Saatva vs. Simmons Beautyrest Black Mattress Comparison

While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about our affiliate program here.

Simmons Beautyrest is one of the largest mattress manufacturers in the country. They are credited with making the first pocketed coil in 1925. Over the company's storied past, it's been both a popular consumer brand and an innovator in its field. The Beautyrest Black mattress is the company's highest luxury line, made of premium foam and innerspring coiled technology.

Saatva is a relatively newer mattress company that has taken the bedding world by storm thanks to its unique approach to manufacturing. The American handcrafted beds are sold as a premium alternative to big-name brands. They are one of the few online-only companies that offer an innerspring option.

Both mattresses offer premium and high-quality versions of the oldest type of bed available. They achieve results using very different approaches to design, giving you the ability to pick what works best for you.

Mattress Construction Comparison

Saatva

The Saatva Mattress comes in two available heights: 14.5" or 11.5". Both mattresses feature the same five-part construction. The support layer for the Premier Luxury model is seven inches thick while the Custom Slim model is only four inches. Both bases use the same steel coil design with 14.5g gauge Bonnel coils. Saatva uses a coil-on-coil design, with the base layer coils followed by individually wrapped pocket coils designed to contour to the body.

The coils are covered by a thin (.3 inch) layer of memory foam that provides pressure point relief. The top comfort layer uses a Euro pillowtop design with foam and an organic cotton cover.  The final piece of the mattresses' construction is the Dual Perimeter Edge Support System, which is a foam casing that wraps around the entire construction to prevent sagging and provide edge support. The cotton outer-cover is hypoallergenic, all of the memory foam used throughout meets Green manufacturing standards, and the coils are made from recycled steel.

 

saatva construction

 

Simmons Beautyrest Black

The Beautyrest Black mattress is an innerspring bed with some advanced features that help it compete with hybrid models. The company features T3 Pocketed Coil Technology, which uses three strands of steel wound up to create a more durable spring. This advanced coil technology is designed to provide individualized back support and lend to the top layer's pressure point relief.

While the different classes of Black mattress use varying combinations of materials, all the beds use multiple layers of foam on top of the innerspring to help contour to your body. Beautyrest comfort foam uses Micro Diamond technology to conduct heat away from your body. The comfort layer of the Beautyrest Black mattress uses SurfaceCool Plus Fiber, which are fibers that are vertically arranged to flow your body heat away from the bed's surface.

 

Simmons Beautyrest Black Mattress construction

 

Firmness Comparison

Saatva offers three firmness levels. The Saatva Plush Soft (3) is best for side and combination sleepers who are looking for a bed that will contour the most with your body. The Saatva Luxury Firm (5-6) offers both support and contour. The Saatva Firm (8) option is best suited for back and stomach sleepers, offering the most support of all the firmness levels.

Simmons Beautyrest Black mattresses have many different options, but each class (C, L, and K) have the same four basic firmness options. The first two are Ultimate Plush Pillow Top (1) and Plush Pillow Top (2) that give you the softest mattresses with the most body-conforming. The Medium Pillow Top and regular Plush names are used for different class options, but both have the same firmness rating (5). The firmest option (9) of the Black mattress is called either Luxury Firm or Extra Firm, depending on the class.

The Beautyrest beds have the broadest range of firmness options. While the naming conventions can be confusing, the matresses all fall into the same firmness options that are at either end of the scale and directly in the middle. Saatva's firmness options all fall in the middle, which might be better for someone looking for a firmness level that isn't too extreme.

Sleep Experience

A good night's sleep is dependent on numerous factors. While the buying experience and construction of your mattress are important considerations, there are also a few day-to-day elements that you should consider. Below we've outlined major factors to look for and compared how these two mattresses stack up.

Temperature Control

The temperature control of your mattress is all about your body heat and how the bed handles it. If you're a hot sleeper, then you want a mattress that can keep your body heat away from you so you don't wake up sweaty and uncomfortable.

With the minimal amount of foam used in the Saatva mattress, it's great for temperature control. The coil-on-coil design allows for maximum airflow to keep you cool while you sleep. The inner coil construction of the Beautyrest does allow for a good amount of airflow. The SurfaceCool fiber also feels cool to the touch. However, the thicker layers of foam make it sleep slightly hotter than the Saatva.

Motion Transfer

Motion transfer is how movement on one side of the bed affects the other side. This typically applies to one partner waking up or moving around while the other tries to sleep. If a matress provides motion isolation, then your partner's movements are unlikely to wake you up. It's important to note that innerspring mattresses are known for having the most motion transfer, which is often their most significant setback. Both the Saatva and Beautyrest, though, do a great job of minimizing this issue. They both use pocketed coils and a foam comfort layer that help isolate motion. If this is a particularly important factor for you, consider choosing a memory foam or hybrid option instead.

