Tuft & Needle vs. Saatva Mattress Comparison

While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about our affiliate program here.

Saatva and Tuft & Needle are two of the most popular online mattress companies. Both firms offer high-quality mattresses at affordable prices, and both sell directly to consumers over the internet.

Tuft & Needle has been in business since 2012. They offer two main mattress models, with their flagship Tuft & Needle mattress and the luxury Mint mattress. This article will focus on the classic T&N model, which is a medium-firm, all-foam mattress. You can learn more in our Tuft & Needle mattress review.

Saatva has been in operation since 2011. They offer their flagship Saatva mattress in 3 firmness levels: Luxury Firm, Plush Soft, and Firm, as well as multiple thickness levels. Saatva also offers other mattresses, but this page focuses on the flagship Saatva model. Find out more in our Saatva mattress review.

While each mattress differs in construction and feel, both have scored similarly in comfort and performance tests. This page breaks down the specs of  the Tuft & Needle vs Saatva to help you learn more about each mattress.

Mattress Construction Comparison

Tuft & Needle

The Tuft & Needle mattress is a 10-inch all-foam mattress. It features two main components: the support core consisting of 7 inches of 1.8 PCF polyfoam, and the comfort layer consisting of 3 inches 2.8 PCF polyfoam. The cover is made of a blend of rayon and polyester.

The construction of the Tuft & Needle mattress creates a “medium-firm” feel, which is about a 6.5 out of 10 on the firmness scale. Only one firmness level is available from Tuft & Needle. The foam construction does a great job of minimizing motion transfer from sleep partners, and the bed is very quiet when bearing weight.

The moderate-density foams and average thickness of this mattress make it exceptionally lightweight. A Queen mattress weighs just 72 pounds, making moving a Tuft & Needle bed much easier than most mattresses.

Puffy mattress layers construction

 

Saatva

The Saatva has a more complex construction than the Tuft & Needle. It’s a hybrid bed, meaning it uses both foam and coils. The bed’s design features polyfoam, memory foam, two separate coil layers, and a foam-padded Euro-top.

The pocketed coils used in the Saatva help to reinforce the bed, improving its longevity and support. They also improve airflow, which helps keep the mattress cool on warm summer nights. The foam layers are added to promote comfort, while also improving motion isolation. In short, the Saatva aims to combine the positive features of traditional innerspring mattresses with the benefits of memory foam beds - and the result is a very comfortable, supportive and durable mattress!

The Saatva mattress also comes in several different variations. It’s available in a thickness of 11.5 or 14.5 inches. Firmness levels of 4, 6, and 7.5 out of 10 are all available. This means that the construction of the mattress will differ based on which specific model you choose.

Due to its hybrid design and greater thickness, the Saatva is quite a bit heavier than the Tuft & Needle. Saatva mattresses weigh between 110 and 120 lbs, depending on the model selected.

Leesa Mattress Construction

Firmness Comparison

Firmness is a measurement of how firm or soft a mattress feels when you lay down on it. There is no universal scale used to measure firmness, but SleepHelp uses a proprietary scale of 1-10, with 1 being the softest and 10 the firmest. We base our ratings off of our own test results from hand-testing mattresses, as well as data available from the manufacturer.

Various factors can influence how firm a mattress feels. Material selection and the density of foams used are some of the biggest factors. The thickness of the various layers, as well as the mattress itself, also influence firmness.

The Tuft & Needle mattress is a solid medium-firm, at a 6.5/10 rating on our firmness scale. There is only one firmness level available on the flagship Tuft & Needle mattress.

The Saatva has several options available. It can be purchased in a medium-soft (4/10), medium-firm (6/10), and firm (7.5/10). This gives shoppers more variety to choose from. Other than the firmness levels and thickness of each variety, all the Saatva models are the same.

Keep in mind that firmness is somewhat subjective. Every sleeper likes a different firmness level, and on top of that, a bed that feels like a firm to one person may feel more like a medium-firm to another.

