Tuft & Needle vs. Loom & Leaf Mattress

Updated on July 24, 2020 While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about our affiliate program here.

Tuft & Needle and Loom & Leaf are both all-foam mattresses produced by industry-leading direct-to-consumer mattress companies.

Tuft & Needle launched its mattress in 2012 and quickly became one of the most well-known brands in the industry. The Loom & Leaf mattress is produced by Saatva. Saatva launched in 2011 and focuses on producing mattresses using eco-friendly materials.

The following comparison will focus on the companies’ flagship mattresses. Tuft & Needle offers two models: the Original and the Mint. This comparison will focus on the Original. In addition to the Loom & Leaf mattress, Saatva also produces the Zenhaven latex mattress and the Saatva innerspring mattress. This comparison will focus exclusively on the Loom & Leaf mattress.

While the Tuft & Needle and Loom & Leaf mattresses have some similarities, they also vary on some important factors. Assessing each mattress’s construction, sleep experience, and product information can give you the insight necessary to decide between Tuft & Needle and Loom & Leaf.

Tuft & Needle Mattress vs. Loom & Leaf Mattress – Which One Should You Buy?

Even once you know about a mattress’s construction, sleep experience, and product information, selecting the right mattress for you can still be tricky. The Tuft & Needle mattress and the Loom & Leaf mattress have some similarities and differences. However, both mattresses have major advantages that may make them the right choice for you.

Buy the Tuft & Needle if…

1. Want affordability

The Tuft & Needle mattress offers a low price point that’s hard to beat. If you’re looking for a budget-friendly foam mattress, the Tuft & Needle is a good option.

2. Want a great value

In addition to being budget-friendly, the Tuft & Needle mattress is also a solid mattress option, making it an exceptional value when compared to most other foam mattresses.

3. Want to be able to return the mattress for free

Buying a mattress is a big decision. Knowing you can return the mattress for free may make you more comfortable in that decision. You can return the Tuft & Needle mattress for free, so if you’re concerned you might not like your purchase, the Tuft & Needle mattress gives you the opportunity to reconsider without spending more money.

Tuft & Needle Bed

Buy the Loom & Leaf if…

1. Value eco-friendly materials

The Loom & Leaf mattress uses eco-friendly materials, like an organic cotton cover, natural thistle flame retardant, and natural foams. If sustainability is important to you, this may give the Loom & Leaf mattress might be a good choice.

2. Prefer a mattress that wasn’t compressed

Mattresses compressed for shipment may emit more off-gassing odors or take some time to regain their intended shape. The Loom & Leaf mattress isn’t compressed for shipment, so it is less likely to suffer from these issues.

3. Want more firmness options

The Loom & Leaf mattress comes in two firmness levels: Relaxed Firm and Firm. This gives you the opportunity to select your firmness, so you might find the Loom & Leaf mattress can more closely match your firmness preference.

The Tuft & Needle mattress and the Loom & Leaf mattress are both good options. The Tuft & Needle mattress provides an exceptional value, offering a low price on a quality foam mattress. The mattress offers the contouring and motion isolation associated with foam mattresses. However, the graphite and cooling gel in the Adaptive foam layer help prevent some of the heat retention often associated with foam. The Loom & Leaf mattress comes in at a higher price point, but its use of eco-friendly materials and its two firmness options can make it an appealing choice. Both the Tuft & Needle mattress and the Loom & Leaf mattress offer some clear advantages. Ultimately, the best mattress is the one that best suits your unique needs and preferences.


Mattress Construction Comparison

Tuft & Needle

Many all-foam mattresses use several layers of foam to promote a comfortable night’s sleep. However, the Tuft & Needle mattress deviates from this norm. Instead, the Tuft & Needle uses just two layers of foam. The idea behind this practice is that extra layers increase a mattress’s cost without providing a better night’s sleep. Tuft & Needle aims to provide a more affordable, but just as comfortable option with two layers of quality foam in a 10-inch tall mattress.

