Nectar vs. Puffy Mattress Comparison

While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about our affiliate program here.

Nectar and Puffy are both relatively new to the mattress industry but have quickly become popular. If you are looking for a high-quality memory foam mattress, chances are you have come across these two companies.

Nectar was founded in 2017, with a focus on creating an affordable memory foam mattress that is comfortable for everyone. To give you a chance to try out the mattress, Nectar offers an extended 365-night sleep trial. The Nectar mattress is also backed by a Forever Warranty.

Puffy was also founded in 2017 after years of research and development. The Puffy mattress is manufactured through environmentally friendly practices with zero emissions. Puffy has since expanded its collection to include the Puffy Lux mattress and offers a lifetime warranty on both.

For this review, we focus on the Nectar mattress and the original Puffy mattress. These mattresses are both all-foam with contouring support. While they do have some similarities, it is important to understand their differences in order to determine which one is best for you.

Mattress Construction Comparison

Nectar

The Nectar mattress is 11 inches tall, constructed of four layers of memory foam. Its Tencel cover is soft and breathable and wicks away moisture as you sleep.

The top layer of the Nectar mattress is 1 inch of quilted gel-infused memory foam. This layer contours to your body, while providing a cooler sleep than traditional memory foam. The second layer is 3 inches of premium gel memory foam with a density of 3.5 PCF (pounds per cubic foot). This contouring layer distributes your body weight evenly for a supportive feel.

The third layer is 1.75 inches of adaptive hi-core memory foam. This memory foam is supportive and responsive. It is also designed to bounce back more quickly than traditional memory foam, providing more resilience to the mattress. Nectar is the only direct-to-consumer mattress company that uses this foam.

The base layer is 5.25 inches of foam. This supports the comfort and transition layers, which provide the medium-firm feel of the mattress. Nectar is CertiPUR-US certified, meaning the materials used are non-toxic and non-carcinogenic.

 

Puffy

The Puffy mattress is comprised of three layers of foam and is 10 inches tall. The cover is stain resistant and Oeko-Tex Standard 100 certified, meaning it is made without harmful chemicals.

The top layer of the Puffy mattress is 2 inches of gel-infused memory foam, referred to as the Cooling Cloud Foam layer. This layer contours closely to your body while pulling away body heat for temperature neutrality. It is designed to relieve pressure points while keeping your spine aligned.

The second layer is 2 inches of Climate Comfort polyfoam. This foam is designed to maintain a consistent temperature and even support. The third layer is 6 inches of Firm Core Support polyfoam, which adds stability to the mattress. It also provides pressure point relief and spinal alignment. Puffy does not disclose the density of its foam layers. The foams used are CertiPUR-US Certified.

Puffy mattress layers construction

Firmness Comparison

Determining whether a mattress feels comfortable depends on multiple factors, but finding the right firmness is key. How plush or firm a mattress feels will affect how comfortably you sleep on it. Firmness is also affected by body weight, sleeping position, and personal preference. Though comfort is subjective, firmness is often referred to on a scale from 1 to 10. Though 1 is extremely soft and 10 is extremely firm, most mattresses are rated between a 4 to 7. This medium firmness appeals to a wide range of people and is the most popular.

The Nectar mattress is available in one firmness option, which is around a 6.0 on the firmness scale. Since it is considered medium-firm, it provides support and contouring for most sleeping positions without the feeling of sinking in. The comfort layers of gel memory foam conform to the shape of your body, while the adaptive hi-core memory foam and base layer provide proper support and spinal alignment.

The Puffy mattress is also available in one firmness option and is considered to be medium-firm with a rating between 6 to 8 on the firmness scale. The Puffy mattress has a thicker foam core support layer that adds firmness to the mattress. This is designed to provide pressure point relief while keeping your spine aligned. The gel memory foam top layer contours to the shape of your body for additional support and comfort.

Sleep Experience

In addition to mattress firmness, it is also important to consider additional factors when shopping for a mattress. Temperature control, motion transfer, responsiveness, and support are among the key experience elements for a comfortable night’s sleep. Read on for how the Nectar vs. Puffy mattresses compare.

Temperature Control

How well a mattress regulates temperature depends on the materials used. Memory foam has a tendency to absorb and retain heat. It responds to warmth and pressure for a customized, contoured feel. However, when memory foam contours too closely to your body, it can prevent air from circulating. While memory foam is known for sleeping hot, both Nectar and Puffy take measures to prevent this.

The gel-infused top layer of the Nectar mattress is quilted in order to improve airflow. Since both comfort layers are gel-infused, they are cooler than traditional memory foam. The base layer is also breathable. The Nectar mattress may still feel warm if you tend to sleep hot, though these added design features help to control temperature.

The Puffy mattress has climate-adaptive materials to regulate the temperature of the mattress and provide a cooler sleep environment. The top layer of gel-infused memory foam pulls heat away from your body as you sleep. The second layer stays temperature neutral, as it is less prone to expanding or contracting with temperature changes.

Motion Transfer

Memory foam absorbs motion, isolating it to one area of the bed. This reduces motion transfer so that you are not disturbed by your partner’s movements. The Nectar mattress has good motion isolation, as its foam layers absorb movements and prevent them from transferring across the bed. The thick memory foam comfort layers of the Puffy mattress also absorb and isolate motion well. Both are great options if motion isolation is a priority.

