with a year-long sleep trial and forever warranty. This is an indication that the company really believes in its product, and you can rest easy knowing any problems should be taken care of.

 

 

Buy the Allswell mattress if you:

1. Are price-conscious

At just $345 for a queen hybrid mattress, the Allswell is among the cheapest of the well-known bed-in-a-box brands. If you’re on a budget, this is a clear winner.

2. Care about aesthetics

Allswell is big on design and the company sells curated “looks” that include everything you need in the bedroom, from the mattress to the bedding to the accessories.

3. Need more support

Hybrid mattresses combine the pressure-relieving benefits of plush comfort layers with the enhanced support of springs. The pocketed coils in the Allswell mattress do a great job of providing support for back sleepers, stomach sleepers, and heavyweight sleepers.

 

Choosing between the Nectar and the Allswell mattresses may be difficult. Both companies offer affordable mattresses with a luxury feel.

As a hybrid mattress, the Allswell is better-suited to people who need more support. The quilted memory foam gives it a plush sleeping surface, while the polyfoam transition layer and pocketed coils provide contoured support and a bit of bounce for those who like a mattress that facilitates movement.

In contrast, the Nectar’s thick layers of memory foam will provide above-average pressure relief, which is especially attractive to side sleepers. Thanks to its proprietary foams, the mattress provides the extreme contouring of memory foam without the heat that usually accompanies it. The year-long sleep trial gives you ample time to test out the mattress.

Whichever mattress you choose, you can feel confident that you’re getting a great deal. The Nectar and Allswell mattresses are competitively priced and offer great bang for your buck.

See how Nectar and Allswell compare to other mattresses: