Puffy vs. Purple Mattress Comparison
While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about our affiliate program here.
Puffy and Purple are two movers and shakers in the online mattress world. Puffy made a name for itself when it appeared on the Ellen show back in 2017, while Purple was born thanks to a highly successful Kickstarter campaign.
Both mattress companies use high-quality materials and sophisticated designs that promise a top-notch sleeping experience. Nevertheless, their variations in construction, price point, and sleep experience may make one or the other more appealing to you. We’ll run through the main differences between the Puffy vs. Purple mattress to help you decide.
Puffy also sells a thicker mattress called the Puffy Lux, and Purple has developed several other mattresses, including the Purple Hybrid and Hybrid Premier mattresses. However, in this review, we’ll be focusing on the namesake Puffy and Purple mattresses.
Mattress Construction Comparison
The Puffy mattress is an all-foam mattress with gel-infused memory foam in the comfort layer. The company recently added a transition layer, bringing the total number of layers to 3. The resulting mattress is 10 inches tall.
The top layer is 2 inches tall and features Puffy’s proprietary Cooling Cloud™ foam. This is a gel-infused visco polyurethane memory foam that wicks away heat. The foam is on the lighter, fluffier side for memory foam, and it adapts to pressure to provide alternate support and pressure relief.
Next is the new transition layer, 2 inches of breathable Climate Comfort™ polyurethane foam. This layer helps with pressure relief and temperature control. On the bottom is a 6-inch support core made of polyurethane foam. The Puffy has a zippered machine-washable cover that is resistant to stains.
Purple’s claim to fame is its comfort layer, featuring the company’s proprietary Purple Grid. The grid is 2 inches tall, made of stretchy Hyper-Elastic Polymer™ and coated in a non-toxic polyethylene copolymer powder. The grid contours to your body while allowing for airflow through the columns.
The layer beneath the grid is made of HD polyurethane foam. This layer is 3.5 inches thick and the foam has a density of 1.8 PCF. On the bottom is a 4-inch support layer of HD polyurethane foam. This foam is medium-firm and has a density of 2 PCF. Overall, the Purple mattress is 9.5 inches tall.
Purple uses a stretchy knit cover so as not to impede the flexibility of the Purple Grid. It’s a breathable viscose-polyester-Lycra blend with a polyester non-slip bottom. An integrated Firegard Knit Barrier® eliminates the need for added chemicals.
The firmness of a mattress refers to how far you sink into it. This is influenced by factors like your weight, your body temperature, and your sleeping position. Heavier sleepers will sink further into the mattress and interact with the firmer layers underneath, while lighter sleepers might not sink in at all.
It can be difficult to get an exact idea of the firmness of a mattress by describing it only in terms of “plush” or “firm.” To make things easier, we often assign it an approximate number from 1 to 10, with 10 being the firmest. Ideal firmness differs from person to person, but the majority of people prefer a medium-firm mattress. This is roughly between a 5 and a 7 on the subjective firmness scale.
The Puffy falls around a 6-7 out of 10 on the firmness scale. The top layer is medium-firm, but it’s a fairly thin top layer. While the top layer will feel fluffy to lighter and average-weight sleepers, heavier sleepers who sink into the transition layer below might fight the mattress firmer.
The Purple also falls around a 6 out of 10 in terms of firmness. Most average-weight sleepers should exert enough pressure on the grid to benefit from its contouring properties. However, like in the Puffy, the comfort layer is only 2 inches tall. Therefore, heavyweight sleepers may also find this mattress on the firm side. The Purple is suitable for stomach sleepers, who won’t feel like they’re sinking too deeply into the mattress.
Firmness isn’t the only thing we take into consideration when comparing mattresses. How hot or cool a mattress sleeps, how much it moves when your partner tosses and turns, how much support it provides, and other factors will all have an impact on how comfortable your mattress feels. Below we’ll outline how the different designs of the Puffy mattress vs. Purple mattress affect the sleep experience.
Memory foam mattress designers strive to find ways to eliminate the traditional memory foam problems of restricting airflow and sleeping hot. The Puffy mattress manages to sleep fairly neutral thanks to its light, gel-infused memory foam.
The top layer in the Purple mattress is the Hyper-Elastic Polymer, which doesn’t retain heat like memory foam. The grid promotes airflow in the space between the columns, so body heat doesn’t get trapped against you. The Purple has a reputation for being an extremely breathable mattress.
With its combination of memory foam and firmer support foams, the Puffy performs very well on motion isolation. This means movement in one part of the bed will generally not affect other parts of the bed.
The Purple also limits motion transfer. The columns buckle under pressure, distributing the weight to the neighboring columns. However, this reaction is limited to the immediate region.
Due to their above-average motion isolation, both mattresses are good choices for people who share the bed, especially if you have a restless sleeping partner.
A responsive mattress will contour to the shape of your body and provide support where needed in order to encourage proper spinal alignment.
The top layer of the Puffy is memory foam, a material which is recognized as one of the best for contouring. Along with the transition and support layers, the Puffy mattress should alleviate pressure points while providing a supportive cradle for your shoulders, back, and hips.
Purple’s proprietary Purple Grid does a good job of mimicking the contouring effects of memory foam. The hyper-elastic material is stretchy and provides relief from pressure points, but it’s also supportive where you need it to be. The firm layer of foam underneath helps keep the spine aligned.