Sleep Experience

Quality, restful sleep is vital to living a good life - and a comfortable mattress is vital to a good night’s sleep. The overall sleep experience of the mattress you choose will greatly influence the quality of your sleep. There are many factors that contribute to sleep experience. Below, find out what to look for in some of the most important aspects of the mattress search.

Temperature Control

Temperature control refers to the bed’s ability to maintain a comfortable sleeping temperature throughout the night. In most cases, this means not getting too hot for comfort. Some memory foam mattresses tend to trap body heat, creating a sweaty and uncomfortable sleeping experience. So, it’s important to keep temperature control in mind when shopping for a mattress.

Both the Saatva and the Tuft & Needle mattress perform fairly well in terms of temperature neutrality. The Saatva, in particular, has very good temperature control, as it has innerspring coils that help to improve airflow.

The Tuft & Needle is an all-foam mattress, so it does sleep a bit warmer than the Saatva. A few reviewers mentioned issues with excessive heat on the Tuft & Needle mattress, but most were happy with its performance.

If you live in a very warm climate or just tend to sleep hot, the Saatva may be a better choice.

Motion Transfer

Motion transfer refers to the amount of movement in the bed when a sleeper moves or gets up. This is an important factor for those who sleep with a partner, as the nighttime movements of one partner can easily cause the other partner to wake.

Both mattresses isolate motion fairly well, although this is one area where the Tuft & Needle outperforms the Saatva. The Tuft & Needle is an all-foam mattress, which tends to absorb most motion. 

The Saatva, being an innerspring mattress, does not absorb motion quite as well. If you sleep with a partner, it’s likely that you will notice their movements more on the Saatva, compared to the Tuft & Needle. 

If you sleep with a partner and are a light sleeper, you may want to consider the Tuft & Needle over the Saatva.

Responsiveness

Responsiveness refers to how the mattress reacts when you lay on it, and how it contours to your body. A more responsive mattress will more closely contour to the shape of your body, which generally improves comfort and support. Responsive beds can also help to reduce pain and provide pressure relief to problem areas like the lower back and neck. Responsiveness is a very important factor for just about every sleeper.

The Tuft & Needle mattress is very responsive and offers above-average pressure relief. It stacks up well against the competition and is overall a very responsive and comfortable mattress.

The Saatva has good responsiveness, but lags behind the Tuft & Needle. The coil construction of the Saatva, mixed with layers of foam, creates a moderately responsive mattress. In general, all-foam beds are considered the most responsive. If you are someone who prefers the sinking-in feeling of memory foam, Tuft & Needle may be a better option.

Resilience and Bounce

Bounce is the amount of immediate response to motion. Resilience is the ability of the mattress to keep its shape over time, and not break sag under the pressure of bodyweight. Resilience is an important factor in the overall durability of the mattress, while bounce is less important but still something to consider. 

The Saatva has a bit more bounce to it, due to the innerspring coils. It may be better for sex and easily repositioning during sleep than the Tuft & Needle.

In terms of resilience and durability, both mattresses score well. Both the Saatva and the Tuft & Needle are designed to last for 6-7 years under regular use, which is about average. Since both models are fairly new to the market, there is not much real-life data on the longevity of these beds. However, reviews from previous customers have reported minimal sagging over time on both mattresses. 

It’s possible that the Saatva will last longer than the Tuft & Needle, due to its thicker and more dense construction. Hybrid mattresses like the Saatva also tend to last longer than all-foam.

Edge Support

Edge support is a measure of how well the edges of the mattress hold up to pressure. This is mostly relevant when sitting on the edge of the bed, and for side-sleepers who frequently find themselves sleeping towards the edge of the mattress. 

The Saatva performs very well in terms of edge support, as innerspring mattresses typically do. It offers a consistent sleep surface, whether you’re sleeping near the edge or right in the middle.

