Tuft & Needle vs. Helix Mattress

While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about our affiliate program here.

Tuft & Needle and Helix are two major manufacturers of quality mattresses. Tuft & Needle was founded by two engineers who wanted to change the mattress industry. They then merged with Serta Simmons Bedding in 2018. Tuft & Needle offers memory foam mattresses that can be purchased online, including its T&N Original Mattress, as well as the luxury Mint Mattress. The company also offers bedding, pillows, and furniture, such as bed frames and foundations.

Helix was founded on the belief that “one option isn’t an option,” and that is reflected in the fact that each of the company’s mattresses come in six different firmness options. The Helix Mattress is the company’s original memory foam design, while the Luxe mattress is a luxury option. Helix also offers specialty mattresses, such as the Nightfall for plus size and big and tall consumers, as well as the organic Birch Mattress. Helix also offers a selection of pillows, bedding, and bed bases and frames.

To compare the Tuft & Needle mattress to the Helix mattress, we will focus on the T&N Original Mattress and the Helix Mattress.

Tuft & Needle Mattress vs. Helix Mattress – Which One Should You Buy?

Even after considering all of the above factors, it can still be difficult to decide which mattress is right for you. That’s why we’ve created a list of differentiators to help you pinpoint the mattress that’s the right choice for your sleep habits, needs, and preferences.

Buy the Tuft & Needle if...

1. Sleep hot

With a combination of heat wicking graphite and cooling gel in the foam layer, the T&N Mattress has a breathable cover to help you sleep cool.

2. Want pressure relief without the sinking sensation

The T&N Adaptive® Foam offers pressure relief and comfort without feeling too soft or allowing you to sink in too deeply.

3. Are looking for versatile

This mattress pairs with a variety of bed setups, including slatted frames, adjustable frames, platforms, and box springs.

 

Tuft & Needle Bed

Buy the Helix if...

1. Want control of the mattress firmness

The Helix Mattress is available in a soft, medium, or firm feel, giving you the control to choose the exact firmness that you want your mattress to have.

2. Need edge support

Individually wrapped coils create durability and offer edge support, helping to prevent sagging and making it easier to get into and out of bed.

3. Want custom support

With the Helix Mattress, you can choose from a design that offers side sleeper or back & stomach support, ensuring you buy the mattress that is right for your sleep habits.

 

Both the Tuft & Needle and Helix mattresses are great choices; these mattresses are more advanced than traditional memory foam mattresses and are engineered with factors like spinal alignment, support, and comfort in mind. Both mattresses use multiple layers of foam in their construction. The Helix mattress incorporates individually wrapped coils in its hybrid design, and while the Tuft & Needle’s mattress construction is simpler, the T&N Adaptive® Foam offers a unique combination of the best qualities of memory foam and latex.

One of the largest differences between the mattresses is that the Helix Mattress is offered in different firmness options, giving you some control over the firmness and properties of the mattress. However, the Tuft & Needle mattress offers a blend of softness and support that many people find comfortable; 95 out of 100 people keep the Tuft & Needle mattress after the trial.

With two quality mattresses to choose from, you’re sure to be pleased with the performance of whichever mattress you decide is right for you.

Mattress Construction Comparison

Rather than create a multi-layer memory foam mattress, the Tuft & Needle Mattress is designed with just a few layers of quality foam. A high-quality support layer creates the foundation for this mattress, while the T&N Adaptive® Foam combines the benefits of both memory foam and latex for a comfortable, contouring mattress. This dual-layer construction promotes airflow throughout the entire mattress while also keeping the overall cost of the mattress down.

Tuft & Needle sources quality materials and puts the final touches on each mattress in a Southern California factory. The foam is poured and cut in the United States, and the company purchases its fabric from a family-owned mill in the Carolinas. By sourcing materials from the United States, Tuft & Needle supports the country’s economy while eliminating unnecessary long-distance shipping for environmental benefits.

Tuft & Needle Mattress Construction

Helix

The Helix Mattress’ construction features layers of Memory Plus Foam and Helix Dynamic Foam. This multi-layer design using foams of different densities creates both pressure relief and contouring for increased comfort.

Durable DuraDense foam creates the base layer, creating stability. That base layer is topped by a layer of individually wrapped coils to help limit motion transfer throughout the mattress while also supporting and cradling your body. These coils are carefully positioned to also reinforce the mattress edges to prevent sagging and to make it easier to get into and out of bed.