Responsiveness

A supportive mattress should respond proportionately to your pressure points. Memory foam reacts directly to pressure and body heat in order to conform to your shape and distribute your weight evenly. Contouring support alleviates pressure points while keeping your spine aligned. The Puffy mattress is designed for pressure point relief and spinal alignment. The thick memory foam comfort layers cushion your hips and shoulders, while the Firm Core layer adds support. Both mattresses are made of responsive materials that balance comfort and support.

Resilience and Bounce

Resilience in a mattress determines how quickly it returns to its original shape when you change positions or leave the bed. It also helps to facilitate movement. Generally, memory foam is low-resilience with little bounce. Since it is designed to conform to your body and responds to heat and pressure, it can be slower to return to its original shape.

The Nectar mattress has a little more bounce than traditional memory foam, due to the adaptive hi-core memory foam support layer. The Puffy mattress is designed with thick memory foam that makes it ideal for motion isolation and contouring, but it has less resilience as a result.

Both the Nectar mattress and Puffy mattress are medium-firm, which helps facilitate movement and prevents the feeling of being stuck. But if you are looking for a mattress with high resilience and more bounce, an innerspring or latex mattress may be a better fit.

Edge Support

Memory foam mattresses tend to lack edge support, as the foam compresses under pressure. Having proper edge support increases the sleepable surface area of the bed and prevents sagging over time.

The Nectar mattress is designed for a consistent firmness edge to edge. However, as the mattress does not have a reinforced perimeter, you may notice the lack of support when you sit on the edge of the bed.

The edge support of the Puffy mattress is also average, as it does not have a reinforced perimeter. The thick comfort layers of memory foam compress easily, which is more pronounced when sitting on the edge of the mattress.

Off-gassing and Smell

Foam mattresses tend to have a noticeable smell at first, referred to as off-gassing. This smell is not harmful but is a result of the synthetic materials used in the mattress. Both Nectar and Puffy mattresses have a faint smell when new, though it should dissipate within a few hours in a well-ventilated room. At most, this smell will last a couple of days.

Shipping, Trial, Warranty, and Returns

When shopping online for a mattress, it is important to take the below factors into consideration. The delivery method, sleep trial length, returns process, and warranty length for both Nectar and Puffy are outlined below.

Nectar Puffy
Delivery fee Free within the contiguous U.S.

$150 shipping fee for Alaska and Hawaii

Free in the contiguous U.S.

Additional fee for Alaska and Hawaii

How is it shipped? Bed-in-a-box Bed-in-a-box
Old mattress removal? Available for extra fee Not available
Sleep trial length 365 nights 101 nights
Return cost and process Free returns; company picks up Free returns after 30 days; company picks up
Warranty length Forever lifetime warranty Lifetime warranty

Prices, Sizes, and Value

As the Nectar mattress and Puffy mattress differ in price, it is important to take budget into consideration when determining which mattress is right for you. Prices are listed below.

Mattress Size Nectar Puffy
Twin $499 $795
Twin XL $569 $825
Full $699 $995
Queen $799 $1,150
King $999 $1,350
California King $999 $1,350

Nectar has built its reputation around designing a high-quality memory foam mattress that is durable and affordable. Because of this, Nectar is less expensive than the average memory foam mattress. The Puffy mattress is more expensive than Nectar, though its pricing still comes in below the industry average. Promotions and sales are offered seasonally by both Nectar and Puffy, which may reduce the above prices by 15 to 30 percent.

Nectar and Puffy both use innovative design and high-quality materials. With generous lifetime warranties, both the Nectar mattress and Puffy mattress are sound investments.

Nectar vs. Puffy Mattress - Which One Should You Buy

Making the final decision between two high-quality memory foam mattresses can be difficult, even after considering all the factors detailed in this comparison. Though the Nectar mattress and Puffy mattress have some similarities, there are key factors that set them apart. Read on for our list of differentiators to help you decide which of these two memory foam mattresses may be the best for you.

Buy the Nectar mattress if you:

1. Take your time making decisions

Nectar’s 365-night sleep trial is among the longest in the industry. If you tend to take your time with big decisions, Nectar’s sleep trial gives you a full year to decide if it’s the right fit for you.

2. Want the more affordable option

Though both Nectar and Puffy price their mattresses below the industry average, the Nectar mattress is more affordable. If you’re on a budget, Nectar may be a better fit.

3. Need White Glove Delivery

Having your old mattress removed and a new mattress set-up upon delivery is an option with Nectar. This is not a service that Puffy provides.

 

 

Buy the Puffy mattress if you:

1. Tend to sleep hot

The top two layers of the Puffy mattress are specifically designed to maintain temperature neutrality for a comfortable night’s sleep. The cooling top layer draws heat away from the body, while the second layer stabilizes the temperature of the bed.

2. Want a stain-resistant cover

The fabric cover of the Puffy mattress is stain-resistant. It can also be unzipped, removed, and washed as needed.

3. Support a charitable cause

Puffy donates mattresses to children’s shelters. The company has social media promotions and currently donates one mattress for every ten posts tagged with #puffydonation.