Resilience and Bounce
Another important factor in the sleeping experience is resilience, or how “bouncy” a mattress feels. A material is considered resilient when it quickly springs back to its normal shape after pressure is removed.
The polymer material in the top layer of the Purple springs back almost instantaneously. This prevents the feeling of sinking into the mattress and makes it practical for sex and for people who frequently change sleeping positions.
The memory foam in the top layer of the Puffy is slow to regain its shape. However, with the new transition layer, there’s less of the all-enveloping hug feeling typical of memory foam.
Like many foam mattresses, the Purple mattress lacks dedicated edge support and the material will compress under you at the edges. This may be a problem if you share the bed or sleep near the edges and may make it more difficult to get out of bed.
The updated version of the Puffy has better edge support than before, probably due to the addition of the transition layer. Sitting on the edge of the bed may not be your favorite activity, but sharing the bed with a partner who hogs the space shouldn’t lead to you falling off the edge.
Off-gassing and Smell
Like most all-foam mattresses, the Puffy and Purple mattresses may emit a slight odor when they are unpacked. This nothing to worry about and shouldn’t last more than a few days.
The polymer in the Purple mattress is non-toxic, and all the foams used in the Purple and Puffy mattresses are CertiPUR-US certified. This guarantees them to be free from ozone depleters, formaldehyde, heavy metals, and other dangerous chemicals. CertiPUR-US certified foams are also low in volatile organic compounds, commonly known as VOCs.
Shipping, Trial, Warranty, and Returns
The delivery, shipping, sleep trial and return policies for the Purple vs. Puffy mattresses are highly similar. Both companies insist on a short break-in period so you can accurately gauge whether the mattress is right for you.
Puffy sets itself apart with a lifetime warranty, which is very rare in the online mattress industry.
Neither company offers old mattress removal, which is something you might want to take into consideration if you don’t have an elevator or aren’t sure how to dispose of your mattress properly.
|Delivery fee||Free shipping to contiguous U.S.; shipping costs apply for Alaska and Hawaii||Free shipping to contiguous U.S.; shipping costs apply for Alaska and Hawaii|
|How is it shipped?||Bed-in-a-box||Bed-in-a-box|
|Old mattress removal?||Not available||Not available|
|Sleep trial length||Risk-free trial period: 101 nights||100 nights; 21-night break-in period|
|Return cost and process||No charge; company picks up, but shipping fees for Hawaii, Alaska, and Canada are not refunded||No charge; company picks up, but shipping fees not refunded|
|Warranty length||Lifetime limited warranty||10-year limited warranty|
Prices, Sizes, and Value
The reduced overhead costs of online mattress companies allow them to offer their mattresses at a much cheaper price point than in a store. In comparing the Puffy mattress vs. Purple mattress prices, you’ll notice they’re both very competitively priced.
At first glance, the Puffy mattress is slightly more expensive than the Purple mattress. However, it’s worth noting that the Purple mattress works much better with stretchy sheets. Purple recommends investing in Purple sheets and a mattress cover, which will bring your budget a bit higher.
It’s not unheard of to see Puffy offer as much as $300 off their suggested retail price. Purple has also recently started offering discounts of around $100 on holidays like Memorial Day and Black Friday.
Puffy vs. Purple Mattress - Which One Should You Buy
Puffy and Purple are both great choices, and it’s understandable if you can’t bring yourself to choose one over the other. The following considerations may help you decide which mattress is better for your individual needs.
Buy the Puffy mattress if you:
1. Sleep on your side
Lightweight and average-weight side sleepers will find that the memory foam in the comfort layer of the Puffy mattress provides just the right amount of cushion for the hips and shoulders.
2. Want that “hug” feeling
Memory foam aficionados will gravitate towards the Puffy mattress simply because it’s impossible to replicate the signature “hug” feeling.
3. Like to eat in bed
It’s rare for a bed-in-a-box mattress to have a stain-resistant cover, and even more rare for that cover to be machine-washable. If you are prone to spilling things in bed, the Puffy mattress will help avoid stains.
4. Value a lifetime warranty
Almost none of the competitors offer a lifetime warranty, so if you plan on using your mattress for a long time, Puffy’s offer is hard to beat.
5. Want to donate beds to kids
Upload a photo of yourself jumping on the bed and tag it #jumpforkids and for every 100 such posts, Puffy donates a mattress to charity.
Buy the Purple mattress if you:
1. Tend to sleep hot
The Purple Grid provides unparalleled airflow compared with the average foam mattress, which is great for people who tend to overheat during the night.
2. Want more bounce
The resilient polymer in the top layer of the Purple mattress will provide ample bounce. This makes the mattress an ideal choice for sex and for changing sleeping positions.
3. Want to try something new
If you’ve had trouble finding a mattress that works for you, or if you’re looking to branch out from traditional mattress designs, the innovative construction of the Purple mattress may be the answer to your problems.
See how the Puffy and Purple compare to other mattresses:
- Puffy vs. Leesa Mattress Comparison
- Puffy vs. Tempur-Pedic Mattress Comparison
- Nectar vs. Puffy Mattress Comparison
- Puffy vs. Tuft & Needle Mattress Comparison
- Layla vs. Purple Mattress Comparison
- Bear vs. Purple Mattress Comparison
- Nectar vs. Purple Mattress Comparison
- Purple vs. Casper Mattress Comparison
- Tuft & Needle vs. Purple Mattress Comparison
- Purple vs. Leesa Mattress Comparison