Foams make up the next two layers;  a Helix Dynamic Foam offers both ergonomic support and cushioning properties, and it is topped by a layer of Memory Plus Foam or by a second layer of Helix Dynamic Foam, depending on the mattress model. The Memory Plus Foam is a special blend that offers a soft feel and plenty of pressure relief, maximizing your comfort. The Soft Touch Design cover completes the mattress and is extremely soft to the touch. The cover is designed to allow plenty of airflow, which can help to regulate temperature so that you can sleep more comfortably.

Helix construction

Firmness Comparison

Mattresses come in a variety of different firmness options, and it’s important to find a mattress that has the right amount of firmness for your preferences and needs.

A mattress’ firmness refers to how the mattress feels as soon as you lie down on it, and is affected by the materials used in and the overall design of a mattress. A softer mattress will allow you to sink down into it and may even resemble sleeping on a cloud. A firmer mattress may feel like it’s pushing back at you, and you won’t be able to sink down into it.

Finding the ideal mattress firmness is largely a personal preference, and no one firmness is better than another. Instead, you should try a variety of mattresses to get a sense of what you prefer. Generally speaking, people who have chronic pain often prefer a softer mattress, but a mattress that is very soft can make it a bit more difficult to reposition yourself at night. Softer mattresses that allow you to sink down into them can feel a little warmer at night as the mattress’ material comes into contact with more of your body; if you prefer to sleep cool, a slightly firmer mattress may be a better choice. Side sleepers and lightweight sleepers also tend to prefer a softer mattress, while heavier sleepers would do well in a firmer option.

The Tuft & Needle Mattress falls somewhere between a soft and a medium firmness. The T&N Adaptive® Foam reacts according to your body weight; the heavier the sleeper, the more the foam pushes back against you. This makes for a softer sleep surface that still offers plenty of support so you don’t sink down too far into the mattress. Because the T&N Adaptive® Foam blends together the pressure relief of memory foam with the bounce of latex, this mattress has a unique feel.

The Helix Mattress is offered in three different firmness levels, so you can choose the ideal firmness. Select a soft, medium, or firm feel, and then choose from a mattress that offers pressure relief or body contouring properties. In total, you can choose from six different mattress designs for the exact feel that helps you to get your best sleep.

Sleep Experience

To effectively compare the Tuft & Needle Mattress to the Helix Mattress, you will need to consider sleep experience elements such as temperature control, edge support, resilience, and bounce. Both of these products are designed to help you get quality sleep, but depending on your sleep preferences, some of these elements may be more important to you than others. When you understand the specific elements that each mattress offers, you can better decide which mattress is the best fit for your needs and preferences.

Temperature Control

With carefully selected cover materials designed to promote airflow, mattresses can help to control the temperature of your bed at night.. This is particularly important if you often wake up feeling too hot, since a mattress that feels cool can help you to quickly fall back to sleep.

The Tuft & Needle Mattress features T&N Adaptive® foam, which includes heat wicking graphite as well as cooling gel. The cover is also breathable to keep you cool during the night. Helix’s mattress also features a breathable cover, while its hybrid design allows for generous airflow throughout the mattress itself.

Motion Transfer

If you find yourself waking up every time your partner shifts or gets into or out of bed, then you’ve experienced the downside of a mattress that transfers too much motion. A mattress that prevents motion transfer can allow you or your partner to keep sleeping even when the other moves, and is a wise choice if one of you often gets out of bed during the night or if you wake up or go to bed at different times. Memory foam is often favored because of its ability to limit motion transfer.

Because the Helix Mattress is built on a layer of individually wrapped coils topped by foam layers, its design helps to minimize motion transfer. The Tuft & Needle Mattress also helps to minimize motion transfer, but because the T&N Adaptive® Foam incorporates some of the bounce of latex, this mattress may allow more motion transfer than the Helix mattress.

Responsiveness

The responsiveness of a mattress refers to how quickly and how well that mattress reacts to pressure. A highly responsive mattress may feel a little bouncy, while a mattress that has little responsiveness may allow you to sink down deeply into it.