Responsiveness

Both the Beautyrest and Saatva use a foam comfort layer that is designed to be responsive. A responsive mattress compresses based on the weight that is applied and contours to help relieve pressure in critical areas. The different firmness options play an important role in how responsive a mattress is. Beautyrest offers the softest option with its Ultimate Plush Pillow Top. The multiple foam layers offer the most contouring possible. This may be too soft for specific customers, in which case Saatva's softest option could be a better fit. The Plush Soft option is very responsive but also offers better support than the Ultimate Plush Pillow Top.

Resilience and Bounce

While responsiveness deals with the sinking in of a mattress, resilience is all about how quickly a mattress regains its shape. This goes hand in hand with the bounce of a bed, which both mattresses have thanks to their innerspring core. The Beautyrest balances the springiness of their core with multiple layers of foam covering the top. While the bed retains the bounce you'd expect from an innerspring mattress, it isn't as resilient as the Saatva. The Saatva mattress gets its resilience from the thinner foam comfort layer and having dual spring layers that respond quickly to your movements. This makes both options great for those who switch positions often and for sex.

Edge Support

The two mattresses are about even on edge support. The ability for a mattress to retain its shape is essential if you sleep close to the sides or frequently sit on the edge of your mattress. Both the Saatva and Beautyrest mattresses use a similar foam layer that surrounds the outer edge of the beds. This will provide great edge support compared to many all foam options.

Off-gassing and Smell

Saatva's bed uses minimal foam, so off-gassing isn't much of an issue. The Beautyrest has more foam layers, so it has a slightly more noticeable off-gassing period, but it is also insignificant.

Shipping, Trial, Warranty, and Returns

One of the most important parts of buying a new mattress is actually getting it to your house. The ease of transportation and the ability to return a mattress you dislike are crucial factors.

Saatva Simmons Beautyrest Black
Delivery fee Free shipping in the U.S. and Canada Depends on retailer
How is it shipped? White glove delivery Only available through individual retailers
Old mattress removal? Included with white glove delivery Depends on retailer
Sleep trial length 120 nights Depends on retailer
Return cost and process No cost; company picks up Depends on retailer - Beautyrest customer service can be contacted if the original dealer is no longer ope
Warranty length 15-year non-prorated warranty 10 years

Prices, Sizes, and Value

The sizing options and pricing of the two mattresses are below. You always want to make sure you are getting the best choice for your money when it comes to such an important purchase.

Mattress Size Saatva Simmons Beautyrest Black

(L Class - K Class)

Twin $599 N/A
Twin XL $749 $1,999 - 3,099
Queen $999 $2,279 - 3,379
Full $1,099 $2,399 - 3,699
King $1,499 $2,899 - 4,599
California King $1,499 $2,899 - 4,599

The Beautyrest Black mattress comes with a much higher price tag than the Saatva mattress. Part of this because of how much customization goes into the Black mattress, with three different classifications, multiple comfort levels, and design options. You also have to consider how well known and highly respected Beautyrest's parent company (Simmons) is compared to how new Saatva is.

However, Saatva offers a lot of great options at a fraction of the price, and their beds are highly reviewed by customers.

Saatva vs. Beautyrest Black Mattress Mattress – Which One Should You Buy?

There's a lot to consider when picking what a mattress that you'll be sleeping on for years to come. To help you narrow down your search, here are some key features that could help you pick out the best option.

Buy the Saatva mattress if you:

  • Don’t want to go through a dealer: Saatva mattresses are only available through the company itself. This makes purchasing easy and avoids the extra retailer cost.
  • Want a long sleep trial: Saatva offers a 120-night sleep trial to test out its mattress, which is higher than the average 100-day trial.
  • Are on a budget: The Saatva mattress is by far the more affordable option. Plus, it's still made from premium materials that rival the Beautyrest.

 

saatva mattress

 

Buy the Beautyrest Black mattress if you:

  • Want a custom mattress: The Beautyrest Black mattress line has a plethora of options from different material classes, firmness options, and thickness options for your sleep style and aesthetic.
  • Want to test it out in person: Simmons Beautyrest works with a lot of different mattress dealers, so finding a local store is fairly easy. This gives you the opportunity to see the mattress in person before you buy.
  • Like different retailer options: Since there are so many different places that sell the Black mattress, you also have a wide range of shipping, trial, and sales options that each dealer can offer you.

 

Simmons Beautyrest Black Mattress lifestyle featured

 

Both Saatva and Simmons Beautyrest offer great products. Each mattress has features that can help make it the perfect choice for you. Saatva is a smaller business that focuses on online sales and direct customer interaction. Its mattress is a premium bed at an affordable price. The Black mattress is available all over the country thanks to Beautyrest's numerous dealers. It offers a large number of options and customization.

See how the Saatva compares to other mattresses:

Table Of Contents

Read Our In-Depth Reviews