Puffy vs. Leesa Mattress Comparison

While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about our affiliate program here.

Choosing which mattress to buy is a major decision that shouldn’t be taken lightly. A mattress is a major purchase that will likely impact your health and life for years to come. There are many online mattress companies and it can be difficult to discern how they and their products differ from each other when viewing their websites alone.

This guide will help you compare the Puffy vs. Leesa mattress as you decide which foam mattress is best for you. Both Puffy and Leesa are online, direct-to-consumer companies and this guide focuses on their main flagship all-foam mattresses. The Puffy and Leesa mattresses are both multi-layer foam mattresses suitable for side and back sleepers of average weights.

Keep reading to determine whether the Leesa or Puffy mattress would be best for you based on individual characteristics such as weight, preferred sleeping position, whether you sleep alone or with another person, and personal comfort preferences.

Mattress Construction Comparison

Puffy

The Puffy mattress is an all-foam mattress that has gel-infused memory foam as the top comfort layer and polyfoam as the core support layer. Memory foam contours to the body, while polyfoam provides firmness and support. The Puffy mattress also contains ClimateComfort foam, which helps keep a consistent temperature throughout the night. The Puffy mattress is a good option for someone who enjoys the contouring feel of foam and wants a medium-firm mattress.

There are two Puffy mattresses available: the original Puffy mattress and the Puffy Lux. The Puffy has three layers, while the Puffy Lux has four layers and is slightly firmer. The original Puffy mattress is 5 - 5.5 on the firmness scale and the Puffy Lux is 6 - 6.5. Both mattresses have gel-infused memory foam, ClimateComfort foam, and support polyfoam. The Puffy Lux has an additional layer of softer, cushioning polyfoam beneath the gel-infused memory foam top layer.

Puffy mattress layers construction

 

Leesa

The Leesa mattress is an all-foam mattress, constructed of three types of foam. The top layer is two inches of cooling Avena foam. The middle layer is two inches of contouring memory foam. The bottom layer is a six-inch foam support core. The Leesa mattress is considered a mixed-foam or hybrid mattress because it contains both memory foam and latex foam (the Avena foam layer).

Memory foam mattresses contour to the body, which gives a feeling of being held. This contouring can trap heat, however, which is why the Leesa contains the top Avena foam layer. Avena foam is breathable and will reduce the likelihood of a person’s body heat becoming trapped in the foam contour.

The Leesa mattress ranges 5-6 on the firmness scale, which goes up to 10. That means the Leesa is a medium firmness bed, and it is best suited for people of average weight.

Leesa Mattress Construction

Firmness Comparison

Firmness refers to how soft or hard a mattress feels when a person lies down on it. Generally, the upper layers of the mattress--called “comfort” layers--are what determine how firm a mattress feels. Mattresses are given official firmness ratings so consumers have a standardized measure by which they can compare the firmness levels from mattress to mattress. The firmness rating scale ranges from 1 - 10, with one being extra soft and ten being extra firm.

When comparing Puffy vs. Leesa mattresses, they are similar firmness levels. The Leesa mattress falls between 5 and 6 on the firmness scale. The original Puffy mattress is 5 - 5.5 and the Puffy Lux is 6 - 6.5 on the firmness scale. Both Leesa and Puffy mattresses are medium-firm.

How firm a mattress feels will range from person to person depending on their weight. Softer mattresses are generally ideal for people with below-average body weight (under 130 lbs.). Medium-firm mattresses are ideal for people with average body weight (130 - 230 lbs.). Firm and very firm mattresses will be most comfortable for people weighing over 230 lbs.

Firmer mattresses tend to last longer than softer mattresses and they are also generally less expensive. The cost and lifespan of a mattress can vary greatly based on the materials used in its construction, however.

Sleeping position also affects how a person experiences the firmness of a mattress. Softer mattresses can be more comfortable and provide better spinal alignment for side sleepers. Medium-firm mattresses generally work for people who sleep in any position. Firmer mattresses can be better for stomach and back sleepers, though body weight should also be taken into consideration.

Sleep Experience

Construction materials and firmness aren’t the only factors that influence the sleep experience you will have with a particular mattress. When deciding between Leesa vs. Puffy mattresses, it’s best to also consider how the mattress performs in terms of temperature control, motion transfer, responsiveness, resilience and bounce, edge support, and off-gassing or smell. All of these elements are important and play a role in how well any particular mattress will fit your unique needs and tastes.

Temperature Control

Temperature control can be an issue with foam mattresses. As memory foam contours to a sleeper’s body, it has the potential to trap heat. Both Puffy and Leesa mattresses have constructed their mattresses to increase breathability and reduce the possibility of trapped body heat.

Both Puffy mattresses contain 2 inches of ClimateComfort polyfoam, which is a foam they specially created to promote temperature regulation. Similarly, the Leesa mattress contains a 2-inch layer of Avena foam, which is a latex-derived foam specifically designed for breathability. These layers help make both brands’ mattresses cooler than other foam mattresses. Our tests show Puffy mattresses being somewhat better at temperature control, however.

Motion Transfer

Motion transfer is an important factor for people who regularly share their bed with someone else to consider when mattress shopping. A mattress with high motion transfer can lead to disturbed sleep for one person when the other person rolls over, adjusts their position, or gets on or off the bed.

Foam mattresses are generally good in terms of motion isolation, which means they have low motion transfer. Foam mattresses, unlike innerspring mattresses, tend to curve to the body and keep movements isolated in one spot. When comparing the Puffy mattress vs. Leesa, both brands construct mattresses with little motion transfer. This means two people can sleep comfortably without being disturbed by each other’s movements throughout the night.

Responsiveness

Responsiveness refers to how the mattress responds to the weight of your body and your body movements. The responsiveness of a mattress will influence how comfortable a person feels on the mattress as well as how well their body and spine are supported by the mattress.