The Tuft & Needle Mattress is very responsive because of the T&N Adaptive® Foam. While the foam has the contouring properties of memory foam, it also introduces the bounce and resiliency of latex, allowing the mattress to respond quickly to weight. The more weight put on the mattress, the more it responds, allowing it to provide sleepers of any size or weight with a soft yet supportive sleep surface.

The Helix Mattress’ responsiveness differs between the individual mattress models. The Sunset, Midnight, and Twilight models have a latex-foam hybrid blend layer for body contouring properties. These models offer more responsiveness than the Moonlight, Dusk, and Dawn models, which incorporate a Memory Foam Plus Foam layer that provides increased pressure relief with a softer feel.

Resilience and Bounce

While a mattress with too much bounce can make it difficult to sleep and contributes to motion transfer. A mattress with little to no bounce can make it difficult to shift and reposition yourself during the night. This bounce is often referred to as resiliency, and refers to the mattress’ ability to rebound after pressure is applied to them. Some lower quality memory foam mattresses can become compacted over time because of lack of resiliency, making resiliency and bounce important qualities in any mattress.

Both of these mattresses have resilience and bounce. The Tuft & Needle’s T&N Adaptive® Foam offers the contouring of memory foam with the bounce and resilience of latex, allowing you to enjoy the best qualities of both products. Similarly, the Helix Mattress is built on layers of dense foam and individually wrapped coils, which creates a durable base. The Sunset, Midnight, and Twilight models feature a latex-foam hybrid blend layer which creates the bounce of latex with the soft comfort of memory foam. The Moonlight, Dusk, and Dawn models feature a Memory Foam Plus Foam layer, creating a softer feel with less bounce.

Edge Support

Over time, memory foam mattresses may start to sag at their edges as the foam becomes worn and compressed. This is more common in lower quality mattresses, and when it occurs, you may find it difficult to get in and out of bed because of the sagging edges. Mattresses can be designed with extra edge support to prevent this sagging, increasing the usable area of the mattress.

The Helix Mattress features edge support in the form of individually wrapped coils carefully positioned to provide extra reinforcement. While the Tuft & Needle Mattress does not have additional edge support, the latex resiliency of the T&N Adaptive® Foam makes it more durable than a traditional mattress constructed only of traditional memory foam.

Off-gassing and Smell

When you unpack a new mattress or pillow, you may notice your room soon fills up with a strong odor. This process is called off-gassing, where the volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in the foam of your mattress break down and are released into their air. VOCs can create some powerful smells, and some mattresses have much higher off-gassing levels than others.

The Tuft & Needle Mattress features low off-gassing levels. The foam is CertiPUR-US® certified, which means it does not contain harmful chemicals and has low levels of VOCs. The mattress is also GREENGUARD Gold certified, meaning that its off-gassing has been carefully tested.

The Helix Mattress is also made with CertiPUR-US® certified materials that have an extremely low impact on indoor air quality.

Shipping, Trial, Warranty, and Returns

Details such as delivery fees, old mattress removal, and the cost of returning a mattress can all add up. When comparing Helix vs Tuft & Needle mattresses, be sure to also consider the sleep trials and warranties each company offers.

Tuft & Needle Helix
Delivery fee Free Free
How is it shipped? Bed-in-a-box Bed-in-a-box
Old mattress removal? No Yes
Sleep trial length 100 nights 100 nights
Return cost and process No cost; company picks up Full refund after 30 days
Warranty length 10 years 10-year limited warranty

Prices, Sizes, and Value

The prices of mattresses vary significantly. While it’s important to weigh all of the benefits that a mattress offers, the mattress ultimately needs to be within your budget to be a wise purchase.

Tuft & Needle
Helix
Mattress Size Price
Twin $350
Twin XL $395
Full $495
Queen $595
King $750
California King $750
Mattress Size Price
Twin $600
Twin XL $700
Full $850
Queen $995
King $1,245
California King $1,245

While there is a difference between the prices in these mattresses, pricing shouldn’t be a defining factor in choosing which mattress is right for you. The Helix Mattress offers the advantage of being able to choose the mattress firmness and to select whether you want a mattress that offers pressure relief or body contouring properties. These benefits may justify the more expensive price of the Helix Mattress, especially if you’re looking for a very soft or very firm mattress, which can be difficult to find.

However, both mattresses are made of quality materials and are a step above a traditional memory foam mattress. With the prices being relatively similar, you should ultimately consider the benefits that each mattress offers before simply evaluating according to price.