The mattress’s top layer uses T&N Adaptive foam, which is designed to provide pressure relief without being excessively soft. This foam is intended to offer the best features memory foam and latex while being both cool and responsive. This layer uses foam with a density of about 2.8 PCF (pounds per cubic foot). High-density foam like this is usually more durable than lower density foam.

The Tuft & Needle mattress’s foam base layer provides additional support. This layer uses poly-foam with a density of around 1.8 PCF. The mattress uses a quick-dry cover composed of micro polyamide and polyester to promote a cooler night’s sleep. 

Tuft & Needle Mattress Construction

Loom & Leaf

The Loom & Leaf mattress uses multiple foam layers for comfort, support, and breathability. While the mattress is around 12 inches high, this can vary slightly between mattresses due to production and shipping factors.

The mattress’s top layer is composed of 2 inches of 4 PCF proprietary Spinal Zone Gel designed to provide lumbar support. This layer is infused with cooling gel to promote a cool, comfortable night’s sleep while supporting your lumbar region.

The next layer uses 2.5 inches of high-density 5 PCF premium memory foam that promotes a cool night’s sleep. The support layer offers additional contouring for extra comfort through multiple layers of support foam, including 5.5 inches of 1.8 PCF polyfoam and 2 inches of 1.6 PCF polyfoam. The cover is composed of quilted organic cotton that is pulled and set in place by hand.

Firmness Comparison

Mattress firmness is one of the key features that can determine how comfortable a mattress feels to you. Firmness refers to how hard or soft a mattress feels, and to how well it keeps the sleeper’s spine in alignment. To quantify firmness, firmness levels are often rated on a 10-point scale, with 1 assigned to ultra-soft mattresses and 10 referring to the hardest possible mattress.

Mattress firmness is determined by a mattress’s materials and construction. Some materials, like memory foam, have a reputation for being softer. However, construction also plays a major role in firmness. Softer materials like memory foam can often be layered to craft a firmer mattress.

Firmness is a personal preference. However, medium-firm is a mid-range option that is acceptable to most sleepers. Weight can also affect firmness preferences. Sleepers who weigh less than 130 pounds might need a softer mattress in order to sink in. Similarly, sleepers who weigh over 230 pounds may require a firmer mattress to prevent excessive sinking.

The Tuft & Needle mattress rates at about a 6.5 on the firmness scale, making it a medium-firm mattress. This is an appropriate mid-range firmness that most sleepers will find acceptable. However, if you prefer a plush mattress or weigh under 130 pounds, the Tuft & Needle mattress may be too firm.

The Loom & Leaf offers two firmness options: Relaxed Firm and Firm. The Relaxed Firm mattress is about 5.5 on the firmness scale, making it a mid-range, medium-firm option. The Firm comes in at about an 8, so it is a truly firm mattress. The Relaxed Firm is appropriate for the average sleeper, while the Firm mattress can accommodate sleepers who prefer a firmer sleep surface or who weigh over 230 pounds.

Sleep Experience

Sleep experience takes into account several factors that contribute to your mattress experience. These factors can affect your comfort and the quality of your sleep. When purchasing a mattress, it is important to consider how it performs in key areas, like temperature control, motion transfer, responsiveness, resilience and bounce, edge support, and off-gassing. Below, we’ll discuss you how the Tuft & Needle mattress and the Loom & Leaf mattress compare.

Temperature Control

Overheating can lead to an uncomfortable, sweaty night’s sleep. This can occur if a mattress lacks airflow or retains heat. If you tend to sleep hot, temperature control may be an important factor when choosing the right mattress for you.

The Tuft & Needle mattress is fairly firm, so it doesn’t contour too closely to the body and trap your heat. Additionally, the Tuft & Needle mattress offers several key features that offer good temperature control. The top layer is composed of proprietary Adaptive foam, which wicks away body heat with graphite and cooling gel. The micro polyamide and polyester mattress cover is designed to dry quickly, which can also help keep you cooler.