Foam mattresses generally have greater responsiveness in the sense that they sink down and contour to the body more than non-foam mattresses. Their responsiveness might be slower, however, which means that when you move, the mattress might maintain an indent from your previous position for a short period of time.

The Puffy mattresses have average responsiveness. They will contour to the body while providing the support needed for spinal alignment. The Leesa mattress is similar in responsiveness, but because the mattress is slightly firmer, it contours to the body a bit less. The Leesa mattress has a slightly less “hugging” feeling.

Resilience and Bounce

When a mattress quickly rebounds after having pressure put on it and removed, it is considered resilient and bouncy. Memory foam mattresses generally have the least bounce, while innerspring mattress offer the most bounce.

Like most foam mattresses, neither the Leesa nor the Puffy mattress has much bounce. Bounce and resilience affect how easily a person can move around on a mattress, and they often play a role in how good the mattress is for sex. Some people might find that sexual movement is more difficult on the Leesa and Puffy mattresses than on other mattresses because of the sinking in that happens with foam.

Edge Support

A mattress with good edge support maintains shape and firmness around the edges even when weight is put on them. Edge support is important for people who tend to sleep near the edge of the bed or sit on the edge of the bed often. When a mattress has poor edge support, a person might feel like they are sliding off when they near the edge of the mattress.

Both the Puffy and Leesa mattresses provide average or even slightly below average edge support. People searching for a mattress they can frequently sit on the edge of might want to consider an innerspring mattress instead of a foam mattress since innerspring mattresses generally have greater edge support than foam mattresses. If you don’t sit on or sleep near the edge of the bed, edge support likely isn’t an important characteristic for you to consider when mattress shopping.

Off-gassing and Smell

A brand new mattress usually has a smell, whether strong or slight, in the hours or days after it is first opened. This smell is due to the off-gassing of chemicals involved in the mattress production process. The strength of smell varies quite a bit from mattress to mattress.

Both the Leesa and Puffy mattresses will have a mild smell upon opening due to the memory foam, but it should dissipate within a few days.

Shipping, Trial, Warranty, and Returns

A mattress is a long-term investment so it is important to get the most flexibility for the logistics of buying, trying, and returning your mattress. The table below explains everything you need to consider for delivery, shipping, returns, sleep trials, and warranties.

Puffy Leesa
Delivery fee Free shipping to contiguous U.S.; shipping costs apply for Alaska and Hawaii Free shipping to all 50 states
How is it shipped? Bed-in-a-box Bed-in-a-box
Old mattress removal? Not available Yes, with the purchase of White Glove Delivery and an additional $50 fee
Sleep trial length Risk-free trial period: 101 nights Risk-free trial period: 100 nights
Return cost and process Free returns $49 “bed adoption fee”
Warranty length Lifetime limited warranty 10-year limited warranty

Prices, Sizes, and Value

For people on a budget, price can be a determining factor in deciding which mattress to purchase. The following table outlines the prices of Leesa vs. Puffy mattresses at each size as of August 2019.

Puffy
Leesa
Mattress Size Price
Twin $795
Twin XL $825
Full $995
Queen $1,150
King $1,350
California King $1,350
Mattress Size Price
Twin $499
Twin XL $599
Full $899
Queen $999
King $1,199
California King $1,199

The Puffy mattress is somewhat pricier than the Leesa mattress. Our independent testing resulted in higher ratings for the Puffy mattress, so the Puffy might be worth the additional cost for many buyers.

When comparing the Leesa mattress vs. Puffy, their quality and value is similar in many categories. One thing that makes the Puffy mattress stand out is its lifetime warranty. If you’re wanting your new mattress to last, the Puffy might be the best choice. Puffy does not offer White Glove Delivery, however. If you require that, Leesa could be your best option.

Puffy vs. Leesa Mattress - Which One Should You Buy

Even after considering all of the factors presented, it might be difficult for you to choose which mattress is best for you when comparing Leesa vs. Puffy. This section contains lists of information identifying what types of people are better suited to each mattress.

Buy the Puffy mattress if you:

1. Want a lifetime warranty

Most mattress companies do not offer a lifetime warranty. The Puffy mattresses are an excellent choice for people who are concerned about the lifespan of their mattress and wanting their mattress to last a very long time. Their lifetime warranty is generous, and a good sign that the company is confident their mattresses will last for years to come.

2. Are a side or back sleeper

The Puffy mattress provides good support for side sleepers, contouring to the body and keeping the spine aligned. The combination of comfort and support they provide is ideal for side sleepers. They are also a good choice for people who sleep on their back and need support in that position.

3. Sleep with a partner

The Puffy mattress has very good motion isolation and a low level of motion transfer because of its memory foam. If you sleep with another person, you will most likely not be disturbed when they roll over or get in and out of bed because the foam will absorb the motion rather than move it across the mattress.

4. Weigh under 230 lbs

People who weigh under 230 lbs. are best suited to the Puffy mattresses, which provides ample support for people of average weight. The mattress might sink too much and not provide enough firmness for those who weigh over 230 lbs.

 

Buy the Leesa mattress if you:

1. Want medium firmness or are a back sleeper

The firmness level of the Leesa mattress is ideal for back sleepers. Some side sleepers might find it to be too firm for their liking.

2. Budget is top priority

The Leesa mattress is less than the Puffy mattress at every size, making it more attractive to people on a budget.

3. Require white glove delivery

Leesa, unlike Puffy, offers White Glove Delivery service, which means that they will set up your new bed and even remove your own mattress for an additional fee.

4. Weigh under 300 lbs

The Leesa mattress can support people who weigh up to 300 lbs. People who weigh more than that amount might find that the mattress doesn’t provide adequate support.