The Tuft & Needle mattress does not perform as well. All-foam beds typically don’t have great edge support, and the Tuft & Needle is no exception. Sinkage may occur along the edges when you sit or sleep on or near the edge.

Off-gassing and Smell

Off-gassing refers to a period during which the mattress will release some smell after being unpacked. This is a normal process, and typically the smell dissipates within a few days.

Both mattresses have some off-gassing from their various polyfoam/memory foam layers. However, the smell should dissipate within 3 to 5 days. Both the Tuft & Needle and the Saatva have a similar amount of off-gassing.

Shipping, Trial, Warranty, and Returns

The comfort and performance of mattresses are most important, but you should also consider other factors related to the purchase. Below, find a table comparing Tuft & Needle vs Saatva in terms of their warranties, shipping costs, return policies and more.

Tuft & Needle Saatva
Delivery fee Free shipping Free shipping
How is it shipped? Bed-in-a-box Uncompressed
Old mattress removal? Not available Yes, free removal of old mattress
Sleep trial length 100 nights 120 nights
Return cost and process Free returns within 100 days of delivery. The mattress will be picked up and donated to a local charity. Returns allowed within 120 days of delivery. A $99 transportation fee will be charged to the customer.
Warranty length 10-year limited warranty 15-year limited warranty

Prices, Sizes, and Value

The price of a mattress will be a factor for most people. Ideally, you want to strike a balance between getting the best quality possible, without spending a fortune.

Mattress Size Tuft & Needle Saatva
Twin $350 $599
Twin XL $395 $749
Full $495 $999
Queen $595 $1,099
King $750 $1,499
California King $750 $1,499

As you can see, the Tuft & Needle mattress is quite a bit cheaper than the Saatva. This is to be expected, as foam beds are almost always cheaper than hybrid and innerspring beds like the Saatva.

Because the Saatva is nearly twice as expensive for some sizes, the price will likely be a big consideration for anyone comparing the Tuft & Needle mattress vs Saatva.

Is the Saatva worth the extra expense? That depends. The Saatva has better edge support, better cooling, and a more luxurious feel. It will also likely last longer than the Tuft & Needle.

On the other hand, the Tuft & Needle mattress is excellent, especially at its low price-point. Both are excellent choices - if you’re still on the fence, check the recap below.

Tuft & Needle vs. Saatva Mattress - Which One Should You Buy

The detailed comparison of Saatva vs. Tuft & Needle provides a lot of information - but it can still be tricky to make your selection. Below you will find some highlighted differentiators between these two excellent mattresses.

The Tuft & Needle is a great all-foam, closely contouring and budget-friendly mattress. The Saatva is a supportive and comfortable taste of luxury at an affordable price.

Ultimately, either of these mattresses would be a fantastic choice. The “best” option for you depends on your personal preferences and budget. But don’t worry - you really can’t go wrong with either!

Buy the Tuft & Needle mattress if you:

1. Want a high-quality, low cost bed

The Tuft & Needle is around half the price of the Saatva for some sizes. If you’re bargain-hunting, it’s tough to beat the value of Tuft & Needle.

2. Prefer a closely conforming mattress

The Tuft & Needle mattress does a great job of closely conforming to your body, reducing pressure on problem areas. If you prefer a very close feel, you may sleep better on the Tuft & Needle over the Saatva.

3. Sleep with a partner

If you or your partner are light sleepers, you will appreciate the Tuft & Needle's excellent motion isolation.

 

Buy the Saatva mattress if you:

1. Tend to sleep hot

If you are someone who sleeps hot, or you live in a warm climate, the Saatva is a better choice. The Saatva has excellent temperature control, while the Tuft & Needle sleeps a bit warmer.

2. Want a choice of firmness levels

The Saatva is available in a range of firmness levels, so you can customize it to your preferences. Tuft & Needle only offers one option.

3. Want a luxury mattress at a fair price

The Saatva is truly a luxury bed - with the price tag of an average mattress. If you have it in your budget, the Saatva is an excellent bed at a fair price.