Loom & Leaf uses a layer of Spinal Zone Gel that offers lumbar support while providing cooling properties. However, some owners still feel the mattress retains heat.

If you’re concerned about overheating, the Tuft & Needle mattress may have an edge over the Loom & Leaf.

Motion Transfer

Motion transfer occurs when one partner moves and that motion carries over to the other side of the mattress. If you sleep with a partner, motion transfer could interrupt your sleep, so you may prefer a mattress that offers greater motion isolation. The Tuft & Needle and the Loom & Leaf are both foam mattresses, so they’re good at isolating motion. However, the Loom & Leaf earns truly exceptional customer ratings in this area.


Responsiveness is how a mattress adjusts to the weight of your body parts to provide appropriate cushioning, promoting proper alignment. A responsive mattress will allow your wider, heavier body parts, like your hips, to sink in.

The Tuft & Needle mattress has an Adaptive foam layer that is designed to offer pressure relief while preventing you from sinking in too deeply. Similarly, the Loom & Leaf’s layer of proprietary Spinal Zone Gel is designed to provide ideal lumbar support to promote proper alignment. Either mattress could be a good option for customers looking for responsiveness.

Resilience and Bounce

Resilience refers to how quickly a material like foam regains its shape. “Bounce” occurs when the material regains its shape quickly. Resilience and bounce are important factors when deciding on a mattress because they can make it easier to engage in sexual activity and change position during the night. The Tuft & Needle mattress’s Adaptive foam layer aims to replicate some of the benefits of latex, like resilience and bounce. However, the Loom & Leaf mattress’s foam layers are designed more for contouring and support, so they may provide less resilience and bounce.

Edge Support

Edge support is whether or not a mattress offers reinforced edges. If a mattress has strong edge support, you can sit or sleep close to the edge of the bed without much sinking. As with most all-foam beds, the Tuft & Needle and Loom & Leaf mattresses lack reinforced edges, so you may feel the foam sink when you’re near the edge of the bed.

Off-gassing and Smell

New foam mattresses traditionally emit an odor. This odor should go away within a few days if left in a well-ventilated room. Since they are both foam mattresses, the Tuft & Needle mattress and the Loom & Leaf mattress may come with a faint odor when they are first unpackaged. However, since the Loom & Leaf mattress is not compressed for shipment, it may air out more quickly.


Shipping, Trial, Warranty, and Returns

Knowing a mattress company’s policies can help you ensure your needs are met. Policies vary on shipping, mattress removal, sleep trials, returns, and warranties. Tuft & Needle and Loom & Leaf share similar policies, but there are also some key differences.

Tuft & NeedleLoom & Leaf
Delivery feeFreeFree
How is it shipped?Bed-in-a-boxWhite glove delivery
Old mattress removal?NoYes
Sleep trial length100 nights120 nights
Return cost and processNo cost; company picks up$99
Warranty length10 years15 years

Prices, Sizes, and Value

Price can play a big role in your mattress purchase. Your budget may be limited, or you may want to make sure you get the best value for your money. The following table compares the Tuft & Needle mattress and the Loom & Leaf mattress prices.

Mattress Size Tuft & Needle Loom & Leaf
Twin XL$395$1,149
California King$750$1,999

Tuft & Needle mattresses and Loom & Leaf mattresses vary dramatically in price. The Tuft & Needle mattress is significantly cheaper, making it an exceptional value for a foam mattress.

While the price of the Loom & Leaf mattress may seem dramatically high by comparison to the Tuft & Needle mattress, the Loom & Leaf aims to compete with a different class of mattresses. The Loom & Leaf website compares the mattress to the TEMPUR-Cloud Luxe Breeze. Since a queen size TEMPUR-Cloud Luxe Breeze retails for over $4,000, the Loom & Leaf mattress may offer a good value by comparison.


See how the Tuft & Needle compares to other mattresses: